I've heard of that in Korea, just forgot about it. Given it's a communal culture very concerned with conforming and what other people think, punishment by that kind of humiliation would be very effective. And very over the top. Imagine being brought up in that kind of family atmosphere, where that's possible. And guess who'll be harsh like that to her kids. The once shaven one. And I call this one, Mongolian justice.
Maybe the girl did something really bad, as that does sound like a harsh punsihment for a teenage girl in Korea. In the west her peers might even say, wow, cool. In Korea I can imagine they might not be so accepting, but may understand why.
Joined: 01 Aug 2004 Location: Darwin, Northern Territory, Australia
Posted: Wed Dec 01, 2004 1:49 am Post subject:
What if said girl is starting to become sexually active? What if Mum and Dad have done everything they can think of to stop her but it's just not working? What if they're under a great deal of stress, and fear for their daughter having to go through a teenage pregnancy? Wouldn't her chances of getting pregnant be reduced if she had an undesirable looking shaved head?
Posted: Wed Dec 01, 2004 1:46 pm Post subject: on a Korean drama
I saw where an older brother tried to shave the head his younger sister. They were in their 20's. It was because she was dating a divorced man and had brought shame to the family. I am sure that is not the case with this girl. I am not sure of her age. It sounds like she did something to bring shame to the family. Probably failed to get all A's.
Posted: Wed Dec 01, 2004 3:59 pm Post subject: some of my students would prefer the buzz
Remember there's that Korean singer these days with a short-as hair do. Many of my older students would rather get the cut than face not being able to sit down - as at least one of them reports this happens a lot in her house - or being punched on the side of her head by her dad.
And yes, I told my supervisor who is very open-minded and she said there's nothing we can do.
In my class, humiliation works a treat and is better than penalising students. I take away phones, mp3 players, notebooks, school textbooks all the time. I make them go and tell the girls at reception what they have done, or give them a special seat at the front and make them answer every question.
I think in this case it all depends on what the student has done. I think its pretty extreme, but at least she can still walk. Some of these spoiled kids need to face what they have done IF it is that bad. If its not bad, then the parents are cruel without a doubt.
Posted: Wed Dec 01, 2004 4:03 pm Post subject: Re: some of my students would prefer the buzz
littlefish_bighook wrote:
I take away phones, mp3 players, notebooks, school textbooks all the time.
I used to put them in the closet and make them pray to the good lord Jesus for forgiveness. I'd also call them dirty girls and belittle their self esteem.
Either that or I watched Carrie again last night and was impressed with the mothering displayed.
Wouldn't her chances of getting pregnant be reduced if she had an undesirable looking shaved head?
... somehow I don't think this would work for teenagers. It would basically be like advertising to every young male in her school that "this girl puts out".
... somehow I don't think this would work for teenagers. It would basically be like advertising to every young male in her school that "this girl puts out".
FAQ
Search
Memberlist
Usergroups
Register
Profile
Log in to check your private messages
Log in
