|
Job Discussion Forums "The Internet's Meeting Place for ESL/EFL Students and Teachers from Around the World!"
|
View previous topic :: View next topic |
Should this gentleman attempt ESL? |
Yes, it is a rewarding experience in its own right. |
|
50% |
[ 4 ] |
No way! just go on Holiday dude. |
|
37% |
[ 3 ] |
No, don't come to Asia I hate you. |
|
12% |
[ 1 ] |
|
Total Votes : 8 |
|
Author |
Message |
feynman
Joined: 01 Apr 2010 Posts: 4
|
Posted: Fri Apr 02, 2010 5:42 am Post subject: Is this something for people like me to consider? |
|
|
Hi ESLers,
I really know pretty much nothing about this whole thing but I wanted to get a bit of insight. I am maybe in a somewhat different position from the typical ESLer( or maybe not this is why I asked). I have an advanced degree in a highly sought after technical field which is very strong in the US. I am looking to take a year off in Asia to teach English not so much to make money or a career out of it but just because it seems like a way to experience a complete change of pace and engage in a vastly different culture while not bleeding money like I would I just went over on holiday.
Is this a sensible thing for someone like me to do? I don't have much of a passion for teaching English as a Second Language but I think it could be fun for a short term undertaking. I do think I'd enjoy teaching math, engineering and physics but I doubt there is much of a place for English language instruction of that in Asia, especially without a Ph.D. I'm not much interested in teaching kids, but sounds like those Japanese conversation school could be enjoyable since I could more or less just have fun with the "students."
I'm pretty much open to working anywhere in Asia, Japan though is the top pick. As this is only going to be a one-off experience for me I'm not planning on investing in a teaching certificate. I'd also like to find a job with large multi-week breaks, does this limit me to working with kids in schools? I'm not so worried about salary but hopefully whatever it is would be enough to pay the bills and have a good deal of fun. I'm also not concerned about saving any money in the process.
There are of course a miriade of other way I could end up in another country, like taking a job with a firm and trying to get transfered or just blowing through some saving and spend a year backpacking. However, ESL seems like it would be a unique experience to really dig in and understand a culture and taking a year off from my career would also be a nice change of pace. Am I crazy for looking down this road? Would those who do ESL in Asia still do it if there were in a position like me?
Thanks for any input folks! |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
feynman
Joined: 01 Apr 2010 Posts: 4
|
Posted: Fri Apr 02, 2010 6:02 am Post subject: |
|
|
Also, I wanted to ask how difficult it is in the big picture to find a job somewhere in Asia. My sense from reading the forums seems to be that if you have a degree and want to teach you will get it somewhere. Is this correct or do some people just end up SOL? |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
tttompatz

Joined: 06 Mar 2010 Posts: 1951 Location: Talibon, Bohol, Philippines
|
Posted: Fri Apr 02, 2010 8:04 am Post subject: |
|
|
Advanced degrees in a technical field?
Teach in a uni in your subject area. Lots of demand and the salaries aren't bad for this side of the planet.
Ex:
non-related degrees and no teaching cert as an ESL teacher in China = 4000-6000 rmb.
Rates are similar in places like Thailand (thb 30-40,000).
However...
Uni prof in a professional field = ~$1500-1800 in China.
The package is similar in most other Asian countries like Thailand or the Philippines.
In Korea, Japan or Taiwan you could get about double that but the cost of living is comparable to the US.
. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
The Ever-changing Cleric

Joined: 19 Feb 2009 Posts: 1523
|
Posted: Fri Apr 02, 2010 11:25 am Post subject: Re: Is this something for people like me to consider? |
|
|
feynman wrote: |
I'm pretty much open to working anywhere in Asia, Japan though is the top pick. As this is only going to be a one-off experience for me I'm not planning on investing in a teaching certificate. |
those certs arent really necessary and for a short term job, while they may improve your teaching skills, aren't a smart investment moneywise.
feynman wrote: |
I'd also like to find a job with large multi-week breaks, does this limit me to working with kids in schools? I'm not so worried about salary but hopefully whatever it is would be enough to pay the bills and have a good deal of fun. I'm also not concerned about saving any money in the process. |
university jobs in china give a generous amount of holidays over a one year (10 month) contract. several national holidays that translate into long weekends and about 6-8 weeks off for chinese new year in the middle. plus the weekly workload is ridiculously low. most other esl jobs, esp. in language schools wont give you anywhere near this amount of time off.
feynman wrote: |
There are of course a miriade of other way I could end up in another country, like taking a job with a firm and trying to get transfered or just blowing through some saving and spend a year backpacking. However, ESL seems like it would be a unique experience to really dig in and understand a culture and taking a year off from my career would also be a nice change of pace. Am I crazy for looking down this road? Would those who do ESL in Asia still do it if there were in a position like me? |
i left a very decent job back home to travel for a couple of years before i discovered esl. its nice to travel freely over a long period of time without worries of any sort, but you can burn thru the cash quickly if you're not careful. i probably spent about $20,000 over the 24 months i was backpacking. had a great time but could have been a bit smarter how i spent the money. but then again, it was a well deserved holiday for me after military service so i didn't care about the money. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
Sadebugo
Joined: 10 May 2003 Posts: 524
|
Posted: Fri Apr 02, 2010 8:46 pm Post subject: Re: Is this something for people like me to consider? |
|
|
feynman wrote: |
Hi ESLers,
I really know pretty much nothing about this whole thing but I wanted to get a bit of insight. I am maybe in a somewhat different position from the typical ESLer( or maybe not this is why I asked). I have an advanced degree in a highly sought after technical field which is very strong in the US. I am looking to take a year off in Asia to teach English not so much to make money or a career out of it but just because it seems like a way to experience a complete change of pace and engage in a vastly different culture while not bleeding money like I would I just went over on holiday.
Is this a sensible thing for someone like me to do? I don't have much of a passion for teaching English as a Second Language but I think it could be fun for a short term undertaking. I do think I'd enjoy teaching math, engineering and physics but I doubt there is much of a place for English language instruction of that in Asia, especially without a Ph.D. I'm not much interested in teaching kids, but sounds like those Japanese conversation school could be enjoyable since I could more or less just have fun with the "students."
I'm pretty much open to working anywhere in Asia, Japan though is the top pick. As this is only going to be a one-off experience for me I'm not planning on investing in a teaching certificate. I'd also like to find a job with large multi-week breaks, does this limit me to working with kids in schools? I'm not so worried about salary but hopefully whatever it is would be enough to pay the bills and have a good deal of fun. I'm also not concerned about saving any money in the process.
There are of course a miriade of other way I could end up in another country, like taking a job with a firm and trying to get transfered or just blowing through some saving and spend a year backpacking. However, ESL seems like it would be a unique experience to really dig in and understand a culture and taking a year off from my career would also be a nice change of pace. Am I crazy for looking down this road? Would those who do ESL in Asia still do it if there were in a position like me?
Thanks for any input folks! |
Sounds like you've thought it through. Don't let any 'purists' tell you it's not honorable to teach for a year and move on. Most people enter the profession without any qualifications to speak of and/or leave it after a short time. By selecting the country of your choice and putting forth a good effort, you will have accomplished more than most.
Japan is a good choice but don't be suckered into Korea because of the ease of getting jobs there. Believe me, you'll feel like you wasted a year if you go there.
Sadebugo
http://travldawrld.blogspot.com/ |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
Glenski

Joined: 15 Jan 2003 Posts: 12844 Location: Hokkaido, JAPAN
|
Posted: Fri Apr 02, 2010 11:30 pm Post subject: Re: Is this something for people like me to consider? |
|
|
feynman wrote: |
I am maybe in a somewhat different position from the typical ESLer( or maybe not this is why I asked). I have an advanced degree in a highly sought after technical field which is very strong in the US. I am looking to take a year off in Asia to teach English |
Is this degree very new, or do you have some related work experience to go with it? With the economy of the world in the shape it is today, my initial recommendation is to remain in that "highly sought after" field. Teaching English abroad will do practically nothing to improve your odds of landing a job in that technical field, and it may actually hurt it, depending on your situation.
BTW, I also have an advanced degree in a technical field.
Quote: |
not so much to make money or a career out of it but just because it seems like a way to experience a complete change of pace and engage in a vastly different culture while not bleeding money like I would I just went over on holiday. |
Since your prime choice in Asia is Japan, realize that you will "bleed money" just to get started. Japan's market is in a glut of teachers right now, too, so competition for entry level jobs is high. You have very few opportunities to get hired from your home, so if you choose to come here (at the right time) to look around, figure you'll need US$4000-5000 to set yourself up before the first paycheck comes in.
Quote: |
Is this a sensible thing for someone like me to do? |
That's pretty subjective and hard to answer.
Quote: |
I don't have much of a passion for teaching English as a Second Language |
This will be reflected in your work, and it's probably a good indicator of how to answer the previous question.
Quote: |
I do think I'd enjoy teaching math, engineering and physics but I doubt there is much of a place for English language instruction of that in Asia, especially without a Ph.D. |
Unless you're qualified to teach in an international school, you're not going to teach those subjects without strong fluency in the local language, PhD or not.
Quote: |
I'm not much interested in teaching kids, but sounds like those Japanese conversation school could be enjoyable since I could more or less just have fun with the "students." |
A popular misconception. Get over it, or you will just add to the plethora of eikaiwa drones who ruin the industry. You are hired to work and that means teach in some way, even if the popular label is "edutainment". You may also be given kiddies to teach whether you like it or not.
Quote: |
As this is only going to be a one-off experience for me I'm not planning on investing in a teaching certificate. |
So, based on your previous statement about not being that interested in teaching ESL [sic], I'd say this is even more reason to stay home and focus on your technical career.
Quote: |
I'd also like to find a job with large multi-week breaks, does this limit me to working with kids in schools? |
Why do you want these things? Work the local schedule. In Japan, you'll probably get a week off for Golden Week (May), Obon (August) and a week or more for New Year (that means you might have to work on Christmas day).
Quote: |
I'm not so worried about salary but hopefully whatever it is would be enough to pay the bills and have a good deal of fun. I'm also not concerned about saving any money in the process. |
Japan's salaries are falling, but you can still live off them. Your statement about having "a good deal of fun" is a dangerous one if taken the wrong way, because there are so many people who travel abroad as pleasure seekers first and as employees second, and they often cause a lot of trouble. If you just mean having the time for sightseeing and such, I'd suggest you come as a tourist instead.
Quote: |
ESL seems like it would be a unique experience to really dig in and understand a culture |
It is, but you also have to realize that you would be accepted to do work, not to learn the local language, culture and customs, nor to sightsee. The job comes first in employers' minds. In Japan, you may not even have 2 consecutive days off for a weekend, and your hours are roughly noon to 9pm, not exactly conducive to a grand social life or sightseeing. Many people disregard the work ethic and those hours by drinking, clubbing and carousing with women and show up ragged, hung over, or in otherwise no shape to do the job well.
Quote: |
and taking a year off from my career would also be a nice change of pace. |
I will repeat my earlier question...what has been the "pace" for you so far in your technical career?
Quote: |
Am I crazy for looking down this road? Would those who do ESL in Asia still do it if there were in a position like me? |
How much time can your career stand to lose by coming here? You won't gain enough language skills to be worth anything back home unless you study so much that you have no time for sightseeing. You will barely gain any sense of what Japanese business is like in that time, so that won't translate into much use either. It will be different from any college days life or a non-teaching job, but how much will a year off cripple your current career, whether you have a "highly sought after" major or not? The market everywhere is tight, and I suspect that includes back where you are, too. Bear in mind, that a lot of people think they'll just take off a year, but it becomes far longer, and then it becomes even more difficult to impossible to return to their former careers.
You are not in that different a position than a lot of people, especially with what I perceive as your reasons for coming. Really think about whether you want a teaching job and can hack it, or whether you just need a break (i.e., vacation).
ttompatz wrote: |
Uni prof in a professional field = ~$1500-1800 in China.
The package is similar in most other Asian countries like Thailand or the Philippines.
In Korea, Japan or Taiwan you could get about double that but the cost of living is comparable to the US. |
He's not qualified to teach English or anything else in Japanese universities, so the talk of salary is moot. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
feynman
Joined: 01 Apr 2010 Posts: 4
|
Posted: Sat Apr 03, 2010 8:06 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Wow Glenski thanks for the honest and good advice. I think you are probably right that this isn't going to be the way for me to go. To be honest if I did go the actual job on would surely be very low on priorities. Not that I mind taking advantage of some of these companies because a good deal of them seem like scumbags anyway.
I guess after getting some quality advice and reading up a bit this really doesn't sound like a ton of fun. I'm not a teacher, and certainly not a language teacher. I mean I am probably well enough establish in my career and in a field where any competent qualified person will find a job(Engineering) that going wouldn't hurt to much. In fact I will probably still travel anyways but just go on my savings.
You people that are actually interested in this stuff should be a little more vigilant in dissuading imposers like me. I'm sure if I did end up going I would have hated every minute of it. Let this be a warning to those considering it. It seems like you are in a much better position to get a good job at home, save up some money and gone on a leisurely and long holiday abroad. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
Glenski

Joined: 15 Jan 2003 Posts: 12844 Location: Hokkaido, JAPAN
|
Posted: Sun Apr 04, 2010 12:01 am Post subject: |
|
|
feynman wrote: |
Wow Glenski thanks for the honest and good advice. I think you are probably right that this isn't going to be the way for me to go. To be honest if I did go the actual job on would surely be very low on priorities. Not that I mind taking advantage of some of these companies because a good deal of them seem like scumbags anyway. |
While that statement is true, consider these 2 points:
1) Your students are not scumbags.
2) A teacher's attitude, even towards a scumbag employer, carries over into the next teacher's opportunities. You leave behind a legacy that can perpetuate problems in the local industry (contracts full of legalese, lower salaries, etc.).
Quote: |
I guess after getting some quality advice and reading up a bit this really doesn't sound like a ton of fun. I'm not a teacher, and certainly not a language teacher. |
Most people who start EFL/ESL aren't. But at least a lot of them want to give the teaching part of the job a try.
Quote: |
You people that are actually interested in this stuff should be a little more vigilant in dissuading imposers like me. I'm sure if I did end up going I would have hated every minute of it. Let this be a warning to those considering it. It seems like you are in a much better position to get a good job at home, save up some money and gone on a leisurely and long holiday abroad. |
Have not tried to dissuade most people from coming to Japan, but I've often been labeled as a "doom and gloom" person who does precisely that. In rare cases I tell people directly to stay home. Usually, my advice is meant to point out misinformation and to open eyes on realities of the working/living situation here, and that often gets misconstrued. I refer to that as not looking at the world entirely through rose-colored glasses, or telling everyone "Come on in, the water's fine!"
Giving advice to dissuade people should be done carefully, since all either side has to go on is what is written on the page, and text can be misunderstood. If you want more conversation on this, send me a PM or post more here. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
feynman
Joined: 01 Apr 2010 Posts: 4
|
Posted: Sun Apr 04, 2010 2:26 am Post subject: |
|
|
No thanks it's alright Glenski, I kind of reached the decision on my own and just found your advice to kind of reinforce what I thought.
Superficially ESL seems like a great idea but frankly I'm not willing to deal with this strange and sometimes dishonest companies just to make a wage abroad. I'm also certainly not interested in financing this "set-up" procedure to get started which is something any decently honest company should cover.I can definitely see how kids right out of school could be enticed by the possibilities but after having some life experience in the real world, I don't think I could put up with the kind of stuff teachers have to deal with, especially abroad.
Don't take that as a put down toward teachers though, you who are really interested in it and do well you guys certainly deserve a ton of respect. However for the untrained n00b, as it were it, sounds more like you have to interview has if you were trying out for a reality show and once you get the job you are more there for show than anything.
Good luck to those of you who really love the stuff though, I guess I'm more or less content to experience Asia as an outsider for the time being. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
spiral78

Joined: 05 Apr 2004 Posts: 11534 Location: On a Short Leash
|
Posted: Sun Apr 04, 2010 8:21 am Post subject: |
|
|
To be honest if I did go the actual job on would surely be very low on priorities. Not that I mind taking advantage of some of these companies because a good deal of them seem like scumbags anyway.
It's all about the students. I'm glad you've decided not to go for teaching. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
naturegirl321

Joined: 04 May 2003 Posts: 9041 Location: home sweet home
|
Posted: Tue Apr 06, 2010 2:37 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Couple of things.
Just try it. A year is nothing.
Second, don't say just a year, you might meet someone, get married, etc.
Lastly, about salaries. Budgeting is key, getting extra classes, bonuses, etc and you could save. I'm hoping to save at least 2K a month. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
coledavis
Joined: 21 Jun 2003 Posts: 1838
|
Posted: Thu Apr 29, 2010 11:38 am Post subject: |
|
|
There are a few positions which are for teachers who want to teach around specific content (EAP?). I still think you ought to get a good qualification first. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
|
This page is maintained by the one and only Dave Sperling. Contact Dave's ESL Cafe
Copyright © 2018 Dave Sperling. All Rights Reserved.
Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2002 phpBB Group
|