Dave's ESL Cafe's Student Discussion Forums

[learner12]

Hello, teachers!!

(1) I may work this summer. On the other hand, I may take a long vacation.

(2) I may work this summer. On the contrary, I may take a long vacation

I guess that (1) is correct, but why is (2) wrong? I think that (2) is acceptable in English because I may work this coming summer but I may take a long vacation this coming summer? Do you have any ideas why (2) is wrong?

Thank you in advance.

[pugachevV]

On the other hand is correct. It means "or". e.g. I may work or I may goof off.
On the contrary is used to intensify a denial of what has just been said.
e.g. Father: I suppose you'll be working at MacDonald's again this summer?"
You: "On the contrary: I'm biking around Australia."

[learner12]

Dear pugachevV:

Thank you so much for your logical explanation.

Take care and have a lovely weekend.

[pugachevV]

You're welcome, learner12.