Dave's ESL Cafe's Student Discussion Forums

[klafterreith]

Tom: Last year we visited some cities in Europe: Rome, Paris, London...
Sue: Where else have you been?


Would Sue use present perfect tense or past tense? (were you?)

[pugachevV]

If she asks "Where else have you been?" I would say she is asking where you have been apart from the trip last year.
If she wanted to know what other cities you had visited on last year's trip she would have asked, "Where else did you go?, or "Where else were you?"