|
Korean Job Discussion Forums "The Internet's Meeting Place for ESL/EFL Teachers from Around the World!"
|
| View previous topic :: View next topic |
| Author |
Message |
rapier
Joined: 16 Feb 2003
|
Posted: Sun Sep 05, 2004 3:38 am Post subject: |
|
|
| As I say, for things to change, it'll mean that mixed kids should attend Korean schools. That way people will become aware of the racism. But who is going to be first to allow their kids to be guinea pigs, human sacrifices, the pioneers of muticulturalism in this country? |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
kiwiboy_nz_99

Joined: 05 Jul 2003 Location: ...Enlightenment...
|
Posted: Sun Sep 05, 2004 3:45 am Post subject: |
|
|
| LMG wrote: |
| for a mixed person, your thread title is incredibly offensive. |
She is imitating the attitude of Koreans she has encountered, not speaking "as herself".
| Quote: |
and if u were born in the states then your fellow teachers are right, u are american not chinese. |
People are allowed to define thier own identity. If she says she's Chinese American then that's what she is. Saying she's "American", while technically correct because that word defines nationality not ethnicity, does not fully define her. You're being pedantic.
| Quote: |
and half-korean kids don't have to go to different countries to go to school, whoever told u that is full of *beep*. |
NOWHERE in the OP did she suggest that mixed kids have to do this, making this statement redundant. She did suggest that mixed kids get a hard time here in Korea, and she is utterly correct about that.
| Quote: |
when i was in korea, none of the koreans that i met with had any problem grasping the fact that i was american with parents of different races. |
Translation: "What I experience defines the totality of reality". Or, "If I don't have a problem then you don't have a problem".
| Quote: |
while many ppl in america have hang-ups about "one-dropism" it's not exactly like that in korea or asia. |
Quite correct, it's much worse in Korea.
| Quote: |
telling them u have one parent that's chinese and another that's non-chinese they will understand. |
Clearly she has done that already, and clearly they didn't understand.
| Quote: |
telling them u are "chinese" makes no sense because one u are mixed and second u are not from china. |
NOWHERE in the OP did she even come close to suggesting that she told them she was "Chinese", making this statement redundant. She told them she was "Chinese American", which is true, and completely different from saying she was "Chinese".
| Quote: |
the way u write makes me so depressed. |
Likewise.
| Quote: |
there's nothing wrong with being american. |
NOWHERE in the OP did she even come close to suggesting that she felt there was anything wrong with being american. There is something wrong, however, with having half your identity denied because of someone elses ignorance.
Your post was full of falsehoods and false assumptions. It was also offensive. I have relieved you of your false assumptions. Thank me for it, you're now a better person. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
peppermint

Joined: 13 May 2003 Location: traversing the minefields of caddishness.
|
Posted: Sun Sep 05, 2004 3:46 am Post subject: |
|
|
I think part of the change needs to come from the teachers themselves. It's not just the mixed kids that get treated badly, it seems like there's a kid who's outcast in every class, and the teachers tolerate this.
As well, the Korean teachers union has a reputation for being one of the most conservative groups in the nation ( Not all public school teachers belong to it though) There have been controversies in the past with them producing tests with very anti American and anti Japanese content. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
little mixed girl
Joined: 11 Jun 2003 Location: shin hyesung's bed~
|
Posted: Sun Sep 05, 2004 1:03 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| kiwiboy_nz_99 wrote: |
She is imitating the attitude of Koreans she has encountered, not speaking "as herself".
|
the person said asian halfbreeds. u can use a different title. it's not that hard.
| Quote: |
People are allowed to define thier own identity. If she says she's Chinese American then that's what she is. Saying she's "American", while technically correct because that word defines nationality not ethnicity, does not fully define her. You're being pedantic.
|
a person can define their identity, but they can't erase what they are.
you're just starting fights cuz u have nothing better to do...
| Quote: |
NOWHERE in the OP did she suggest that mixed kids have to do this, making this statement redundant. She did suggest that mixed kids get a hard time here in Korea, and she is utterly correct about that.
|
why don't i show u:
| Quote: |
| Initially, I was shocked and upset. But at a party last night I heard that Korean children that are mixed usually have to go to other countries to go to school, or a special international school for foreigners... |
| Quote: |
Translation: "What I experience defines the totality of reality". Or, "If I don't have a problem then you don't have a problem".
|
the poster asked about other people...plz go back and refresh your reading comprehension skills.
| Quote: |
Quite correct, it's much worse in Korea.
|
it depends on the person.
| Quote: |
Clearly she has done that already, and clearly they didn't understand.
|
let's re-read:
| Quote: |
"You are not Chinese, you are American."
This is what three Korean teachers said to me at my school. I am half Chinese American. I identify with being Chinese American yet the teachers have repeatedly told me that I am just American, not Chinese...i don't look Chinese to them, I am not from China, etc. |
being "idetified" as "chinese" makes no sense to them.
those things can pass in america or european countries that have a history of saying "anyone with 'non-white blood' is a minority".
going to korea with that mind-set is not going to work.
| Quote: |
NOWHERE in the OP did she even come close to suggesting that she told them she was "Chinese", making this statement redundant. She told them she was "Chinese American", which is true, and completely different from saying she was "Chinese".
|
look above.
[quoteLikewise.
[/quote]
then plz stop replying to my posts as the mods have suggested... =)
| Quote: |
NOWHERE in the OP did she even come close to suggesting that she felt there was anything wrong with being american. There is something wrong, however, with having half your identity denied because of someone elses ignorance. |
it's nothing about having identity denied.
it's like me going to korea and saying "my dad is white so i am too".
it makes no sense because even if my dad is white, my mom is not. and to top it off i don't look white.
going to korea and telling people that i am mixed is something they can grasp. hell, i've said american too when people tried to guess where i was from and they had no problem with it.
| Quote: |
| Your post was full of falsehoods and false assumptions. It was also offensive. I have relieved you of your false assumptions. Thank me for it, you're now a better person. |
^ take your own advice son.
there was a girl at my dorm over the summer who was not mixed, but was "indian". and she had to go and explain things to the other AMERICANS in the dorm that her grandparents were from india, her parents were from africa and she was born in england.
if u want people to understand you, you have to take the extra step to explain things to them.
if the original poster just wants the people at his/her work to call him/her "chinese" then they also have to go into the politics behind that decision and such. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Ryst Helmut

Joined: 26 Apr 2003 Location: In search of the elusive signature...
|
Posted: Sun Sep 05, 2004 1:04 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Scott in HK wrote: |
peppermint
| Quote: |
| I'm assumeing as a caring parent, you wouldn't want your kids to grow up being treated like that. |
So, I am still not a caring parent because I intend to send my children to school in Korea. Are you standing by that statement? You don't want to leave room that there is a remote possibility that my kids will have a different experience? Or that perhaps we have thought through our decision and believe that it is important for our children to spend time in Korea at a young age? Or are you going to stick with the rather blanket statement that insults me and every other parent with 'international' children who plan to raise their kids in Korea? Just wondering....
I am also wondering though why my girls are so accpeted by their friends on the street. Now they aren't in school yet, and it may be that things will change..but at the present they seem to have no problem making friends and playing with other children.
Perhaps things are not so black and white.....just perhaps.... |
First off, let me state that I've no children, but when I do, they will indeed be of mixed ethnicity (but called American, period). My wife and I continually debate whether or not we want to raise our children in Korea. Yes, it is a great country for us, great family, great jobs, but....what about our children?
We've met several Amerasian/Eurasian people (kids and adults) that reside(d) in Korea, and we heard by far more horror stories than anything positive.
With that said, I could see how Peppermint would say such a thing. Even if there were no prejudices (overt and preactised), there are numerous other draw backs for children growing up in Korea (quality of life). However, Scott I see your point as well.
I see the early years as a good thing (c'mon, takes a kid a while to learn to hate...ok, become prejudiced...so we've some leeway on time), I mean living in Korea, but things change.
As in anyplace, any child that has a characteristic that is different from the norm is teased. With your/our children living in such a homogeneous country, our kids can only be subjected to infinitely more ridicule....or so I presume.
So my wife and I realised that if we were to spend our professional career working in Korea, our kids would have to take one of these educational paths: home schooling (great educational benefits, depending if child works well under that style), private/international school (ouch, could be bookoo bucks), or military school (or similar).
We've also heard repeatedly that if our children's parents are wealthy, and if they receive high marks, the other kids couldn't/wouldn't tease them. Even if so, common....."oh, I know you think less of me because I am not 100% Korean, but since my parents are richer than yours and I get better grades, you can be my friend."
WTF?
I'd love to be able to reside in Korea, but I just don't want to chance my children (probability factor) being subjected to racism. After all, having my children tell their friends that they are Korean-Panameno-Navajo-British-Canadian-American will probably confuse others.....
Oh well. We'll probably give it a shot.
!Shoosh
Ryst |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Happamitta

Joined: 20 Apr 2004 Location: Seoul, South Korea
|
Posted: Sun Sep 05, 2004 5:11 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Hi Mslaoshi. I don't know of any Eurasian-type organizations where I live (Daegu), and since you said you live somewhere in the boonies, I somehow doubt you'll have much luck in finding anything that might be nearby, unless you're close to Busan or Seoul. At least, nothing comes up in web searches...
It doesn't sound like you've been having a terrible time being in Korea, though - is it just the fact that Koreans don't acknowledge your self-definition of yourself as Chinese-American that bugged you? That's to be expected - lots of folks, Koreans especially, like to call things as they seem to appear. You look mostly white, you said. That being the case, I don't find it at all surprising that Koreans would think of you as anything other than American.
Back in the United States, I knew a few people who had distant Amerindian ancestry.. in some cases, nothing more than a great-great-great-great grandmother who was __(insert tribe name, usually Cherokee though)__. Since they had this oh-so distant Indian forebearer, they saw it fit to consider themselves Native American. One person in particular, one of my college professors, was a red-bearded green-eyed Irish-looking man, a leprechaun of 5' 7" height. He had one incredibly distant Cherokee grandmother (g-g-g-g-gm). And if you asked him, he was 100% Native American, from his lips. He didn't speak Cherokee, didn't look Cherokee, and from my point of view, was just like anyone else with a fascination with any certain culture. He was, btw, teaching a class in Amerindian studies. He said his reason for his self-label was that it was something he willfully chose. Being a non-issue (meaning it has no real repercussions on others), I respected that.
Back then, my hair was long and usually tied up. Being mixed myself (Korean mother, South American father of Hungarian heritage), and with my particular configuration of genes, I looked pretty Native American. Thick black hair, skin light brown from days on the beach, long slanted eyes; even 'real' tribespeople would ask me what tribe I was from.
So, even though I didn't mind what he said he was, I would still look at this professor and, on a few occasions, think to myself, "I don't have a single drop of Indian blood in me, and yet I'm more Indian than this guy. What's his trip about?" Idle minds so like to kick up dust...
So there, like the Koreans who work with you, I ignored the assertions of my prof's self-label, thinking it was nonsensicle, for whatever reason I thought justified that point view. Is it wrong? I don't know. I can say, though, that it's a waste of mental effort, of time. It doesn't do me, him, or anyone else any good. And so in your case, I'd ask, does it matter that others don't label you as you label yourself? If they did as you wished, would it make any real discernible difference in the way they treated you or others? I'd be inclined to say no. You can claim whatever title you prefer for yourself... just don't mind the opinions of others if they differ from your POV on this subject.
On the half-Asian experience in Korea you said you were interesting in hearing about.. well, I can throw in my own quick 2 cents.
As of yet, I haven't experienced a single instance of someone belittling me for my mixed parentage. On those occassions where I have told a Korean about my folks, they seemed to be pleased more than anything else. "Ah, so that's the case... you speak so well! (lie)" says Korean X. I don't claim to be Korean-American, nor did I ever do so. Most of my life I thought of myself simply as a fellow who lived in America, with a Korean Mom and Latin-Euro-oldworld Dad.
Though I've lived around Koreans and Korean-Americans my whole life (and I still regret being the stubborn child who didn't want to speak a single word of Korean), the folks here and the ones there are obviously different in several ways. The Koreans here seem much less visibly happy, for one thing (or maybe it's just Gyeong-sanbukdo?). They also talk like dogs (just Daegu, in this case. Damn the yap-yap satoori), and are incredibly blunt (much less so in Seoul and other parts). And, as many posters have stated, Koreans seem to have little concept of waiting in line; the times when I've been cut in front of being already too numerous to recount. My mother, who just visted me, also stated as much. And there are other things...
Does being mixed have perks? Of course it does. It's all the rage in the fashion world. It's currently 'hip.' You probably have at least snippets of another language that you picked up as you grew up (unless you were a stubborn brat like me who didn't want his mom's language). And there's a good chance you look far-from-ordinary wherever you live (sans Latin America). Does it have its low side? Sure, usually dependant on where you live(d). Mixed kids seem to have a harder time of it in some places rather than others - in my own hometown I hardly experienced any problems beyond those that I constructed for myself. I'm certain that in a homogenous nation like the RoK it would be rougher for a mixed kid to grow up than in tossed-salad West-coast North America. Oh, and you aren't automatically entitled to call any category of people your "people." Unless you choose to.
Mitta.
1. Pali word meaning 'friend'
- Hap(p)amitta |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
little mixed girl
Joined: 11 Jun 2003 Location: shin hyesung's bed~
|
Posted: Mon Sep 06, 2004 5:03 pm Post subject: |
|
|
=(
aww....u can say my name person, i'm not gonna bite.
if u want to tell them u are "chinese", go for it.
but if u know that chinese ppl think that way, then why would u think that koreans would think differently?
it's nothing particular to korea, it's something that happens all over the world. if u call yourself "chinese", but don't look chinese people want an explination.
sorry if it offends you
but even ABCs get the "american" thing.
and like i said, if i decided to identify as white because my dad was white and i was raised in a majority white environment, people are gonna raise their brows and question me because i don't look 'white'.
personally, it just seems to me like u are ashamned to be 1/2 white.
anyways, have fun being chinese but you are going to have to explain your reasoning, because most people are going to press u on it (ie- you don't LOOK chinese). if you are not willing to do that, then u are going to be in for a lot of heartache.
[edit]
i forgot, if u want links:
http://www.mixedfolks.com/
http://www.mixedfolks.com/forum/index.php <--have to be registered to view
http://www.hapas.com/ <--i think there's a lotta racist-type/stuck up ppl on that site, but whatever
http://www.mixedrace.com/ <--really ghetto forum
books:
'what are you? voices of racially mixed young people in america' edited by pearl fuyu gaskins
'racially mixed people in america' edited by maria p. roots
'half and half: authors on growing up biracial and bicultural'
if u want more titles ask. i work at a library. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
girlinseoul
Joined: 15 May 2004 Location: seoul
|
Posted: Tue Sep 07, 2004 3:13 am Post subject: |
|
|
Just wanted to add my two-cents worth. My daughter was born and raised in Canada (she has Canadian nationality, but she is ethnically Korean). She started grade one in March of this year in a Korea public school. She looks every bit Korean as the other students, but she couldn't read, write , or speak Korean like a native. As a result, she was ostracized by her classmates (grade one students!). She has made some good friends now, but in the beginning it was a really difficult time for her. I just wanted to say that even though Korea is changing and becoming more and more global, it's just a little hard for children to be as open-minded and international as adults . By the way, the other mothers made me feel really unwelcome because being Korean-Canadian, I wasn't able to communicate freely with them in Korean. Oh well, having a Korean face but not being able to speak Korean perfectly was my daughter's and my only drawback i guess. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
rapier
Joined: 16 Feb 2003
|
Posted: Tue Sep 07, 2004 5:51 am Post subject: |
|
|
If you accept yourself as you are, there is no need to look to others for acceptance.
In this way, I think being a mixed race schoolkid in Korea would be a character building exercise. If I had children, I would subject them to it, at least for a time. It'd make them stronger, and also ensure they never became racists themselves.
I remember at school in (relatively homogenous) Northern England, there was a "half caste" Thai boy, and another black guy. After several years, they had learned to be really strong, sharp and independent guys, that would not only fight at the drop of a hat, but got all the girls. All because they had to defend themselves against offhand, casual racism from a young age. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
|
|