|
Job Discussion Forums "The Internet's Meeting Place for ESL/EFL Students and Teachers from Around the World!"
|
| View previous topic :: View next topic |
| Author |
Message |
travelNteach
Joined: 14 Jul 2009 Posts: 222
|
Posted: Fri Feb 18, 2011 3:30 pm Post subject: |
|
|
interesting discussion.
i dont do privates, but if i did i would make a small little company. where i currently teach, it has to be owned in part by a citizen of this country. i would then pay myself a small hourly wage. basically i would then have a full time job and a part time job and still be under the 90,000 limit.
i have no idea why anyone would want to pay taxes anyway, but that is your personal decision. being that i dont owe any taxes, i can file whenever i want too and there isnt any penalty.
if i am working overseas and working for a local school, i cannot be considered self employed. i am an employee on a time limited contract. there are lots of people in the usa that also now work on time limited contracts. it order to be conisdered self employed, i would have to set up a sole proprietery company owned solely by me and be working for the company as a sub-contractor, not an employee. i guess different countries have different contracts and different ways of approaching employment. i have a one year renewable contract with my school paying my national taxes here. i dont owe US taxes for anything and i am not self employed.
thanks for the links zero. internet here is so slow that i havent had time to read them. i will cheat and get my sister who is a CPA to check it out. either way, it seems simple enough to work around it. and there are millions of people, both citizens and illegal immigrants, who work for cash under the table and never pay taxes yet get all the benefits of subsidized housing, free education, police and fire protection and the like. they dont even attempt to catch them so i seriously doubt that they would fly halfway around the world to see naturegirl made and extra 400 dollars.
the social security sytem became broken 20 years ago when the started allowing other governmental departments to raid it to make up for shortfalls in their budgets. \
about interest rates: cambodia pays 7% on us dollar accounts. in australia u can get 6-7% on australian dollar accounts. this was great a year ago when the rate was 60 cent aussie to 1 us dollar. now it is near parity. so the rate is still good but u could lost your shirt if the exchange rates fell again by the time your cd matured. in new zealand, they have govt and bank bonks that pay over 10%but u have to lock your money in for a number of years, somewhere between 3-5 i believe. again, u have to watch the exchange rate and open the cd when the dollar is strong and and close them when the dollar is weak. they also have dollar accounts, but i dont know what the current rate on them is. vietnam also has high dollar rates on deposits, both savings and cd's. the pay even higher for vietnam money, but it is devaluing so u would probably break even or lose money in the long run........ 1/2 year cd's. u can also make a lot of money on curency exchange, whether it is eruo/pound or dollar/won or almost any currency. sometimes u have to move quickly, sometimes u have to be patient and let the money sit.
there are lots of ways to let your money make you money. and doing these things are not taxable as capital gains taxes and goes under regular earnings. i would rather be in charge of my own money, they a group of men that put billions of dollars of pork bellies in every bill they pass. nothing short of bribery. and who have overspent trillions and trillions of dollars each year. i dont think my bank would cover my checks if i did that. china has bought up so much american debt that they will soon own the country if they dont already.
sorry about the rant. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
naturegirl321

Joined: 04 May 2003 Posts: 9041 Location: home sweet home
|
Posted: Sat Feb 19, 2011 1:32 am Post subject: |
|
|
| travelNteach wrote: |
| i have no idea why anyone would want to pay taxes anyway, but that is your personal decision. being that i dont owe any taxes, i can file whenever i want too and there isnt any penalty. |
While I completely agree with you, there's something's you've missed. I REALLY don't thinik the majority of us WANT to pay taxes. We do so because it's the law and could be prosecuted if we didn't.
Aso this example is hard to explain.
| travelNteach wrote: |
| if i am working overseas and working for a local school, i cannot be considered self employed. i am an employee on a time limited contract. . i have a one year renewable contract with my school paying my national taxes here. i dont owe US taxes for anything and i am not self employed. |
ON the 2555, there's only room for ONE employer. So if you have two jobs, what do you do? I honestly have no idea. Maybe put one job on the 2555 and the other on the 1116?
| travelNteach wrote: |
| they dont even attempt to catch them so i seriously doubt that they would fly halfway around the world to see naturegirl made and extra 400 dollars. |
Let's certainly hope so! BUT, there's a bit of an alternative motive behind my tax paying. IF I ever decide to go back to the US and have my husband come with me, I'd have to show taxes for him to get a visa. PLUS, if I ever have kids and want them to go to school in the US, guess what? Arg. You need taxe forms to file the FASFA. Do I want this to happen, honestly, no. BUT, it's an option and I believe it's best to have options open to you. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
travelNteach
Joined: 14 Jul 2009 Posts: 222
|
Posted: Sat Feb 19, 2011 10:17 am Post subject: |
|
|
| Quote: |
travelNteach wrote:
i have no idea why anyone would want to pay taxes anyway, but that is your personal decision. being that i dont owe any taxes, i can file whenever i want too and there isnt any penalty.
While I completely agree with you, there's something's you've missed. I REALLY don't thinik the majority of us WANT to pay taxes. We do so because it's the law and could be prosecuted if we didn't. |
here i was talking about that 400 dollars or whatever you earned teaching privates. u can claim 90,000 tax free, so why not file? but u dont have to file by the april 15th deadline because u dont own any taxes.
| Quote: |
Aso this example is hard to explain.
travelNteach wrote:
if i am working overseas and working for a local school, i cannot be considered self employed. i am an employee on a time limited contract. . i have a one year renewable contract with my school paying my national taxes here. i dont owe US taxes for anything and i am not self employed.
ON the 2555, there's only room for ONE employer. So if you have two jobs, what do you do? I honestly have no idea. Maybe put one job on the 2555 and the other on the 1116? |
what would u do when filing a 1040A? you can either write real small or do as i have always done........ i put my main employee on the form, but include the wages from the second job in the additional income box and attach the W2 from the second job to the first job.
| Quote: |
travelNteach wrote:
they dont even attempt to catch them so i seriously doubt that they would fly halfway around the world to see naturegirl made and extra 400 dollars.
Let's certainly hope so! BUT, there's a bit of an alternative motive behind my tax paying. IF I ever decide to go back to the US and have my husband come with me, I'd have to show taxes for him to get a visa. PLUS, if I ever have kids and want them to go to school in the US, guess what? Arg. You need taxe forms to file the FASFA. Do I want this to happen, honestly, no. BUT, it's an option and I believe it's best to have options open to you. |
never heard of u needed tax returns to bring back your husband, but file anyway. again we are talking about the pitiance u get from untraceable private lessons, not the main job that u sponsors your work visa and provides your main salary. again i am not advocating not filing taxes, just against the the supplemenatl forms u fill out for a few dollars and call yourself self-employed when u are not and u dont have a company established within the united states.
about the fasfa form............. i have friends that are illegal aliens in the US. nearly all of them work under the table and have never filed taxes, yet their children all attend school........ from K to high school. so what is the point. also, there are so many children from illegal hispanic parents who cant speak any english, that most school disttricts have declared ESL teachers i critical need/shortage, much the way science or math used to be. if u are a certified ESL teacher, u get bonuses including having your student loans repaid for u. but again, we are missing the point........ file your regular taxes and u are in the clean even if this regulation is in place or enforced. my entire disagreement was filing forms and paying taxes on the little money u get in private lessons.
that little bit that u are filing for and paying taxes on is in no way benefiting u or upping your average for your social security benefits that will get paid to u. every day they are cutting SS benefits and pay outs as well as changing the qualifications to be eligible for them. they are already talking about pushing the age back to 70, which i think will happen sooner than lettter. maybe i am unreaslistic or just too free-spririted for my own good, but i think u are causing yourself alot of extra anxiety and stress for no reward/benefit and u will never be caught or punished for that 400 dollars.
file your regular forms for your tax exempt salary. decide for yourself whether to add this to your overall income as a secondary benefit or just forget about it. or keep doing as u are dong but u dont gain anything but headaches. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
naturegirl321

Joined: 04 May 2003 Posts: 9041 Location: home sweet home
|
Posted: Sat Feb 19, 2011 10:36 am Post subject: |
|
|
| travelNteach wrote: |
here i was talking about that 400 dollars or whatever you earned teaching privates. u can claim 90,000 tax free, so why not file? but u dont have to file by the april 15th deadline because u dont own any taxes.
if i am working overseas and working for a local school, i cannot be considered self employed. i am an employee on a time limited contract. . i have a one year renewable contract with my school paying my national taxes here. i dont owe US taxes for anything and i am not self employed.
what would u do when filing a 1040A? you can either write real small or do as i have always done........ i put my main employee on the form, but include the wages from the second job in the additional income box and attach the W2 from the second job to the first job.
never heard of u needed tax returns to bring back your husband, but file anyway.
about the fasfa form............. i have friends that are illegal aliens in the US. nearly all of them work under the table and have never filed taxes, yet their children all attend school........ from K to high school. so what is the point.
that little bit that u are filing for and paying taxes on is in no way benefiting u or upping your average for your social security benefits that will get paid to u. every day they are cutting SS benefits and pay outs as well as changing the qualifications to be eligible for them. |
I DO file and for the past two years I HAVE paid. And it DOES count towards SSA credits. It's not $400. that's the max you can make as a self employed person WITHOUT filing. Since I file, I make MORE than $400. The 2555 does NOTHING for SSA, BUT, by declaring self employment and paying taxes, I get credit for SS.
About your one year contract. I agree, BUT if people have TWO or more jobs, or are self employed, chances are they will owe taxes. Case in point.
I have two jobs. My main job I don't pay US taxes, my self employed job, I do. I AM self employed. I make money by writing (not teaching privates, at least not anymore), I don't pay taxes on that to Korea. So I MUST pay taxes on this to the US. Cash in hand isn't traceable, but bank transfers ARE. Were I to get cash in hand, I might not declare it but I don't.
I'm employed overseas, I don't get W2s.
And I don't file 1040As.
And you DO need to show taxes to bring a FOREIGN spouse to the US. YOu have to show the past three years in order to prove that you make enough to support the both of you. YOu have to earn something like 120% over poverty line. And poverty line changes depending on how many people you have in your family.
As far as schooling, I meant UNIVERSITY, you have to file the FASFA. It's not for K to 12. Where are you getting your info?
Don't take this the wrong way, but I really think you need to do a bit more research. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
elamericano
Joined: 10 Nov 2007 Posts: 65
|
Posted: Sat Feb 19, 2011 10:03 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| naturegirl321 wrote: |
| elamericano wrote: |
| TEFLers, and really anyone working overseas on a work visa for a foreign employer, can be considered self-employed because they are usually on time-limited work contracts because of how work visas operate. Therefore they can declare this status and pay the self-employment tax for their FICA contributions. |
I don't know. I've always filed the 2555 on my foreign income, since it's my main job and then the Sch C and Sch SE on self employment.
Why pay double taxes? Honestly, you'd have to pay taxes on your foreign income in the foreign country and then AGAIN to the IRS. YOu COULD do the 1116 though. Kind of a happy medium. |
But you wouldn't be gaining US Social Security points on the foreign employment income because you would not be paying FICA off of that, in fact you cannot pay FICA off of that because it's from a non-US employer. However if you declare the whole thing as self employment then you can do so. The 2555 form excuses you from federal income taxes, which are separate from FICA. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
naturegirl321

Joined: 04 May 2003 Posts: 9041 Location: home sweet home
|
Posted: Sun Feb 20, 2011 12:48 am Post subject: |
|
|
| elamericano wrote: |
| But you wouldn't be gaining US Social Security points on the foreign employment income because you would not be paying FICA off of that, in fact you cannot pay FICA off of that because it's from a non-US employer. However if you declare the whole thing as self employment then you can do so. The 2555 form excuses you from federal income taxes, which are separate from FICA. |
Right, exactly. that's the reason behind declaring self employment and paying taxes on it. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
travelNteach
Joined: 14 Jul 2009 Posts: 222
|
Posted: Fri Feb 25, 2011 3:38 am Post subject: |
|
|
@ NG: about FASFA i completely missed the boat. thanks for your pleasant comment.
and i think we are not listening well to each other, so no sense to hijack the thread. i have a minor in accounting and worked as a employee, sub-contractor, piece worker, self-employed, and consultant, and owned my own businesses hiring up to 20 employees.
its ok if u want to discount eveything i say about the tax law. i am not having problems with my taxes or SS. but even IRS and SS employees will give u different answers to the same questions. u seem very concerned with your taxes, which is fine. perhaps the best solution would be to hire a competent CPA in the states that specializes in expat citizens with both primary and secondary incomes. i am sure the peace of mind he would give u, the money u might save on taxes, and credits for SS would be worth his fees. i am sure that he would be a much more knowledgable and reliable source of information than teachers who just pick up bits and pieces of the tax law on our journey thru the ESL life.
with that i will drop out of this thread. best wishes to everyone on their taxes and living life overseas |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Zero
Joined: 08 Sep 2004 Posts: 1402
|
Posted: Fri Feb 25, 2011 3:53 am Post subject: |
|
|
I personally think naturegirl is doing it exactly right, according to the law. Getting cash for private lessons is one thing, but the writing income is traceable if one were audited. Also, if it is greater than (either $400 or $600, I forget which) from a single U.S. client, the client would send a 1099 to both naturegirl and the IRS. If naturegirl didn't report it, the IRS would eventually come knocking to ask about it because the records didn't line up. I've seen it happen.
The only sticky area to me is whether it is legal to perform such work on the side under Korean law, and whether it should be taxed under Korean law. And if it were me, I would not spend one second worrying about it. When you're sitting at your computer in your apartment, the Korean government has no way of knowing if you're earning sending email, looking at porn, or earning $100,000 through freelance writing. Or all of the above. And I'd argue that it's not their business. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Perilla

Joined: 09 Jul 2010 Posts: 792 Location: Hong Kong
|
Posted: Fri Feb 25, 2011 3:59 am Post subject: |
|
|
| My wife is from the US. Last year she filed her tax return for the first time after 12 years of living in Asia. Nightmare. She employed an accountant here in HK to help, and he cost a good chunk. The paperwork still took her an age to sort out. And she wound up having to pay around 2 or 3,000 US in tax as she makes over the 90K threshold. At least she's "clean" now after worrying over not filing her returns for years ... but boy am I glad we don't have to do this in the UK. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
naturegirl321

Joined: 04 May 2003 Posts: 9041 Location: home sweet home
|
Posted: Fri Feb 25, 2011 1:10 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Zero wrote: |
I personally think naturegirl is doing it exactly right, according to the law. Getting cash for private lessons is one thing, but the writing income is traceable if one were audited. Also, if it is greater than (either $400 or $600, I forget which) from a single U.S. client, the client would send a 1099 to both naturegirl and the IRS. If naturegirl didn't report it, the IRS would eventually come knocking to ask about it because the records didn't line up. I've seen it happen.
The only sticky area to me is whether it is legal to perform such work on the side under Korean law, and whether it should be taxed under Korean law. |
Don't do privates anymore Seriously, it's against the immi rules here and my husband AND I could get deported, not worth it.
I'll declare, I paid my $150 ish this year. That's fine. Though the SSA hasn't sent me anything yet, which is a bit odd.
As for writing, it's online and nothing comes in to Korea, so I should be good
My mom's friend is a tax accountant. She's seen people get busted for not declaring cash in hand income. Happens when the person paying declares it (and they get audited) and then the person receiving it doesn't. Sure, chances are slim that it will happen to you, but if you declare then the chances are nil. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
naturegirl321

Joined: 04 May 2003 Posts: 9041 Location: home sweet home
|
Posted: Fri Feb 25, 2011 1:14 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| travelNteach wrote: |
@ NG: about FASFA i completely missed the boat. thanks for your pleasant comment.
and i think we are not listening well to each other, so no sense to hijack the thread. i have a minor in accounting and worked as a employee, sub-contractor, piece worker, self-employed, and consultant, and owned my own businesses hiring up to 20 employees.
its ok if u want to discount eveything i say about the tax law. i am not having problems with my taxes or SS. but even IRS and SS employees will give u different answers to the same questions. u seem very concerned with your taxes, which is fine. perhaps the best solution would be to hire a competent CPA in the states that specializes in expat citizens with both primary and secondary incomes. i am sure the peace of mind he would give u, the money u might save on taxes, and credits for SS would be worth his fees. |
NOt sure if you'e being sarcastic or not with your first comment I'll suppose that you're not and give you the benefit of the doubt.
BUt look, I realise that you have more experience than I do, but still, ikf you make income and you don't declare it, you're breaking the law. Look at this,
http://www.careeroverview.com/blog/2010/10-most-famous-tax-evaders-of-all-time/
Doesn't matter if you're rich, famous, a ganster, or have 50 years experience, You can still get caught.
As for expat tax accountants. I've looked at it, beleive me I have, but the money I'd spend on the accountant would be more than I owe the IRS. So I'll just pay the IRS, rather than pay an accountant to fudge the numbers and end up paying him more  |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
|
This page is maintained by the one and only Dave Sperling. Contact Dave's ESL Cafe
Copyright © 2018 Dave Sperling. All Rights Reserved.
Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2002 phpBB Group
|