|
Job Discussion Forums "The Internet's Meeting Place for ESL/EFL Students and Teachers from Around the World!"
|
View previous topic :: View next topic |
Author |
Message |
NorthofAmerica
Joined: 17 Jul 2006 Posts: 187 Location: Recovering Expat
|
Posted: Sun Jan 11, 2009 6:53 pm Post subject: Narrowing down my positions: points to consider, HELP! |
|
|
Okay, so finally I am beginning the process of applying for jobs in China.
I have 2 years experience in Japan teaching everything from corporate training to 3 year olds. I have my TESOL certificate as well. As always, at this stage I am sorting through mounds of info and trying to make a somewhat educated jump in.
Here's my thought process about the positions and cities I have looked at.
1) Shanghai, originally my number 1 choice but I have dropped it off the list because I am eager to improve my Putonghua and Shanghainese might interfere. Is that right? Also, cost of living vs. salary seems tighter. Culturally, is this city more than just bright lights and new money?
so with the language in mind I began to look more at jobs in the North and North-east. Also, kinda second tier cities began to look better for quality of life.
1) Beijing, not a second tier I know but I was there last year and it kinda grew on me. The language seemed standard (I learned the weird "err" they throw on things like Sanlitun) and it seemed nice if a little bland compared to large cities in Japan.
2) Dalian, This city keeps looking better and better to me. A relatively large Japanese business presence (I speak Japanese), clean, and fairly cosmopolitan. I just worry it is too far out there and too COLD! This has become my first choice but I just don't know enough about how other cities stack up to it. How's the cost of living vis a vis Beijing?
3) Shenyang, I was just offered a job there today but had not considered it. Also COLD. Any opinions on this place?
Finally, I keep hearing people say "Don't take anything below XXXX" but the pay rates seem all over the place. My current bottom figure is about 7000 PLUS housing and good contract details. Is that about right? Can I play hardball and get more?
Any help would be greatly appreciated!!  |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
Eyrick3

Joined: 29 Mar 2008 Posts: 161 Location: Beijing, China
|
Posted: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:00 am Post subject: |
|
|
Quote: |
Shanghai, originally my number 1 choice but I have dropped it off the list because I am eager to improve my Putonghua and Shanghainese might interfere. Is that right? |
I'm sure people will argue that every good school with good teachers will teach you standard Mandarin in the classroom. However, it's outside of the classroom where most of your learning will take place. You therefore will want to live somewhere where you can be exposed to standard Mandarin both in and outside of the classroom. If you're serious about studying, you'll want to go farther NE.
Quote: |
Also, cost of living vs. salary seems tighter. |
If you're looking to save money, I wouldn't recommend Shanghai. Plus, FTs are a dime a dozen here. The market is saturated. Go somewhere where you'll be able to negotiate and get more personal attention.
Quote: |
Culturally, is this city more than just bright lights and new money? |
Basically, no.
Quote: |
The language seemed standard (I learned the weird "err" they throw on things like Sanlitun) |
You'll also hear some people argue that Beijing is not completely "standard" for this reason. And while the retroflexive "er" can be a bit annoying, it's easy to get around and not everyone speaks that way.
About Dalian:
Quote: |
How's the cost of living vis a vis Beijing? |
Lower. You'll be on the sea, which, and I haven't been to Dalian, I would imagine compensate for the normally smoggy air here.
Quote: |
Shenyang, I was just offered a job there today but had not considered it. |
There's a famous comedian for this area called "Small Shenyang". He's great because he speaks (often a little exaggerated, but not much) with the local "twang". If you're serious about language learning, stay away from here.
Quote: |
My current bottom figure is about 7000 PLUS housing and good contract details. Is that about right? |
On average, schools won't offer this. If they do they won't give you the complete package (e.g. no housing or visa). If you want the complete package, you'll be looking more around the 6000 mark.
The good schools who often get a lot of applicants (and there aren't many of them) won't negotiation because they won't really be desperate for someone with your credentials. Schools that are desperate, however, will promise you the moon, but may not deliver.
If you stay away from the metropolitan cities, you'll be hard up to find that high of a salary from the get go. Salaries like that are common place, however, in places like Beijing and Shanghai. However, the cost of living is high.
If you're main priority is language, I'd go for a smaller city with fewer foreigners and fewer locals who speak English. This will ensure you have to speak Chinese in order to survive. You seem to not like the cold, so I won't recommend Harbin, though that would certainly be your best bet for language learning and a very low cost of living allowing for savings.
Good luck! |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
Lorean
Joined: 21 Dec 2006 Posts: 476 Location: Beijing
|
Posted: Mon Jan 12, 2009 1:51 am Post subject: Re: Narrowing down my positions: points to consider, HELP! |
|
|
NorthofAmerica wrote: |
1) Shanghai, originally my number 1 choice but I have dropped it off the list because I am eager to improve my Putonghua and Shanghainese might interfere. Is that right? |
Wrong.
Quote: |
Also, cost of living vs. salary seems tighter. Culturally, is this city more than just bright lights and new money? |
No.
Quote: |
Also, kinda second tier cities began to look better for quality of life. |
For me quality of life = Starbucks. Opinions may vary.
Quote: |
Beijing, not a second tier I know but I was there last year and it kinda grew on me. The language seemed standard (I learned the weird "err" they throw on things like Sanlitun) and it seemed nice if a little bland compared to large cities in Japan. |
I live in Beijing, let me know if you decide move there. We could do coffee or beer sometime.
Night life in Beijing dies before 2AM, unfortunately.
There are some interesting places that a tourist wouldn't find. Sanlitun is pretty standard. But...
There's a nice high-class jazz bar across from the silk market in the Twin's Tower (the Star Trek looking buildings)
Xidan clothing district and Zhongguancun electronics district are fun for the occasional hang out.
The thing about Beijing is that everything is spread out.
In general, North-East Beijing (Chaoyang district and Dongcheng district) are the more civilized places to live. North-west (Haidian district) is kinda lame, basically student housing.
Quote: |
7000 PLUS housing and good contract details. Is that about right? Can I play hardball and get more? |
Depends on how many hours.
What was your university major? Do you have a Masters?
For teaching English I wouldn't accept anything under 150 per hour, and I think you could do a lot better.
Also housing costs will vary greatly depending on city. Fortunately, real estate has crashed. I would expect to pay around 3000RMB/month in Beijing for a reasonable place, I would cut that to about 2000RMB/month for a smaller city like Qingdao, and a lot less in other places. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
Sly22
Joined: 29 Jan 2007 Posts: 51
|
Posted: Mon Jan 12, 2009 10:27 am Post subject: Re: Narrowing down my positions: points to consider, HELP! |
|
|
NorthofAmerica wrote: |
1) Shanghai, originally my number 1 choice but I have dropped it off the list because I am eager to improve my Putonghua and Shanghainese might interfere. Is that right? Also, cost of living vs. salary seems tighter. Culturally, is this city more than just bright lights and new money?
so with the language in mind I began to look more at jobs in the North and North-east. Also, kinda second tier cities began to look better for quality of life.
|
Shanghai really is a bad place to learn mandarin. There are other good reasons to live here but if you are coming here to learn chinese then get ready for some headaches. Reasons; 1. Shanghai is full of laowai and the shanghainese are used to dealing with westerners using broken english, hand signals, or just plain ignoring you. 2. Most shanghainese speak... shanghainese! so even when you do speak to them in mandarin, its kind of like going to french canada to practice your english: most will speak it but they don't exactly feel honored that you have taken the time to learn their second language. 3. Once you do speak mandarin, you will often find situations like : you go out with your chinese co-workers for dinner. one on one it was great since they always spoke to you in mandarin, but all of a sudden they are in a group and you have no opportunities to join in because of course they are all speaking shanghainese. 4. Being in shanghai its really hard not to end up hanging out with a group of laowai friends. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
bearcanada

Joined: 04 Sep 2005 Posts: 312 Location: Calgary, Canada
|
Posted: Tue Jan 13, 2009 3:29 am Post subject: |
|
|
OP, you've been given some advice that is too far off the mark and you may make a decision about location that you will regret later.
First of all, Shanghai is one of the most interesting and exciting cities in the world, and for sure it is much more international than many others. It is one of the easiest places for a foreigner to become acclimatised and to adjust. You would indeed find other places interesting, but the culture change might also shock the hell out of you. Shanghai is a great deal more than bright lights and new money, just as New York is. Don't offend a great city by trying to categorise it.
Second, Shanghainese is not a language you would want to learn, but except for shopkeepers most people speak good Putonghua. And there is another advantage here - you will meet people from every province in China and can get coaching from those with the best pronunciation and the cleanest accents. You won't find that in most other cities. And some of the Beijing accent - the nasal twang, the 'r' they add to words, and the manner of making sounds in the back of their throat -is really annoying to me. You might find it the same. And going to Dalian because people speak Japanese is not sensible; that isn't a useful reason for living there.
Also, many Shanghainese speak excellent English and they will welcome you. Someone made a comment about how it's difficult to avoid ending up with foreigners in this city because the locals leave you out of the picture. I've lived in Shanghai for years, and I have almost no foreign friends - I spend all my time with my Chinese friends, local or otherwise. We travel together, we do everything together. With foreigners, I have lunch. With my Chinese friends, I live my life. If I want to live with foreigners, I can go home.
Third, the money in Shanghai is probably the best in China. Yes the cost of living will be higher than in the second-tier cities, but so is the income. The people who complain about money in Shanghai are those who would have reason to complain about money in every other city. Forget about the cost of living and just choose a place where you want to live. The income takes care of the living cost, no matter where you are.
It's not difficult to earn 20,000 or 25,000 a month here. Corporate training is easy and profitable here - 250 RMB per hour is easy to find, and if you are better than average you can do better than that. You said that your bottom line for income is 7,000 RMB per month. You might want to raise your sights. In Shanghai, I pay more than that for rent each month, and I save more than 100,000 each year. You won't do that in many other places.
Fourth, someone told you that English teachers are a dime a dozen here. I think you should consider that some kinds of people are a dime a dozen everywhere, and others are rare everywhere.
Next, many of the places you are considering are COLD. It won't kill you, but being warm may be more enjoyable for you.
Finally, I would tell you that I've travelled through much of China and I do enjoy almost every place I've been. But I am content to live in Shanghai and visit those other places. I cannot conceive of a finer or better home base here, and the attractions of other ciites and smaller centers may not be sufficient to compensate.
I don't want to push you into Shanghai if you have other interests, but it seems to me that your first impression of a city of choice may have been the correct one and you let your doubts put you off. Shanghai is a very liveable city.
Good Luck to you.
. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
Laurence
Joined: 26 Apr 2005 Posts: 401
|
Posted: Tue Jan 13, 2009 7:19 am Post subject: |
|
|
Hi NoA
Quote: |
I am eager to improve my Putonghua |
This won't be dependent on your location. They speak Putonghua everywhere. Personally, I like the Shanghai/Zhejiang accent the most - much more than the rear palette Beijing 'standard'. Perhaps it might be a good idea to avoid Guangdong province (because of the prevalence of Cantonese), although I live here and I use mandarin daily.
Big cities might have more foriegners and English speakers, but you're more likely to find locals with whom you have a genuine connection. I spent a little time in a small city - I found it was little use (from a language learning perspective) to be immersed in an environment where it was difficult to form natural, mutual, symmetrical relationships. Although I did end up studying characters - there wasn't much else to do!
My point is that I wouldn't narrow my options for the sake of the local mandarin accent. Just MHO.
Also,
Quote: |
bright lights and new money |
This is part of Chinese culture. It's interesting. Lujiazui is very much 'real China', much more than synthetically old style places like Yangshuo.
Yeah I hear nice things about Dalian, often, it looks like an interesting landscape. Aim for 10k+ pcm if you can, unless it's a 16 hours a week sort of deal.
Good luck |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
Voldermort

Joined: 14 Apr 2004 Posts: 597
|
Posted: Tue Jan 13, 2009 10:19 am Post subject: |
|
|
Laurence wrote: |
They speak Putonghua everywhere. Personally, I like the Shanghai/Zhejiang accent the most - much more than the rear palette Beijing 'standard'. Perhaps it might be a good idea to avoid Guangdong province (because of the prevalence of Cantonese), although I live here and I use mandarin daily. |
I have to disagree with you there. There is a vast difference between an accent and a dialect. I live and work in Sichuan where the locals speak the Sichuan dialect of Chinese. This is similar in some ways to Putonghua but the vocabulary is not. Sure they may use the same standard characters but the language is not standard. For example, in Putonghua to call a waiter you would say/shout 服务员 (Fuwuyuan) whereas in Sichuan you would say 小妹儿 (Xiaomeier translates to little sister).
In addition to that look at the languages used by some of the minorities. The Yi people spring to mind. I cannot understand a single word of what they say but I'm sure R2D2 would (The language to me consists mainly of 'beeps' and 'bobs'). Though I have been told they use only 700 of the standard characters. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
Sly22
Joined: 29 Jan 2007 Posts: 51
|
Posted: Tue Jan 13, 2009 3:04 pm Post subject: |
|
|
bearcanada wrote: |
OP, you've been given some advice that is too far off the mark and you may make a decision about location that you will regret later.
First of all, Shanghai is one of the most interesting and exciting cities in the world, and for sure it is much more international than many others. It is one of the easiest places for a foreigner to become acclimatised and to adjust. You would indeed find other places interesting, but the culture change might also shock the hell out of you. Shanghai is a great deal more than bright lights and new money, just as New York is. Don't offend a great city by trying to categorise it.
Second, Shanghainese is not a language you would want to learn, but except for shopkeepers most people speak good Putonghua. And there is another advantage here - you will meet people from every province in China and can get coaching from those with the best pronunciation and the cleanest accents. You won't find that in most other cities. And some of the Beijing accent - the nasal twang, the 'r' they add to words, and the manner of making sounds in the back of their throat -is really annoying to me. You might find it the same. And going to Dalian because people speak Japanese is not sensible; that isn't a useful reason for living there.
Also, many Shanghainese speak excellent English and they will welcome you. Someone made a comment about how it's difficult to avoid ending up with foreigners in this city because the locals leave you out of the picture. I've lived in Shanghai for years, and I have almost no foreign friends - I spend all my time with my Chinese friends, local or otherwise. We travel together, we do everything together. With foreigners, I have lunch. With my Chinese friends, I live my life. If I want to live with foreigners, I can go home.
Third, the money in Shanghai is probably the best in China. Yes the cost of living will be higher than in the second-tier cities, but so is the income. The people who complain about money in Shanghai are those who would have reason to complain about money in every other city. Forget about the cost of living and just choose a place where you want to live. The income takes care of the living cost, no matter where you are.
It's not difficult to earn 20,000 or 25,000 a month here. Corporate training is easy and profitable here - 250 RMB per hour is easy to find, and if you are better than average you can do better than that. You said that your bottom line for income is 7,000 RMB per month. You might want to raise your sights. In Shanghai, I pay more than that for rent each month, and I save more than 100,000 each year. You won't do that in many other places.
Fourth, someone told you that English teachers are a dime a dozen here. I think you should consider that some kinds of people are a dime a dozen everywhere, and others are rare everywhere.
Next, many of the places you are considering are COLD. It won't kill you, but being warm may be more enjoyable for you.
Finally, I would tell you that I've travelled through much of China and I do enjoy almost every place I've been. But I am content to live in Shanghai and visit those other places. I cannot conceive of a finer or better home base here, and the attractions of other ciites and smaller centers may not be sufficient to compensate.
I don't want to push you into Shanghai if you have other interests, but it seems to me that your first impression of a city of choice may have been the correct one and you let your doubts put you off. Shanghai is a very liveable city.
Good Luck to you.
. |
Some good points, actually all my chinese friends here are from outside shanghai (3 from anhui, one from xian and one from beijing). I have been here for 2 years and it seems every 'friendship' I have had with a shanghainese included them insisting on speaking english with me, then turning to friends and speaking in shanghainese, which i find really denigrating.
I made my reply above on the premise you were looking for a good city to go to and learn chinese - which shanghai is a bad choice. Shanghai is a great city, I wouldn't be here if I didn't like it, but I beleive I would have made alot faster progress learning chinese if I had lived in a smaller city with putonghua being the commonly used language.
The office I work in right now, I am the only foreginer, and worse I'm the only non-shanghainese. Everyone speaks to me in mandarin, but unfortunatley all discussions and water cooler talk is in shanghainese. I get along great with all of them but I can't help but laugh and think about people warning me before coming here that its a bad city to come to learn Mandarin.
Its true, Shanghai is a great city, lots of fun and very interesting.
Its also true, you will learn chinese much faster in shanghai than you will in say... New York, London, or Rome. But you won't learn faster than you would in say, Beijing, Ningbo, or Qingdao. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
Sonnibarger
Joined: 15 May 2007 Posts: 320 Location: Wuhan
|
Posted: Tue Jan 13, 2009 3:09 pm Post subject: |
|
|
have you considered Qingdao? The speak fairly standard chinese in Shangdong... the city is clean with lots of Japanese living there. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
daveups
Joined: 07 Jan 2009 Posts: 27 Location: Lost somewhere in Zhongguo!
|
Posted: Sat Jan 17, 2009 10:56 pm Post subject: |
|
|
You'll have lots of choices with your credentials and experience. If you're serious about studying Mandarin, choose somewhere in the NE. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
|
This page is maintained by the one and only Dave Sperling. Contact Dave's ESL Cafe
Copyright © 2018 Dave Sperling. All Rights Reserved.
Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2002 phpBB Group
|