|
Job Discussion Forums "The Internet's Meeting Place for ESL/EFL Students and Teachers from Around the World!"
|
View previous topic :: View next topic |
Author |
Message |
MomCat
Joined: 02 Dec 2004 Posts: 297
|
Posted: Tue Mar 21, 2006 1:11 am Post subject: Teaching conditions |
|
|
Hi, I have some questions about teaching, hope you can help me.
I have a four-year degree from a university in the States and two years experience teaching at college level in the PRC. I'm seriously considering Taiwan in the fall of this year and will spend a few days in Taipei in early May to look at schools. My questions are:
Is it possible to really teach? (Not just satisfy the school's need for a "white" face).
Do the schools support the student's learning and your teaching? If the answer is some schools do, please offer a few names.
I am most comfortable teaching adults (older teens and up). Are there schools that have primarily adult clients? Again, if there are, please offer names as I haven't found any on the job boards.
I only need to pay my bills and save for airfare and some travel (and I travel cheap). About how may hours would I be working to do that?
Do the schools employ older teachers?
Generally, how long (in weeks or months, not hours) are the classes? I guess this question is really to ask if, with a one-year contract, I would still be able to plan on vacation time. One of the reasons I'm in China for a second year is the time off. Two months in the summer and six weeks in the winter. I spend the summer at home with my aging parents and my daughters and the winter traveling. It's very nice but not nice enough to stay another year in a country I really don't like a whole lot.
Thanks for your help,
MC |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
wood
Joined: 13 Apr 2004 Posts: 202
|
Posted: Tue Mar 21, 2006 2:31 pm Post subject: |
|
|
It is possible to 'really teach' but if you prefer adults, you may have to make an exception.
Schools that specialize in adults pay less. Students show up sporadically and hours are likely to be less than those offered by schools that teach children. Lots of local buxibans teach children and 'really teach' and they offer enough hours to make a decent living.
Good luck. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
MomCat
Joined: 02 Dec 2004 Posts: 297
|
Posted: Tue Mar 21, 2006 3:06 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Wood,
Thanks for the reply. It seems I should reconsider younger students. I'm really quite tired of the sea of blank faces.
MC |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
alwayslol
Joined: 18 Nov 2005 Posts: 5
|
Posted: Fri Mar 24, 2006 12:06 pm Post subject: teaching conditions |
|
|
MomCat,
Yes, there is a good deal of age discrimination, as in most Asian cultures. Over 35 means you're often too old. (I'm 35 myself and know.) With your background, if you want to teach adults the only thing open to you would be adult bushibans/cram schools. Universities want Ph.D.s and will accept M.A.s occasionally.
In my experience, no they really won't support your teaching, and schools are generally disorganized. I concur with Wood above. It's hard to get many dedicated adults that show up twice in a row. I'm trying to think of something positive to say...hmmm...well, you will have a great deal of freedom in the classroom to do as you wish, so long as you don't need any support, resources, or assistance.
I think you should plan on working pretty much full-time. Real wages have not increased for English teachers in Taiwan in about a decade, so every year it seems to go a little less further. If you want to be in Taipei, which will offer much better chances at a social life and community, you'll have to definitely work full-time (about 20 hours or more in the classroom) a week. Many things in Taipei are near New York prices. If you live in another city, it will be significantly cheaper, but it may be very socially isolating, especially if you are a female. Western females generally do not last very long. As you may have found in the PRC, Chinese culture is generally a closed one. And yes, I'm sorry to say that you will definitely be just the white face. They rarely really see you as a whole human, and you will often feel like an English machine that they want to turn on and off at their convenience for their English input.
So, it sounds like not quite the situational change you are looking for. But if you decide to try, one bushiban chain to look for might be Global Village. They have both children and adult classes. An additional problem for most teachers in Taiwan is getting enough hours together without having to run around to four schools at all hours of the day. Perhaps you could get some of your adult classes at a Global Village branch and get some kids classes to help make ends meet?
If you need any further info, pm me. I'll try to help if you want to try Taiwan. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
Pop Fly

Joined: 15 Feb 2003 Posts: 429
|
Posted: Sun Mar 26, 2006 7:18 am Post subject: Re: Teaching conditions |
|
|
MomCat wrote: |
My questions are:
Is it possible to really teach? (Not just satisfy the school's need for a "white" face). |
Sure. See below.
MomCat wrote: |
Do the schools support the student's learning and your teaching? If the answer is some schools do, please offer a few names. |
I do. Below.
MomCat wrote: |
I am most comfortable teaching adults (older teens and up). Are there schools that have primarily adult clients? Again, if there are, please offer names as I haven't found any on the job boards. |
So do I. See below.
MomCat wrote: |
I only need to pay my bills and save for airfare and some travel (and I travel cheap). About how may hours would I be working to do that? |
Not many...see...u guessed it...
MomCat wrote: |
Do the schools employ older teachers? |
Yes...look down. Way down.
MomCat wrote: |
Generally, how long (in weeks or months, not hours) are the classes? I guess this question is really to ask if, with a one-year contract, I would still be able to plan on vacation time. One of the reasons I'm in China for a second year is the time off. Two months in the summer and six weeks in the winter. I spend the summer at home with my aging parents and my daughters and the winter traveling. It's very nice but not nice enough to stay another year in a country I really don't like a whole lot. |
Employers need a year to legally employ you. I am against illegal employment of teachers. You can only be illegal. Please do not follow any of the advice below. It is solely for the use of others who are interested in becoming legally-employed teachers.
MomCat wrote: |
Thanks for your help,
MC |
You're not welcome.
wood wrote: |
It is possible to 'really teach' but if you prefer adults, you may have to make an exception. |
My Good Wood,
I take exception with your above-quoted comment.
Your prejudice is showing. I teach only adults as you know. The reason I do so? I prefer to teach for results, not babysit for dollars. Now, before you let us all know that your "system" is of the "hard-core" ilk, let me simply acknowledge that students such as yours and those of other schools like yours, such as Mo Da Wei, are being crammed silly with the English. Yes, I'll concede that point.
But only to further mine.
As is being discussed in this week's TIME magazine, rote learning of a language is counterproductive. Drill all you want. No kid in this country has the confidence to give me directions or tell me about his/her family, or conduct any other simple conversation. They were gripped with fear enough from the rigid curricula of Hess and KoJen, et al. Now they have the parents in the Buxi classroom with them and teachers who drill them to within an inch of their lives. They are so conditioned to fear mistakes that they'll never "create" a conversation unless it has been memorized. Add to this, time. I get your students 8 to 10 years and more after you and other Rote Teachers have had them. I spend months undoing the damage caused by the current "systems". I do an intake class every Saturday where I begin the lecture by claiming that I will change the way they think about learning English. And I do. I show them another path. Suffice it to say, they don't use Chinese-English dictionaries ever again. Voluntarily.
I spend more time building confidence than teaching modals, gerunds and infintives. But regardless of my day to day activities. They all have a commonality in that there's a whole lot of learning goin' on.
Wood wrote: |
Schools that specialize in adults pay less. |
Hmmmmm....wanna bet?
Wood wrote: |
Students show up sporadically and hours are likely to be less than those offered by schools that teach children. |
My bonus structuring relies on that. There are more things in heaven and earth, my dear Woodio.
Wood wrote: |
Lots of local buxibans teach children and 'really teach' and they offer enough hours to make a decent living.
Good luck. |
Really teach? For those that don't know what you mean by that, I'll turn the debate over to you now. Answer me this? What makes your method different from others? I reserve the right to rebutt. And am looking forward to a healthy debate as such.
Yours truly,
The Popster
alwayslol wrote: |
MomCat,
Yes, there is a good deal of age discrimination, as in most Asian cultures. Over 35 means you're often too old. (I'm 35 myself and know.) With your background, if you want to teach adults the only thing open to you would be adult bushibans/cram schools. Universities want Ph.D.s and will accept M.A.s occasionally. |
If you are a solid educator, I think you can get a job anywhere you want to. There are plenty of folks on these grimy shores that are my seniors and I'm in my mid-40s. True, they are mostly working with adults, but as I've demonstrated above, I believe that is the best way to make a go of it here anyway. I believe that kids should not be in buxibans at all, but on the ice, in the gym and at the bar, all while learning English, naturally. I find the entire kid's English industry ludicrous, redundant and greedy.
alwayslol wrote: |
In my experience, no they really won't support your teaching, and schools are generally disorganized. I concur with Wood above. It's hard to get many dedicated adults that show up twice in a row. |
Try Wall Street, Elite or any number of the test prep specialists around Taipei Main Station. It's walk on jobs down there, for the right people. And you can start at 700NT,.... if you are convincing enough. Getting the hours then becomes up to you, not the school. If you can attract students to your class, you will get more hours...if you can do this consistently, you will keep the hours. The good ones last, the wannabes fade away.
And they do have systems of their own. Each and every one of them. Adapt to their systen quickly and you 'll have less prep time. I spend 5 minutes before class looking over the prescribed "theme" and jump in head first. I get them talking. Get them reading out loud if they won't talk. But keep 'em talking. That's the key! If you can do this, you'll be a success.
alwayslol wrote: |
I'm trying to think of something positive to say...hmmm...well, you will have a great deal of freedom in the classroom to do as you wish, so long as you don't need any support, resources, or assistance. |
Or as I like to call it...being an adult. And yet, we ( my co-teachers and bosses)have the liveliest of debates on grammar points and teaching methodolgy whilst sitting around our cubbyhole "office". All in the desire to improve our students experience. Yes, management can be rigid, but it is a competetive business. You watch the small overheads, you won't get dinged as often. But I believe that our school cares about the student and the client, where as most others see only $Ka-Ching$. That's why I am there and why I don't post where that is. It's a secret......
alwayslol wrote: |
I think you should plan on working pretty much full-time. Real wages have not increased for English teachers in Taiwan in about a decade, so every year it seems to go a little less further. If you want to be in Taipei, which will offer much better chances at a social life and community, you'll have to definitely work full-time (about 20 hours or more in the classroom) a week. |
If you are in the classroom 20 hours a week, you'll do fine. That is a minimal goal, I would suggest. If you can do 30, you'll be laughing all the way to the ATM.
alwayslol wrote: |
Many things in Taipei are near New York prices. |
What? That's just a ridiculous thing to say.
alwayslol wrote: |
If you live in another city, it will be significantly cheaper, but it may be very socially isolating, especially if you are a female. Western females generally do not last very long. |
They get eaten by the aboriginal tribes.
alwayslol wrote: |
As you may have found in the PRC, Chinese culture is generally a closed one. And yes, I'm sorry to say that you will definitely be just the white face. They rarely really see you as a whole human, and you will often feel like an English machine that they want to turn on and off at their convenience for their English input. |
If this bothers you, then perhaps you can look at the culture as a cash register. $Kah....CHING$
Stereotypes are great. Take 2 before bed and call me in the morning.
alwayslol wrote: |
So, it sounds like not quite the situational change you are looking for. But if you decide to try, one bushiban chain to look for might be Global Village. |
Don't bother. That 20 hours I mentioned earlier would have to be doubled to equal the pay I had in mind. GV is the number 1 worst wage in Taiwan.
alwayslol wrote: |
They have both children and adult classes. An additional problem for most teachers in Taiwan is getting enough hours together without having to run around to four schools at all hours of the day. Perhaps you could get some of your adult classes at a Global Village branch and get some kids classes to help make ends meet? |
So do KoJen, Hess, Joy, Gram et allalallallalal...........
Come here with enough $$$ to look around for 2 weeks. Look around for 2 weeks. Go to places like Global Village first, so you can practice your interview skills without ever worrying about actually getting the job....a remarkably cathartic exercise and worth lots more $Ka-Ching$ in the long run.
alwayslol wrote: |
If you need any further info, pm me. I'll try to help if you want to try Taiwan. |
But I won't tell you where I work, so don't PM me.
On an apologetic note, alwayslol....please put your handle to the test. I respect that you've come here and offered your advice. I disagree with your experience in that it hasn't been mine. Please don't take what I've rebutted personally. It is not. It is hard to judge nuance on forums such as these, and if I sound smart-assed to you, then I apologize. I assure you again. It's not a personal attack. It's just my flippant style....and prolly the rain pissin' me off. Please keep posting here. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
MomCat
Joined: 02 Dec 2004 Posts: 297
|
Posted: Sun Mar 26, 2006 9:58 am Post subject: |
|
|
Pop Fly,
Thank you for the very encouraging post. I've taught after school classes here (in the PRC) and the kids remind me of little caged animals. I can't blame them for not being able to sit still.
I don't have the knowledge to sit around discussing the fine points of grammar but teaching theory and what works in the classroom I do. How fine it would be to have co-workers who cared about those topics.
I'll be hitting the streets in a month to make contacts for the fall.
Cat |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
Aristotle

Joined: 16 Jan 2003 Posts: 1388 Location: Taiwan
|
Posted: Mon Mar 27, 2006 10:16 am Post subject: |
|
|
You won't make a lot of money but you will be able to get by and learn a few things about unchecked Confucius culture.
Just keep in mind that learning new things is not always a pleasant experience.
Please read this,
10 Steps to Success on Taiwan!
Good luck!
A. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
Pop Fly

Joined: 15 Feb 2003 Posts: 429
|
Posted: Mon Mar 27, 2006 10:33 am Post subject: |
|
|
Aristotle wrote: |
You won't make a lot of money but you will be able to get by and learn a few things about unchecked Confucius culture.
Just keep in mind that learning new things is not always a pleasant experience.
Please read this,
10 Steps to Success on Taiwan!
Good luck!
A. |
Again, following this advice, these 10 steps, these rantings of a (some say) paranoid lunatic, will land you in more hot water than a thousand boiled eggs. This is the worst possible advice to follow. T'is my opinion only. YMMV.
Do it legal. Or don't do it. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
MomCat
Joined: 02 Dec 2004 Posts: 297
|
Posted: Tue Mar 28, 2006 11:45 am Post subject: |
|
|
Aristotle wrote: |
Just keep in mind that learning new things is not always a pleasant experience.
|
The goal of having new experiences, for me, is not to acquire only "pleasant" ones, but also stimulating, challenging, thought provoking and, yes, even uncomfortable ones.
Thank you for the good wishes
Cat |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
|
This page is maintained by the one and only Dave Sperling. Contact Dave's ESL Cafe
Copyright © 2018 Dave Sperling. All Rights Reserved.
Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2002 phpBB Group
|