|
Korean Job Discussion Forums "The Internet's Meeting Place for ESL/EFL Teachers from Around the World!"
|
View previous topic :: View next topic |
Author |
Message |
bellum99

Joined: 23 Jan 2003 Location: don't need to know
|
Posted: Sun Apr 29, 2007 3:08 pm Post subject: Who breaks the contract more? |
|
|
We all know the school owners break the contract...but don't many teachers break it all the time. They often don't do a good job, don't act in a professional manner, and couldn't care less about the job. I see teachers slacking off and dragging their butts every single time. The contracts usually stipulate the attitude teachers should have. Perhaps we break the contract every single day (in the eyes of the owners).
I would fire most teachers I see if I was in Canada...without a thought. I have seen some lazy teachers and then they are surprised when at the end of the contract they are screwed. They have bad attitudes about every little thing and never do anything other than what is clearly written in the contract. I am sometimes the same but if I was an owner...I would hate the English teachers. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
TOMODACHI-KID

Joined: 24 Apr 2007 Location: LAND OF THE RISING SUN: TAKASAGO-KATSUSHIKA
|
Posted: Sun Apr 29, 2007 5:07 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Two sides of the coin here, huh...
Sure, there are teachers who "slack" as you mention, but who always draws first blood, eh? Hands down, it's the Directors! You can count on these "Directors" tweaking some aspect of your contract, or pulling some type of bull-crap on you, whether it be not disciplining a student for you, which makes your job even harder, or your basic "mind games" these Hogwon bosses play on you. The list goes on! Hence, the actions of many teachers.
And the reason why teachers don't do any "other thing," as you mentioned, that's not clearly in the contract is because:
1. Why should they (we). What is written is written, nothing more. This is what a contract is for--to do what you have to do, yes? A contract is there, supposedly, to protect us from, per say, washing the director's car on Sundays...you get me....
2. Hogwon bosses will take major advantage of a teacher. If you give them a little, they take everything!
3. Does the term "Save Ass" ring a bell, especially in a foreign country.
_____________________________________________________________
"Some people never change,
what truly horrible lives they must lead."  |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
mack4289

Joined: 06 Dec 2006
|
Posted: Sun Apr 29, 2007 7:47 pm Post subject: Re: Who breaks the contract more? |
|
|
bellum99 wrote: |
We all know the school owners break the contract...but don't many teachers break it all the time. They often don't do a good job, don't act in a professional manner, and couldn't care less about the job. I see teachers slacking off and dragging their butts every single time. The contracts usually stipulate the attitude teachers should have. Perhaps we break the contract every single day (in the eyes of the owners).
I would fire most teachers I see if I was in Canada...without a thought. I have seen some lazy teachers and then they are surprised when at the end of the contract they are screwed. They have bad attitudes about every little thing and never do anything other than what is clearly written in the contract. I am sometimes the same but if I was an owner...I would hate the English teachers. |
In an indirect way, the history of mistreatment of English teachers leads to the kind of teachers you describe. Korea makes very attractive job offers, so why can't they get better teachers? At least partly because everyone knows the horror stories. Combine Korea's bad reputation with the rapidly expanding English hagwan business that creates such a huge need for teachers, and you have a situation where the hagwans really have to hire just anyone.
So yeah there are a lot of lazy English teachers who are basically stealing their companies' money. But Korean hagwons complaining about that is kind of like teachers who don't enforce any rules complaining about their students misbehaving. If they really want changes:
1. let us own our visas, which will force hagwon owners to treat foreign teachers better, which will improve Korea's reputation and help them attract better teachers.
2. Enforce the law requiring hagwon owners to have TEFL certificates.
3. Open the education market. I don't know how protected it is here, but this makes me think there aren't many opportunities for foreign ownership of a hagwon: "The opening of the education market should be performed in stages by considering the impact of the opening and operation of foreign educational institutions, employment of foreign instructors and recognition of the degrees earned in those institutions on the domestic market. At first, the approval needs to be restricted to non-profit corporations in free economic zones or education action zones and then be expanded to for-profit corporations." http://english.president.go.kr/cwd/en/archive/archive_view.php?meta_id=en_infocus&category=170&id=419e65a9f0cb97818d3f2a84. With foreign ownership could come advanced teaching methods, which, if they caught on beyond the foreign owned hagwons, would create a need for more qualified teachers.
4. Ditch the Three Nos. If every student didn't have to pass the same exam to get into universities and universities were allowed to cater to whatever sort of students they wanted, that might bring down some of the demand for hagwons because it would give the less motivated students some breathing room.
Here's my guess why these things haven't happened: the quality of education at English hagwons doesn't really matter. Parents are happy to drop their kids off there and let them recite English mindlessly and have Korean English teachers who almost never use English. Many of them don't know English so how can they tell what their kid is or isn't learning? They write the same 10 words fifty times in a notebook and that's the evidence. We're glorified babysitters and English hagwons are glorified day-care. If it really mattered how well we did our job, would there be new English hagwons opening up every day despite the lack of qualified native speakers? The problems will never change without structural changes in the Korean education and immigration systems. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
ontheway
Joined: 24 Aug 2005 Location: Somewhere under the rainbow...
|
Posted: Sun Apr 29, 2007 9:22 pm Post subject: |
|
|
mack4289
here is no rule requiring hogwan owners to have TEFL certificates. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
ontheway
Joined: 24 Aug 2005 Location: Somewhere under the rainbow...
|
Posted: Sun Apr 29, 2007 9:39 pm Post subject: |
|
|
The Wonjangnim at my hogwan has never broken a single term of any contract with any teacher. In fact, the Wonjangnim always gives more and goes beyond the contract.
The school really teaches the kids. This might be rare in Korea. As a result, some teachers who think coming to Korea is just a vacation - time to have fun playing with cute kiddies - are startled to find out they actually have to work and teach. So, we had problems with one horrible teacher - lazy, low intelligence, unable to teach simple elementary school things. Naturally, the recruiter had told the school she was really great. That teacher broke the contract in many ways and probably shouldn't be a teacher at all.
Quality is another problem. Teachers with degrees in serious subjects: the sciences, engineering, medicine are the best. Teachers who are English majors and have TEFL or some other certificate seem to be serious, but, so far at this school, have not been as smart as the students, so they have been unable to perform at the high level required.
It's really hard to weed out the bad teachers by telephone interview. It would be much better for schools if the teachers owned their own visas. A good school could hire away the good teachers from the bad schools. This would mean the bad teachers could be fired on the spot and replaced with good ones, at higher pay. The bad teachers would be unemployed and driven out of Korea, or left only bad schools to work at. The bad schools would have only bad teachers or no teachers as the good ones would get hired away, or quit to find new jobs. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
mack4289

Joined: 06 Dec 2006
|
Posted: Sun Apr 29, 2007 9:54 pm Post subject: |
|
|
ontheway wrote: |
mack4289
here is no rule requiring hogwan owners to have TEFL certificates. |
Sorry I misunderstood this: ""The sector is totally unregulated, and that�s the problem," says Tom Davidson, who runs the EFL-law.com website, which offers legal advice to English teachers working in Asia. The idea is that everyone should have a recognised Tefl certificate, but (the government) just can�t get it off the ground," he says, adding: "Anyone can set up a school, any time. The owner doesn�t have to know anything about teaching; they just need a licence." http://www.educationworldonline.net/eduworld/article.php?choice=prev_art&article_id=436&issueid=33. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
flint
Joined: 11 Apr 2004
|
Posted: Sun Apr 29, 2007 10:29 pm Post subject: Re: Who breaks the contract more? |
|
|
bellum99 wrote: |
We all know the school owners break the contract...but don't many teachers break it all the time. They often don't do a good job, don't act in a professional manner, and couldn't care less about the job. I see teachers slacking off and dragging their butts every single time. The contracts usually stipulate the attitude teachers should have. Perhaps we break the contract every single day (in the eyes of the owners).
I would fire most teachers I see if I was in Canada...without a thought. I have seen some lazy teachers and then they are surprised when at the end of the contract they are screwed. They have bad attitudes about every little thing and never do anything other than what is clearly written in the contract. I am sometimes the same but if I was an owner...I would hate the English teachers. |
Dunno what contract you signed but none of mine other said the teacher MUST have a positive demeanour at all times or stipulated any other attitude.
Now I did work at a hellish hagwon once where they ordered a teacher to look happy or they would fire him. The reason he looked unhappy was the b*tch of an owner had told him he was a bad teacher (which was BS he was one of the best we had) and that the Korean teachers didn't want to work with him anymore. (which was also BS) In the teachers room he looked miserable, and had stopped talking to the Koreans. Outside the teachers room he forced a smile.
If a school is treating you well and running properly you won't have a negative attitude about them. One that dictates you have a positive attitude all the time is just looking for a tool to use to get rid of teachers they don't like, or to use for an 11th hour firing. A tool which allow them to break the contract while making it look like it was your fault.
As a previous poster mentioned, often (but NOT always) the bad attitude of teachers can be attributed to how the school treats them, and how many lies they told to get the person to sign.
Case in point, a friend of mine who returned to Korea a couple of months ago. He now has a bad attitude about his hagwon and is considering the slacking off method of work. Why? The hagwon has decided that they won't pay overtime even though it is in the contract. Then they started treating him like crap because a) he dared ask for his overtime and b) the other teachers are now asking for their overtime. He was thinking about quiting and finding a new job. The director told him that if he did they would not give him a Letter fo Release. (Yes, he should go to labour office and fight it but that isn't what this thread is about.) So they want to force him to continue working there. Of course he would slack off and/or have a bad attitude. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
flint
Joined: 11 Apr 2004
|
Posted: Mon Apr 30, 2007 6:16 am Post subject: |
|
|
After pondering this question I still believe that the hagwon owners do it more. Which isn't to say teachers aren't to blame. In my time here I can think of 2 teachers I knew of who broke their contracts. One because she prefered to work in the city her BF was at, the other because, well he was a more than a little strange.
I have known many who have quit (thus breaking their contract) or pulled runners. In those cases they did it as a direct result of the owner treating them like dirt or breaking the contract themslves. (One of the reasons I say the teacher broke the contract is because they never went after the hagwon for their contract violations, they just ran or quit. Thus breaking the contract. What can I say, I don't feel like arguing sermantics.)
Once you say no to some (most?) hagwon owners that is the kiss of death. We need you to work Saturday even though it isn't in your contract. No. You are now a bad teacher. They will then (and I experienced this first and second hand (happened to a friend)) do their best to make you want to quit. They poison the work atmosphere, one of their first ways of doing this is by trying to turn you and the Korean teachers against each other) and generally try to make your work life miserable. Until it comes to the point that you quit. If you don't reach that point quickly enough they will ask you to quit. If that doesn;t work they will fire you for no just cause.
It happens from both ends, that is true. But it happens more from the hagwon end.
The best thing I could say about one of the hagwons I worked at is that they only ripped me off a little. They charged me 6% income tax (which I didn't know at the time should have been 3.3%) and didn't pay pension (which, again, I never knew they should pay). Other than that they were good to work for. Mind you isn't it more than a little sad that the best thing most people can say good about the hagwon they worked at is that they only ripped them off a little?
Sorry to digress, but it was something this thread made me think of. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
TOMODACHI-KID

Joined: 24 Apr 2007 Location: LAND OF THE RISING SUN: TAKASAGO-KATSUSHIKA
|
Posted: Mon Apr 30, 2007 5:25 pm Post subject: |
|
|
FLINT WROTE--
Quote: |
After pondering this question I still believe that the hagwon owners do it more. Which isn't to say teachers aren't to blame. In my time here I can think of 2 teachers I knew of who broke their contracts. One because she prefered to work in the city her BF was at, the other because, well he was a more than a little strange.
I have known many who have quit (thus breaking their contract) or pulled runners. In those cases they did it as a direct result of the owner treating them like dirt or breaking the contract themslves. (One of the reasons I say the teacher broke the contract is because they never went after the hagwon for their contract violations, they just ran or quit. Thus breaking the contract. What can I say, I don't feel like arguing sermantics.)
Once you say no to some (most?) hagwon owners that is the kiss of death. We need you to work Saturday even though it isn't in your contract. No. You are now a bad teacher. They will then (and I experienced this first and second hand (happened to a friend)) do their best to make you want to quit. They poison the work atmosphere, one of their first ways of doing this is by trying to turn you and the Korean teachers against each other) and generally try to make your work life miserable. Until it comes to the point that you quit. If you don't reach that point quickly enough they will ask you to quit. If that doesn;t work they will fire you for no just cause.
It happens from both ends, that is true. But it happens more from the hagwon end.
The best thing I could say about one of the hagwons I worked at is that they only ripped me off a little. They charged me 6% income tax (which I didn't know at the time should have been 3.3%) and didn't pay pension (which, again, I never knew they should pay). Other than that they were good to work for. Mind you isn't it more than a little sad that the best thing most people can say good about the hagwon they worked at is that they only ripped them off a little?
Sorry to digress, but it was something this thread made me think of.
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Good stuff, Flint!!! |
No digression at all. Every nuance is connected when it comes to the revelation of these owners/bosses/low-level mafia types! |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
Summer Wine
Joined: 20 Mar 2005 Location: Next to a River
|
Posted: Mon Apr 30, 2007 7:23 pm Post subject: |
|
|
I know of one case where by the teacher was fired and had their visa quickly sold to another school who were desperate for a teacher. They then went around and told all the students and other teachers that he quit and ran away. So being told a teacher did a runner, doesn't always mean they did.
Bosses can use any excuse they want once the teacher has left. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
TOMODACHI-KID

Joined: 24 Apr 2007 Location: LAND OF THE RISING SUN: TAKASAGO-KATSUSHIKA
|
Posted: Mon Apr 30, 2007 9:27 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Summer Wine wrote:
Quote: |
I know of one case where by the teacher was fired and had their visa quickly sold to another school who were desperate for a teacher. They then went around and told all the students and other teachers that he quit and ran away. So being told a teacher did a runner, doesn't always mean they did.
Bosses can use any excuse they want once the teacher has left.
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Yes, this type of action is all too common, and oh so messed up! In the Korean culture there is a term called, "saving face." Many of you teachers know this as I do. At any rate, Hogwon, Hakwon, Hagwon bosses will come up with an absurd lie about a teacher--to make that teacher look really bad, and they (the bosses) look innocent and worthy. When some conflict arises where the teacher leaves, this scenario or another scenario is presented to the students and to the other teachers who don't really know what is going on. This other scenario is where the bosses/owners just don't bring up the matter to anyone...SAVING FACE...
good info as well, Summer Wine...
|
|
|
Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
|
|