|
Job Discussion Forums "The Internet's Meeting Place for ESL/EFL Students and Teachers from Around the World!"
|
View previous topic :: View next topic |
Author |
Message |
tw
Joined: 04 Jun 2005 Posts: 3898
|
Posted: Sun Oct 07, 2007 5:31 am Post subject: Do international schools hire native speakers only? |
|
|
One of my colleagues is a licensed teacher in his home country. He is not a native English speaker but English is commonly spoken in his country. The question here is: can he make the big money, i.e. 10,000+ RMB/month as licensed teachers from USA/Canada/Australia/UK/New Zealand can at an international school, or do those schools only hire licensed teachers from countries of which the students will be studying in? |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
johnchina
Joined: 24 Apr 2006 Posts: 816
|
Posted: Sun Oct 07, 2007 2:39 pm Post subject: none |
|
|
Yes, he might be able to get a job. I know of one similar person in Beijing working at an international school. I imagine that it will be more difficult for him though. Many international schools have a hard time finding the right people for maths and science, so if that's his background ... |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
danswayne
Joined: 23 Apr 2006 Posts: 237
|
Posted: Sun Oct 07, 2007 5:20 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Real international K - 12 schools have different hiring criteria than the average Uni or Language Mill. I returned to China to teach in one, but got burned out on real teaching in Florida so now I have a much easier job running my own company. Anyway to answer your question yes he should be able to get a job with a good school if he meets their qualifications. There is usually many more candidates for these positions than there are jobs to be filled so it is tougher. He needs to go to some of the job fairs that are held around the world. Tieonline . com is a good company that advertises for the schools. Also Ciss and something along the line of iss are two of the biggest recruiting agencies for the schools. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
jammish

Joined: 17 Nov 2005 Posts: 1704
|
Posted: Sun Oct 07, 2007 10:10 pm Post subject: |
|
|
I think you will find that International schools pay substantially more than 10,000 a month |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
jammish

Joined: 17 Nov 2005 Posts: 1704
|
Posted: Sun Oct 07, 2007 10:25 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Re. the OP's question. I'm really not sure. I teach ESL at an International School (which pays just over the 10,000 RMB mentioned). I'm British (It's a canadian school) and they accept me because I'm only teaching ESL, but apparently, even if I do get my UK PGCE, I still couldn't get a job as a subject teacher there, because I would have to be not just qualified in Canada, but qualified to teach in British Columbia (even a qualified teacher from other parts of Canada couldn't work there!) |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
kungfucowboy83
Joined: 25 Jan 2006 Posts: 479
|
Posted: Mon Oct 08, 2007 12:12 am Post subject: |
|
|
it greatly varries on the school but non-native speakers with teaching certification in their home country and masters degrees can be hired in some, especially the lower end international schools. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
SnoopBot
Joined: 21 Jun 2007 Posts: 740 Location: USA
|
Posted: Mon Oct 08, 2007 1:06 am Post subject: |
|
|
Some of these places will hire people to form a "diversity" pool. However, teaching certifications are very different across the spectrum. The Real International schools are based on the Big 5 education system.
NZ, AUS, USA, CA, UK
If you are not certified from one of these places it is much harder to get.
Certain subjects have a shortage, like Calculus and Physics. (Maybe easier to get placed if a background in this area)
The level taught is not very difficult, but for their IB accreditation but you must have some paper to show. (You don't need to have a PhD)
2nd tier International schools will hire non-native speakers as long as their English speaking level is very high without accent problems.
In general terms to answer the question of the OP. NO to the big bucks Beijing International schools that pay 30,000 RMB a month.
If international schools are going to hire non-native speakers, why not hire qualified western educated returning Chinese with good English speaking ability. (And pay low)
To justify the high tuition that they charge, having only the Big 5 teaching staff is considered a major SELLING POINT. This indicates the teachers are part of the Western Education system and Ding and Ling are going to attend Harvard or Oxford after they graduate from a IB school.
Therefore, they are looking for teachers from the big 5.
International schools usually hire from the same country the top management came from. (Example: UK headmaster = most teachers are from the UK and teaching is based on the British System)
Best chance is to look at 2nd tier international schools that are located outside of Beijing or Shanghai.
Most of these are not real International schools and salaries are much lower, but often much higher than the typical ESOL jobs.
I'll give you an example of comparison.
A few years back I was going to work for a well-known International School.
Teaching Physics at 12,000 RMB a month 40 hours a week.
No housing because I was married, they had teacher shared rooms???(Big turn off but common at 2nd tier schools)
Rent would be at least 3000-4000 RMB a month in that area (I would need to pay this out of pocket)
12,000 - 4000 = 8000 RMB a month after housing
I was earning more at a 6500 @ 18 hour University job and a weekend 1500 Private. 1500 X 4 weeks in a month = 6000 private + 6500 University= total 12,500 a month for 26 hours a week.
12,500 for 26 hours (privates +university w/housing)
12,000 for 40 hours (no housing except shared)
Be careful while looking at 2nd tier International Schools if the highest salary is the primary goal. You can get a higher salary if you get the better private jobs coupled with the lower hour University positions.
All less than 40 hours a week. My interest was teaching Physics, and I almost took the position even though I would take a pay cut. However, the wife wasn't too keen with the area so I didn't take the position.
Jeeesh I hope this post makes sense I'm posting tired. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
william wallace
Joined: 14 May 2003 Posts: 2869 Location: in between
|
Posted: Mon Oct 08, 2007 2:08 am Post subject: |
|
|
nil
Last edited by william wallace on Sat Nov 24, 2007 12:16 pm; edited 1 time in total |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
saint57

Joined: 10 Mar 2003 Posts: 1221 Location: Beyond the Dune Sea
|
Posted: Mon Oct 08, 2007 2:44 am Post subject: |
|
|
Quote: |
I still couldn't get a job as a subject teacher there, because I would have to be not just qualified in Canada, but qualified to teach in British Columbia (even a qualified teacher from other parts of Canada couldn't work there!)
|
I am currently certified in Ontario.
The first time I contacted them they were interested, but I past on it for my current job. I contacted them a second time and they told me that I'd have to get certified in B.C. before they would consider me. I would never do that considering I rarely see any other B.C. schools in the world. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
arioch36
Joined: 21 Jan 2003 Posts: 3589
|
Posted: Mon Oct 08, 2007 6:49 am Post subject: |
|
|
I have found that they hire who they need at the price they can get them for. I taught calc and precalc 10 hours a week last year at a school certified from Australia??? But is seemed they were really running two schools in the same building. One "certified" and one just a "language " school. I know see they were offering low wages. I know they had at least two Filipinos, all other UK CA US or Oz. The Filipinos were used in both "schools"
They had a hard time telling me what they wanted as certification. I have a teaching certificate (4 weeks training then three weeks teaching class under the eye of a certufying supervisor) T.A. experinece at my uni, multiple years here in China, and said I could show them my transcripts. They wanted some other cert. I said forget it. Then they said okay, okay, we'll check with the "home office". Oh, you are accepted I accepted, and should have asked for a lot more
Had the same experience this past spring looking at other jobs.
I guess my moral is that what kind certification or license you need, what country you need to be from.... surprise surprise depends on who else they have to teach at what salary
I am said to say... I have never seen a black teaching at an international school, But in my time, of the 20 blacks I have known well, only two were from native speaking countries, |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
malu
Joined: 22 Apr 2007 Posts: 1344 Location: Sunny Java
|
Posted: Mon Oct 08, 2007 11:27 am Post subject: |
|
|
A lot depends on which non native-English speaking country your friend comes from. I'm talking about 2nd tier 'international' schools here - never having worked for one of the big hitters myself.
EU nationals able to teach in English are in a strong position as subject teachers - especially so with IB experience. I know a few Germans working as science and humanities teachers, for example. A similarly qualified Nigerian would undoubtedly have more trouble landing the same job.
Bear in mind that there are also German, Dutch, Korean and Japanese international schools - among many others - and that all these may have the odd vacancy for teachers in the English medium.
I'm surprised that the OP considers 10k a ballpark salary in this market and I'd suggest aiming rather higher. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
waxwing
Joined: 29 Jun 2003 Posts: 719 Location: China
|
Posted: Mon Oct 08, 2007 1:29 pm Post subject: |
|
|
SnoopBot wrote: |
I'll give you an example of comparison.
A few years back I was going to work for a well-known International School.
Teaching Physics at 12,000 RMB a month 40 hours a week.
No housing because I was married, they had teacher shared rooms???(Big turn off but common at 2nd tier schools)
Rent would be at least 3000-4000 RMB a month in that area (I would need to pay this out of pocket)
12,000 - 4000 = 8000 RMB a month after housing
|
For someone qualified (i.e. back home qualified) to teach Physics, teaching IB or A-level or that kind of level (age 15-18 ) this is a terrible deal. This couldn't be an "international school" in the usually understood sense of the term.
You should be looking for no more than 20 contact hours per week and 15K + housing bare minimum - and you can get much better than that, even if not in a (real) international school.
A couple of years back an outfit offered me 5K to teach Physics (I have a PGCE in it). Nearly choked on my coffee
But, anyway, they're crying out for qualified people here.
If you're not qualified to teach it, that's a different game. It's a double edged sword; if you're sure you can do it and have relevant experience, and see it as a step on a ladder, perhaps go for it, even if the salary is weak (but good lord, not 40 hours contact!). In that case it might be better if you at least have a postgrad degree in your subject.
But be wary, because in some of these jobs there's pressure to get the exam results (and, let's face it, so there should be!), so make sure you can deliver.
That's the thing - teaching a technical subject to an international standard is not the same as teaching English to any old standard (I know because I've done both ), so you'd better be passionate about it, and if you are, you should get real qualifications. Otherwise, everyone is likely to be dissatisfied by the experience. The clowns offering <10K for this kind of work and asking you to do 40 hours are just showing they're either clueless or only in it for a (very) quick buck. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
SnoopBot
Joined: 21 Jun 2007 Posts: 740 Location: USA
|
Posted: Mon Oct 08, 2007 2:49 pm Post subject: |
|
|
waxwing wrote: |
SnoopBot wrote: |
I'll give you an example of comparison.
A few years back I was going to work for a well-known International School.
Teaching Physics at 12,000 RMB a month 40 hours a week.
No housing because I was married, they had teacher shared rooms???(Big turn off but common at 2nd tier schools)
Rent would be at least 3000-4000 RMB a month in that area (I would need to pay this out of pocket)
12,000 - 4000 = 8000 RMB a month after housing
|
For someone qualified (i.e. back home qualified) to teach Physics, teaching IB or A-level or that kind of level (age 15-18 ) this is a terrible deal. This couldn't be an "international school" in the usually understood sense of the term.
You should be looking for no more than 20 contact hours per week and 15K + housing bare minimum - and you can get much better than that, even if not in a (real) international school.
A couple of years back an outfit offered me 5K to teach Physics (I have a PGCE in it). Nearly choked on my coffee
But, anyway, they're crying out for qualified people here.
If you're not qualified to teach it, that's a different game. It's a double edged sword; if you're sure you can do it and have relevant experience, and see it as a step on a ladder, perhaps go for it, even if the salary is weak (but good lord, not 40 hours contact!). In that case it might be better if you at least have a postgrad degree in your subject.
But be wary, because in some of these jobs there's pressure to get the exam results (and, let's face it, so there should be!), so make sure you can deliver.
That's the thing - teaching a technical subject to an international standard is not the same as teaching English to any old standard (I know because I've done both ), so you'd better be passionate about it, and if you are, you should get real qualifications. Otherwise, everyone is likely to be dissatisfied by the experience. The clowns offering <10K for this kind of work and asking you to do 40 hours are just showing they're either clueless or only in it for a (very) quick buck. |
I'm not sure what they would classify as being certified. In my case my undergrad degree was EE. So I had the standard Physics track I, II, III and Calculus I-V. I also had various EE and EET courses, I was a trainer at a metrology lab teaching metrology at a standards lab.
However, I had NO USA Praxis Examination scores or certification in Physics. However, I could have easily passed them. The book that was being used was a lower-level non-calculus based physics book.
Maybe without having a teaching licenses in physics was the reason I was offered lower pay. I do have a Med Masters in Education with 2 certifications (one was TESOL).
I strongly feel they pay this salary to most teachers because the range they offered was the same range others were told (actually higher) I will state they charge 70,000 RMB a year.
I was going to build a physics lab because they lacked a good lab (very important) since I had lab experience at a type 3 calibration physics lab, I was going to make the best physics lab in China. I took this as a challenge for me.
The big bomb shell was the shared housing complex and told that If I was married I could rent a place near the school. Talking to Chinese friends of my wife and fellow teachers a place with western style outfitting would cost us at least 3000 + a month.
Now that original teaching salary just dropped lower, I would have took the position just to get out of ESOL, my interest is not in Language Arts, I've always been into Sciences. My university position was MBA based so was interesting enough to not make the big switch.
Sometimes I wonder if I made the correct choice or not. Who knows..
I do know many 2nd and 3rd tier International Schools pay from 8000-16,000 RMB a month. The top tier will pay +30,000 + with Housing allowances.
Teaching certification is difficult and a mess in my state now. If I completed a 1-year PGDE I still would not be qualified. The current rules are "Teaching Certification" from country of Birth = USA.
My state will not grant Public School licenses unless the new teacher spends a few years in a combat zone "High Demanding District."
Permanent teaching licenses are not given out now, I would be required to stay in some inner-city zone for a few years, then hope to transfer out. To retain my licenses I would be required to meet yearly "Continuous Education Credits" So if the State decides that I must take "Diversity and Multiculturalism in the classroom" and I'm teaching in China. My licenses will be cancelled if I cannot prove I am meeting the constant changing requirements to keep a valid license.
This means NO TEACHERS from my state under the new system can go abroad and keep their licenses. Teachers are stuck in the same inner-city schools for years to fill the teaching shortages. The days of doing a runner from a poor school district to a more upscale one is over.
If more US states adopt this kind of system, you will not find any USA teachers outside the USA system in the future sans DOD sanctioned schools.
I'm very angry about the current situation concerning new Public School teaching licenses. Many teachers are very angry about it.
Alternate teaching certification still has yearly CEU's but do not require all teachers to attend yearly ever-changing politically correct seminars. (How can I attend them if in China to keep my licenses active?)
I'm better off going to another country and getting a PGDE PGCE and hope they will waive the "Country of Birth" requirements.
USA Public School teaching certification is designed to Certify the teacher for that State in the USA with all types of clauses that allow the licenses to be revoked or suspended if the teacher doesn't meet yearly-changing state based requirements.
Therefore, it is almost impossible to RETAIN a US license in my state if teaching abroad.
USA certified teachers Beware
 |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
waxwing
Joined: 29 Jun 2003 Posts: 719 Location: China
|
Posted: Tue Oct 09, 2007 12:23 am Post subject: |
|
|
First, SnoopBot, thanks for sharing so many interesting details. I apologise to the thread starter, I know we're off topic. I sometimes wonder whether we could start up a science or general subject-teaching forum for China, since more and more people seem interested in it.
SnoopBot wrote: |
I'm not sure what they would classify as being certified. In my case my undergrad degree was EE. So I had the standard Physics track I, II, III and Calculus I-V. I also had various EE and EET courses, I was a trainer at a metrology lab teaching metrology at a standards lab.
|
Interesting. It sounds like you'd fall under the "not strictly qualified to do it but could do it" heading. Although everything depends on the school, i.e. what specifically they're teaching. Please forgive me, I'm not familiar with the American degree system, but I would mention that my general (indirect) experience has been that the early stages of American degrees in Maths, Physics are far lower in difficulty than first year of degrees in Britain. If I were hiring, I would be suspicious of an American who didn't have a big chunk of his teaching subject in his degree. But, again, it depends what you're teaching - if it's "Chinese high school", it wouldn't matter, if it's A-level or IB, it might. (This is all very tentative...)
Quote: |
However, I had NO USA Praxis Examination scores or certification in Physics.
|
I don't know what "USA Praxis" is - is this connected with teaching or just Physics? Having no scores in Physics would be a problem, I guess. Frustrating for you, I'm sure, if you know you can teach it!
Quote: |
However, I could have easily passed them. The book that was being used was a lower-level non-calculus based physics book.
|
This is what I mean by American degrees. Such a thing (a course on Physics not involving calculus) only happens to us in school (A-level), never in a degree.
Forgive the apparent American bashing - it's a point of frustration to me, but our degree systems are so profoundly different that it can be very difficult establishing anything about the comparison.
Quote: |
Maybe without having a teaching licenses in physics was the reason I was offered lower pay. I do have a Med Masters in Education with 2 certifications (one was TESOL).
|
Not having the license is only a real barrier for genuine international schools. (i.e. schools that teach non-Chinese). But you have a Masters in Education?? Surely that means you have real teaching experience and knowledge of teaching methods, etc.? (I don't know anything about MEd) If so, that surely must give you a big headstart.
Here's the thing - there just aren't that many people teaching in China with what you call a "teaching license" (what I might call a DfES number, or QTS status from the UK). Hardly any outside international schools, we are a rare breed. So whatever you can bring to the party - PhD, MEd, MSc, any kind of teaching experience back home or in international schools in other countries - all of these can get you in to good jobs, certainly let's say in the 10-25K range, without being specific. Now I make this positive statement because your specialism is in science/physics. I wouldn't say the same thing, of course, if it was Spanish or English or Philosophy.
Quote: |
I strongly feel they pay this salary to most teachers because the range they offered was the same range others were told (actually higher) I will state they charge 70,000 RMB a year.
|
I wasn't so astonished by the 10K, as I was by the 40 hours. What kind of teaching does one really do for 40 hours a week? Bad teaching, basically. In English First with a prescribed textbook, let's face it, a hamster could do it, but teaching practical science (without good labs or equipment!), teaching a technical subject in a foreign language, assessing students work in your "free time" (otherwise little point in all those lessons).
I shudder to think how many students would be facing you in your classes. This is a big issue to think about, too, in China.
Quote: |
I was going to build a physics lab because they lacked a good lab (very important) since I had lab experience at a type 3 calibration physics lab, I was going to make the best physics lab in China. I took this as a challenge for me.
|
Quite so, quite so. This is exactly why I prefer to teach Maths than Physics here. Not that it isn't fun, and if you love lab, go for it, but be prepared for a lot of heartache.
Quote: |
The big bomb shell was the shared housing complex and told that If I was married I could rent a place near the school. Talking to Chinese friends of my wife and fellow teachers a place with western style outfitting would cost us at least 3000 + a month.
|
Yep, a complete non starter. Just forget this outfit. You'll resent it if you give in to these kind of conditions, there is better.
Look for something else in the same field. This field is likely to grow in China but do the research.
Quote: |
Teaching certification is difficult and a mess in my state now. If I completed a 1-year PGDE I still would not be qualified. The current rules are "Teaching Certification" from country of Birth = USA.
My state will not grant Public School licenses unless the new teacher spends a few years in a combat zone "High Demanding District."
Permanent teaching licenses are not given out now, I would be required to stay in some inner-city zone for a few years, then hope to transfer out. To retain my licenses I would be required to meet yearly "Continuous Education Credits" So if the State decides that I must take "Diversity and Multiculturalism in the classroom" and I'm teaching in China. My licenses will be cancelled if I cannot prove I am meeting the constant changing requirements to keep a valid license.
This means NO TEACHERS from my state under the new system can go abroad and keep their licenses. Teachers are stuck in the same inner-city schools for years to fill the teaching shortages. The days of doing a runner from a poor school district to a more upscale one is over.
|
Wow that is so sneaky. Absolutely horrible. But, you know, I'm not sure a current "license" is really the main thing. Again, for a real international school, if you actually want to go into that environment (which I don't, personally), it is, but for all the other schools in China which are focussing on international qualifications, it isn't necessary. Some real teaching experience back home, though, has got to be hugely useful.
Thanks again. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
arioch36
Joined: 21 Jan 2003 Posts: 3589
|
Posted: Tue Oct 09, 2007 2:56 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Quote: |
but I would mention that my general (indirect) experience has been that the early stages of American degrees in Maths, Physics are far lower in difficulty than first year of degrees in Britain. |
Not really pertinent. But it varied directly based on what the local school wants and what the state demands. Some states have two different high school degrees, one for college bound students pursuing math-based degrees, one for students who have no interest in this. Many high schools offer three tiers; math without the math (basically), "normal" difficulty pre-calc, calc (equivalent to a non=engineering school's first term of calc) and honours programs for high school students who have a shot at the MIT's and other good enginering schools. My high school physics and calc were identical to my second uni ( a non-engineering school) first 8 weeks
America, the federal government does not play any role in the certification to teach. The highest universities have the fewest requirements (often, Phd, and publications, teaching as a T.A.) At my uni, some of the schools (School of Social Science, etc) would require to take 8 hours of lecture to be in the "teaching track" to teach full time at the University. No state or federal mandated requirements.
To teach at the public high school has strict, specific requirements that the state determines. My state, you could teach with just a BS if you were making satisfactory progress in your teaching M.A. and had two years to complete it (this exception because back 7 years ago not enough public school teachers) A university professor would not be qualfied to teach at a high school. I could teach at my uni. I could teach as a substitute at the high school. I could not be a union cardcarrying full time high school teacher
A M.A. in Education, many are not teacher related, but administration related. Again each state has different regulations. If you are certified(I never heard the term licensed) in one state you could not automatically teach in another state. You have to apply to have your certification accepted. Totally up to the state. I would have to send my resume to California STate Board of Higher Ed, and ask pretty please. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
|
This page is maintained by the one and only Dave Sperling. Contact Dave's ESL Cafe
Copyright © 2018 Dave Sperling. All Rights Reserved.
Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2002 phpBB Group
|