Not Only...But Also
Moderators: Dimitris, maneki neko2, Lorikeet, Enrico Palazzo, superpeach, cecil2, Mr. Kalgukshi2
Not Only...But Also
Hello, all! A quick question about paired conjunctions for you grammar mavens out there. Does this sentence sound correct?
Not only the car was stolen but also the bicycle.
I know that usually not only is followed by an aux. verb, as in the following:
Not only was the car stolen, but also the bicycle.
The first example (which sounds acceptable, to my ear) uses a passive structure; it certainly doesn't work if you use not only ... but also with an active voice.
*Not only the thief stole the car, but also the bicycle.
or
*Not only she likes turtles, but also iguanas.
Does anyone agree/disagree that the following are correct?
Not only the car was stolen but also the bicycle.
or
Not only the donuts were eaten but also the cheescake.
Thank you so much for any words of wisdom!
Echidna
Not only the car was stolen but also the bicycle.
I know that usually not only is followed by an aux. verb, as in the following:
Not only was the car stolen, but also the bicycle.
The first example (which sounds acceptable, to my ear) uses a passive structure; it certainly doesn't work if you use not only ... but also with an active voice.
*Not only the thief stole the car, but also the bicycle.
or
*Not only she likes turtles, but also iguanas.
Does anyone agree/disagree that the following are correct?
Not only the car was stolen but also the bicycle.
or
Not only the donuts were eaten but also the cheescake.
Thank you so much for any words of wisdom!
Echidna
Re: Not Only...But Also
I was *about* to say the first example was "wrong" but then I stressed the word "car" and it sounded just fine.Echidna wrote:
Does anyone agree/disagree that the following are correct?
Not only the car was stolen but also the bicycle.
or
Not only the donuts were eaten but also the cheescake.
Thank you so much for any words of wisdom!
Echidna
My first inclination was for Not only was the car stolen, but also the bicycle, noting also that I seemed to have emphasized car there as well, as opposed to Not only was the car stolen, but it was also vandalized. where "stolen" was emphasized and I hijacked your "but also."

So for me, the sentences sound okay as long as the first noun is stressed.
-
- Posts: 922
- Joined: Mon Feb 02, 2004 7:59 pm
- Location: Poland
- Contact:
-
- Posts: 1421
- Joined: Sun May 18, 2003 5:25 pm
-
- Posts: 1421
- Joined: Sun May 18, 2003 5:25 pm