|
Job Discussion Forums "The Internet's Meeting Place for ESL/EFL Students and Teachers from Around the World!"
|
| View previous topic :: View next topic |
| Author |
Message |
nomadic_meow
Joined: 07 Apr 2013 Posts: 59 Location: Vietnam
|
Posted: Sun Jun 21, 2015 6:39 am Post subject: |
|
|
I'm at a low-ranked provincial university in the north. I have had some classrooms that had computers (generally for listening courses where the textbooks had CD's included), but many that only had a chalkboard.
In the other rooms (many of the speaking and reading class rooms), there is just a biggish (very dusty) chalkboard with a great supply of very low quality chalk (snap crackle pop). If you want audiovisuals in those rooms, you have to cart in equipment yourself.
I've also noticed that some of the rooms have almost no free outlets, but at least in the AV rooms I can usually rearrange everything (and restart all the machines after unplugging half of them - and worrying the staff in the process) to make room for one more device. Some of the AV rooms actually have no chalkboards, so I find it necessary to type out notes on a simple text editor.
One problem I have found, is that I don't know how to make the Chinese software on the classroom computers accept files from the other Chinese software on the apartment computer, and sometimes it won't accept files from my English computer either. The rooms have different ages/qualities of machine. So it's kind of a block if you suddenly think, "Oh a PDF or an image file would be nice, but wait we haven't used that kind of file in that particular room yet..." Sometimes, even videos work at home but fail completely on the classroom machine. I have even had days when I arrived in the classroom and found that someone had completely deleted basic applications like, ahem Windows Media Player.
Some of the teachers make photocopies that include some print imagery (or we can have class monitors make them if they get some advance notice). Some make colorful text outlines or paper posters with visuals and stick them up on the walls somehow. And some of the teachers carry in their own laptop very often, too.
I like to bring in short videos with some more authentic conversation, or to add some sense of what the actual environment is like in parts of the West. The only problem is network speeds (even China Telecom commercially) are very slow here, so it can be a headache waiting for even a 5 min video to download off the web at home. I enjoy playing songs, a range of folk and pop/ballad songs although some students find them very hard to follow. It can be nice to have them sometimes just to spice up break time on a dreary day, too.
Sometimes I challenge them to fill in blanks in a song and explain it as we go. Some students seem to enjoy that, others don't (what's new and we also have a huge ability range). But students here did not do well at all with such fill-ins given a new song in an exam situation (I dunno though, the proctors did not really play the song as many times as I would have and I wasn't there to see just what the situation was).
Bottom line: I really do prefer to use some audiovisuals... And I should mention that students often ask for videos if the rooms are capable, if simply for variety. But there are many challenges to using AV as a central part of the class in this situation. It takes a great deal of work and prep to really be 100% sure anything more than photocopies will work, if in fact you can get in the various rooms to check first at all. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
weigookin74
Joined: 30 Mar 2010 Posts: 265
|
Posted: Mon Jun 22, 2015 3:59 am Post subject: Re: debunking the myth |
|
|
| ghost wrote: |
| Quote: |
| The only time I use the computer in the classroom is to display instructions for their assignment or homework. I assign homework in every class so that we can start the next class with the students reading what they have written. |
I use technology here because I think the boredom threshold of most Chinese students is generally very low. This arises, I think, from "overkill" in the use of books and assignments, and homework, from middle school onwards, when, essentially, Chinese adolescents have 'no life' anymore - by the time they reach university, they are simply jaded and many of them hate the sight of books.
When I was in Japan, I saw a similar phenomenon. It took massive effort to reach university, especially the good universities in Japan, but then - once the Japanese students reached their goal of entering their desired university - the pressure was off, and they had a much more relaxed time, compared with their high school academic efforts - although in Japan's defence (scholastic system) - the sport structure in schools is much more developed compared with China.
Back to China - and the university classroom. I look at technology like the spices which make meals more palatable. Yes, it is possible to teach 'old school' - but most students will not enjoy those classes, unless the teacher were truly exceptional and compelling.
I have spoken to a lot of students here, and they tell me that most of their teachers (referring to their fellow Chinese teachers) are boring, and that most of the classes are a waste of time. There are a few teachers who really interest the students, and they are generally teachers who use a combination of technology and books and personal magnetism. One student referred to an exceptional Chinese teacher of English - and said that this teacher was great because he really challenged the students in class - put them on the spot. After reflection - I think this was easier in this situation, because the teacher was Chinese and the students were Chinese. Not so sure that this method would be as successful if the teacher challenging the students (to their limits) were a foreigner.
Just as there are 'horses for courses' - there are also teachers who use different methods and some of them can 'pull off' teaching 'old school' with success, while others would have empty classes (if permitted) with such an approach.
In Saudi, some of the favorite teachers were 'old school' and they often used the 'drill sergeant' approach (authoritarian) to teach the Saudi students. In Saudi, those old school teachers often were very successful, and at my old place in Saudi, the most successful teacher (cited) was one who used the old school method to great effect. It was like entering a class with Mr Chips at the helm, but I don't think that approach would go down well here. The teacher in question is 72 years old, and keeps getting renewed every year, even though the official retirement age is 60. Once you are in, in Saudi, ageism is less of an issue, compared with China, South Korea and Japan. Another teacher in Saudi, an 'Oxford Old Boy' just retired last year, at age 82 years, after teaching for approximately 40 years there!
Ghost in China |
Just curious, do you get a retirement pension if you work there? I mean do you pay into it and will get it sent sent to your Canadian or whereever bank account when you are old? |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
54321
Joined: 11 Jun 2015 Posts: 14
|
Posted: Mon Jun 22, 2015 5:44 am Post subject: Re: debunking the myth |
|
|
| ghost wrote: |
Another teacher in Saudi, an 'Oxford Old Boy' just retired last year, at age 82 years, after teaching for approximately 40 years there!
Ghost in China |
Christ, 40 years in Saudi Arabia. I'd rather die. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
happyinshangqiu
Joined: 20 Jan 2015 Posts: 279 Location: Has specialist qualifications AND local contacts.
|
Posted: Mon Jun 22, 2015 4:29 pm Post subject: Re: debunking the myth |
|
|
| 54321 wrote: |
| ghost wrote: |
Another teacher in Saudi, an 'Oxford Old Boy' just retired last year, at age 82 years, after teaching for approximately 40 years there!
Ghost in China |
Christ, 40 years in Saudi Arabia. I'd rather die. |
If he is gay, he has probably had a great time! |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
relaxtischina
Joined: 09 Jun 2009 Posts: 113
|
Posted: Mon Jun 22, 2015 10:23 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| toteach wrote: |
| Non Sequitur wrote: |
'Oral English' comprises both speaking and listening.
Hearing a student speak as an individual is essential as you've got to grade them somehow.
The trick is to check them out as they are talking to each other - not to you as teacher.
A warm up class song is essential. |
Can you share a list of the songs you'd suggest? (With or without music?) |
Try getting kids to use google to translate the following song (huge hit around 2007) or a more current favorite into English and then using the English version(s) as a regular warm up for the class. Imagine the fun and meaningful engagement they could have competing in groups re who has the best translation that still fits the beat designed for Chinese lyrics. Ofcourse this does work best with a computer, the internet, a projector and a teacher who is willing to use student-centered approaches and so may not be suitable for teacher-centered dinos
蔡依琳 陶喆-今天你要嫁给我
专辑:太美丽 春暖的花开带走冬天的感伤 微风吹来浪漫的气息 每一首情歌忽然充满意义 我就在此刻突然见到你 春暖的花香带走冬天的饥寒 微风吹来意外的爱情 鸟儿的高歌拉近我们距离 我就在此刻突然爱上你
听我说
手牵手跟我一起走
创造幸福的生活
昨天你来不及
明天就会可惜
今天嫁给我好吗
jolin in the house dt(david tao) in the house our love in the house 夏日的热情打动春天的懒散 阳光照耀美满的家庭 每一首情歌都会勾起回忆 想当年我是怎么认识你 冬天的忧伤结束秋天的孤单 微风吹来苦辣的思念 鸟儿的高歌唱着不要别离 此刻我多么想要拥抱你 听我说 手牵手跟我一起走 过着安定的生活 昨天你来不及 明天就会可惜 今天你要嫁给我 听我说 手牵手我们一起走 把你一生交给我 昨天不要回头 明天要到白首 今天你要嫁给我 听着礼堂的钟声 我们在上帝和亲友面前见证 这对男女生就要结为夫妻 不要忘了这一切是多么的神圣 你愿意生死苦乐永远和她在一起 爱惜她尊重她 安慰她保护着她 两人同时建立起美满的家庭 你愿意这样做吗 yes i do! 听我说 手牵手一路到尽头 把你一生交给我 昨天已是过去 明天更多回忆 今天你要嫁给我 |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
|
This page is maintained by the one and only Dave Sperling. Contact Dave's ESL Cafe
Copyright © 2018 Dave Sperling. All Rights Reserved.
Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2002 phpBB Group
|