|
Korean Job Discussion Forums "The Internet's Meeting Place for ESL/EFL Teachers from Around the World!"
|
View previous topic :: View next topic |
Author |
Message |
JZer
Joined: 13 Jan 2005 Location: South Korea
|
Posted: Fri May 25, 2007 12:29 am Post subject: |
|
|
Quote: |
See the lineup of upper-level management at many companies, and see how many got their grad degrees abroad. |
Yes, this is true but that does not mean that they are getting hired because they are better. In most spheres of life there is an old boys club. These people have a vested interest in limiting outsiders into the group. There degree would not be worth as much if every Joe from IUP, Baylor, San Diego State could get a top notch job. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
JZer
Joined: 13 Jan 2005 Location: South Korea
|
Posted: Fri May 25, 2007 12:38 am Post subject: |
|
|
Furthermore a family member of mine is president of HUSQVARNA USA. He did not go to any fancy school. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
Yaya

Joined: 25 Feb 2003 Location: Seoul
|
Posted: Fri May 25, 2007 1:11 am Post subject: |
|
|
So JZer, if everyone followed your suspect advice, they'd succeed, eh? Forget going to Harvard, instead learn everything on the street and in life? NOT!
Look, I am NOT saying NOT going to an Ivy League school dooms one to failure, but well, there is a reason why it's so damn hard and competitive to get into the top schools, and that most Koreans with ambition opt to go there. Good for your relative who is president of whatever company you listed, but the numbers say otherwise.
But back to the original post. Korea has a glut of holders of overseas MBAs. Many are doing less than expected work or unsatisfactory jobs. I used to work for a Seoul bank's investor relations team, and many of the peeps there who had MBAs had no great advantage in the promotion system, but of course, the ones with the more prestigious MBAs or advanced degrees (as in FOREIGN and 99% U.S) got preference in promotions. Then again, it was a state-run bank so it could've been different at a private bank.
I do have an Italian friend who speaks five languages who is considering an MBA in Korea or China (he's completely fluent in Chinese). His main priority is to do his MBA in a city he wants to be in, and he says he wants to stay in Asia. To his advantage, he's basically set for life and doing an MBA in either China or Korea will cost much less than in the West. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
JZer
Joined: 13 Jan 2005 Location: South Korea
|
Posted: Fri May 25, 2007 3:39 am Post subject: |
|
|
Quote: |
So JZer, if everyone followed your suspect advice, they'd succeed, eh? Forget going to Harvard, instead learn everything on the street and in life? NOT! |
I am not saying that everyone should follow my advice. Of course it is easier just to go to Harvard if you can.
Quote: |
there is a reason why it's so damn hard and competitive to get into the top schools, and that most Koreans with ambition opt to go there. |
Please take a logic class. Just because everyone does something does not make it true. As Joe Kennedy said, when the shoeshine boy gave him stock advice he knew it was time to sell his stocks. Actually it is the fact that everyone believes in something is probably makes it the most dangerous. I would say that Harvard and elite schools are for the people who want to make a good living but not for the truely ingenious people out there. The Bill Gates of the world are looking for what Harvard grads are not learning.
Of course only one percent or less of us can be Bill Gates, so Harvard is the safe route but yaya don't try to sound off and say it is the best route and that Harvard grads are better.
I will be honest, I wish I could go to Harvard but even if I got into Harvard I would not assume that going to Harvard would make me better than someone who went to Central Flordia. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
Yaya

Joined: 25 Feb 2003 Location: Seoul
|
Posted: Sat May 26, 2007 12:41 am Post subject: |
|
|
Going to Harvard will also expose one to the geniuses out there. Competing against Ivy League talent is DEFINITELY better than against minor league talent like at the Univ. of Central Florida. I'm sure Central Florida attracts bright students, but well, Harvard and the Ivy League are what they are.
Sure, you have the stories of the guy who went to a small college making it as a pro athlete, but that's the rare exception and NOT the norm. Yeah, I guess LeBron James would've gone to the University of Akron instead of Ohio State or another big name school just to prove us wrong, right? NOT! |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
Ozabout7or8
Joined: 04 May 2007 Location: NZ
|
Posted: Sat May 26, 2007 1:32 am Post subject: |
|
|
If you haven't developed the skills or abilities that make you who you are by your mid 20's it is too late.
An Ivy League grad education is no better than any other GOOD programme out there. For most it is simply a badge to get a job, which rightly or wrongly alot of the time works. So the money is not wasted if you want it as a badge. Because that is the way the employment world works.
Doesn't mean that Ivy league education was any better than any other good programme out there, of which there are thousands. People have a need to rank things and pick the best. You will find that for most capable students, there is very little difference between any of hte top 1,000 grad schools other than distance from where they are (I am specifically excluding Korean ones at this stage). |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
postfundie

Joined: 28 May 2004
|
Posted: Sat May 26, 2007 2:04 am Post subject: |
|
|
Quote: |
So you hear of ONE SNU MBA grad who is going to Hong Kong and assume that ALL can do it, and beat out peeps who've done MBAs at Wharton, Harvard and the like? Get a life. I also agree connections are key, and perhaps that is what got the ONE guy his break in Hong Kong (which is HARDLY New York or London and I wouldn't be surprised if he got a job there with a KOREAN company).
I'm not bitter but it's clear YOU ARE considering how defensive you got over my post. Yes, there are success stories about people who stayed in Korea to do their biz master's, but a foreign MBA is leaps and bounds ahead of a Korean one, and well, if you disagree with that, you seriously need your head examined.
And as for Korean being useless outside of Korea, think again. I got jobs others couldn't in Los Angeles because I spoke Korean, and I can probably find work for Korean companies in other countries. So NO, I am not bitter about becoming fluent in Korean (at least I can say I have, unlike many losers in Korea who've stayed here years yet can't get beyond "maekjoo deohjusaeyo"). |
YaYa
I don't have anything against your emphasis on going to an Ivy league school...but I think its more about talent and your ability to pick up information....
Also I think you are running scared of the interview process...A girl working at KDB bank was telling me today about her interview with Samsung and how they had belittled her for her low tests scores but then ended up getting the job because her English was soo good and because she reacted in a positive way to their continual negativity. Then she went on to tell me about a study she read where something like 70% of Koreans had felt belittled during an interview here. It's part of the game. You gotta bounce back when they hit you by showing them what you know. Not whine and cry like a little baby and run around in a circle telling us that the sky is falling.....
For example...what is a Fat tail? which hedge fund manager earned the most money last year..(and I'm talking about a guy who EARNED over a billion dollars) In other areas, who is Daniel McFadden? Which is falling out of use more and more these days, the capital asset pricing model or the Black and Scholes model? and since you worship the IVY league so much...have you read any of the articles by Wharton finance professors....they are on line over at the website.......but hey I guess to be privy to that Knowledge you would HAVE to attend the school? right? (and please don't retort with the truism that it's better to be there..I know this)
I've met dudes that have attended MBA programs in the US and some of them just don't shine...One guy, love him to death, but in English he comes across as a dull twit and can't answer a straightfoward question without 20,000 uhs and ahhs...and he has a darn degree....
You are like a sour puss who says that only handsome guys can get hot chicks....while that may be true on one level it's totally not true on another....
Lastly, don't you think it's a bit odd that you will defend spending your time learning Korean (a great accomplishment I might add) and come down so hard on those getting the MBA???? I like the language and all but it's basically worthless...sure it helped you get some job in LA..oh wait and the MBA could NEVER do that in the states???? Get real! there are way over 27,000 listed companies in the US! Koreans mostly do not want to Speak Korean to you anyway. They'd rather practice their English...Even when you are speaking to some of them, they are thinking 'damn but I want to practice my English'...
ok ciao
PS.
Sorry about being a little harsh here but I think you were down right RUDE to that Belgium boy earlier. English isn't even his first language and you are ripping on him...10 bucks says that when you get going in Korean you are not mistake free...regardless, it's rude to put somebody down like that...and as another poster said..."what's he supposed to do?" pack up wifey and head to America...hahhh he 's getting a basically FREE education here and as long as he supplements it..he should be able to land a good enough job..... |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
Yaya

Joined: 25 Feb 2003 Location: Seoul
|
Posted: Sat May 26, 2007 3:35 am Post subject: |
|
|
postfundie wrote: |
Quote: |
So you hear of ONE SNU MBA grad who is going to Hong Kong and assume that ALL can do it, and beat out peeps who've done MBAs at Wharton, Harvard and the like? Get a life. I also agree connections are key, and perhaps that is what got the ONE guy his break in Hong Kong (which is HARDLY New York or London and I wouldn't be surprised if he got a job there with a KOREAN company).
I'm not bitter but it's clear YOU ARE considering how defensive you got over my post. Yes, there are success stories about people who stayed in Korea to do their biz master's, but a foreign MBA is leaps and bounds ahead of a Korean one, and well, if you disagree with that, you seriously need your head examined.
And as for Korean being useless outside of Korea, think again. I got jobs others couldn't in Los Angeles because I spoke Korean, and I can probably find work for Korean companies in other countries. So NO, I am not bitter about becoming fluent in Korean (at least I can say I have, unlike many losers in Korea who've stayed here years yet can't get beyond "maekjoo deohjusaeyo"). |
YaYa
I don't have anything against your emphasis on going to an Ivy league school...but I think its more about talent and your ability to pick up information....
Also I think you are running scared of the interview process...A girl working at KDB bank was telling me today about her interview with Samsung and how they had belittled her for her low tests scores but then ended up getting the job because her English was soo good and because she reacted in a positive way to their continual negativity. Then she went on to tell me about a study she read where something like 70% of Koreans had felt belittled during an interview here. It's part of the game. You gotta bounce back when they hit you by showing them what you know. Not whine and cry like a little baby and run around in a circle telling us that the sky is falling.....
For example...what is a Fat tail? which hedge fund manager earned the most money last year..(and I'm talking about a guy who EARNED over a billion dollars) In other areas, who is Daniel McFadden? Which is falling out of use more and more these days, the capital asset pricing model or the Black and Scholes model? and since you worship the IVY league so much...have you read any of the articles by Wharton finance professors....they are on line over at the website.......but hey I guess to be privy to that Knowledge you would HAVE to attend the school? right? (and please don't retort with the truism that it's better to be there..I know this)
I've met dudes that have attended MBA programs in the US and some of them just don't shine...One guy, love him to death, but in English he comes across as a dull twit and can't answer a straightfoward question without 20,000 uhs and ahhs...and he has a darn degree....
You are like a sour puss who says that only handsome guys can get hot chicks....while that may be true on one level it's totally not true on another....
Lastly, don't you think it's a bit odd that you will defend spending your time learning Korean (a great accomplishment I might add) and come down so hard on those getting the MBA???? I like the language and all but it's basically worthless...sure it helped you get some job in LA..oh wait and the MBA could NEVER do that in the states???? Get real! there are way over 27,000 listed companies in the US! Koreans mostly do not want to Speak Korean to you anyway. They'd rather practice their English...Even when you are speaking to some of them, they are thinking 'damn but I want to practice my English'...
ok ciao
PS.
Sorry about being a little harsh here but I think you were down right RUDE to that Belgium boy earlier. English isn't even his first language and you are ripping on him...10 bucks says that when you get going in Korean you are not mistake free...regardless, it's rude to put somebody down like that...and as another poster said..."what's he supposed to do?" pack up wifey and head to America...hahhh he 's getting a basically FREE education here and as long as he supplements it..he should be able to land a good enough job..... |
I'm telling it like it is, and well, I guess you like to justify to yourself that learning Korean isn't worthwhile, so go ahead with your justification, however wrong it might be.
Like I said, an Ivy League education doesn't guarantee anything BUT the talented people do go for the best, and just because a few people who did MBAs that YOU met weren't all that, so you're assuming an U.S. MBA is not all that, either? Like I said, look at who the top companies hire, AND don't forget earlier posts from people who do recruiting for conglomerates who say it would be HIGHLY UNLIKELY, though not completely impossible, for them to consider someone who got a Korean MBA over people who got theirs overseas at better programs. So you're glossing over the fact that the major firms like Goldman Sachs can choose the cream of the crop, and probably toss many of the non-top 25 MBA grads? An MBA from a non-top 25 program isn't worth getting PERIOD unless you have absolutely no biz experience. It takes a LOT to go through the trouble of getting in and finishing an MBA from a top 25 program, even if the degree has gotten devalued because of a glut.
I didn't pick on the Belgian guy, he just got sore and defensive because I said getting a Korean MBA isn't the smart thing to do. He later agreed with me that going overseas would've been better but that he wasn't financially able to go, and I was cool with that. I'm just saying getting a Korean MBA is fine just as long as you know what you can and cannot get with it. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
postfundie

Joined: 28 May 2004
|
Posted: Sat May 26, 2007 4:01 am Post subject: |
|
|
Quote: |
So you're glossing over the fact that the major firms like Goldman Sachs can choose the cream of the crop, and probably toss many of the non-top 25 MBA grads? An MBA from a non-top 25 program isn't worth getting PERIOD unless you have absolutely no biz experience. It takes a LOT to go through the trouble of getting in and finishing an MBA from a top 25 program, even if the degree has gotten devalued because of a glut.
I didn't pick on the Belgian guy, he just got sore and defensive because I said getting a Korean MBA isn't the smart thing to do. He later agreed with me that going overseas would've been better but that he wasn't financially able to go, and I was cool with that. I'm just saying getting a Korean MBA is fine just as long as you know what you can and cannot get work |
You scorned his English dude...I doubt you'd take someone heaping ridicule on top of your Korean language skills in front of others. Getting a Korean MBA is the smart thing for him to do. (sure beats sticking around and teaching English pissing away time drinking, especially when you can get the degree for basically free!!)
As for not getting the MBA unless it's from the top 25 schools in the US....probably right...but I think in the end it depends on the person and their skills...again look at Mark Hurd...CEO of HP.....As for Goldman Sachs well they HAVE hired foreigners from Yonsei's GSIS....
You should know that learning Korean is just fine as long as you know what you can and can not do with it...ok joking aside I do admire your Korean skills. I've been studying Korean and I'm an intermediate. This language is a hell of a lot more work than Espanol ever was and its taking a lot of effort...so hat's of to you |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
Yaya

Joined: 25 Feb 2003 Location: Seoul
|
Posted: Sat May 26, 2007 4:43 am Post subject: |
|
|
postfundie wrote: |
Quote: |
So you're glossing over the fact that the major firms like Goldman Sachs can choose the cream of the crop, and probably toss many of the non-top 25 MBA grads? An MBA from a non-top 25 program isn't worth getting PERIOD unless you have absolutely no biz experience. It takes a LOT to go through the trouble of getting in and finishing an MBA from a top 25 program, even if the degree has gotten devalued because of a glut.
I didn't pick on the Belgian guy, he just got sore and defensive because I said getting a Korean MBA isn't the smart thing to do. He later agreed with me that going overseas would've been better but that he wasn't financially able to go, and I was cool with that. I'm just saying getting a Korean MBA is fine just as long as you know what you can and cannot get work |
You scorned his English dude...I doubt you'd take someone heaping ridicule on top of your Korean language skills in front of others. Getting a Korean MBA is the smart thing for him to do. (sure beats sticking around and teaching English pissing away time drinking, especially when you can get the degree for basically free!!)
As for not getting the MBA unless it's from the top 25 schools in the US....probably right...but I think in the end it depends on the person and their skills...again look at Mark Hurd...CEO of HP.....As for Goldman Sachs well they HAVE hired foreigners from Yonsei's GSIS....
You should know that learning Korean is just fine as long as you know what you can and can not do with it...ok joking aside I do admire your Korean skills. I've been studying Korean and I'm an intermediate. This language is a hell of a lot more work than Espanol ever was and its taking a lot of effort...so hat's of to you |
I did scorn his English because it was awful. He couldn't spell to save his life, had grammatical mistakes like crazy and the like. I was thinking he needed proper English instruction more than an business education. And well, he got testy so I did, too.
I guess you're talking about Goldman Sachs Korea, and in that case, I can believe it. But that's still no reason to get a degree from either Yonsei's GSIS or international MBA schools. I remember the Korean government tried to get the GSIS program off and running by pumping in a million dollars, and it did little to nothing for the program. It seems the int'l schools are trying to woo foreigners by offering partial to full scholarships but I don't expect to see any of them on the top 25 rankings within my lifetime.
And yes, Korean is a tough language. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
gruegoo
Joined: 15 Mar 2007 Location: Toronto
|
Posted: Sat May 26, 2007 5:53 am Post subject: |
|
|
Ok things are getting personal, which was not my intention when I started posting to this thread again. The same arguments are being stated over and over again, so lets just agree to disagree.
Regarding Korean MBA's or Non-Korean MBA's with work placements in Korea, can anyone talk about their experiences?
I'm planning on a work placement in Korea and maybe even an exchange with Yonsei and I'd like to get a feel for what it would be like. Is it difficult to work in a Korean company without being completely fluent? (This is of course assuming the company knows it's a work placement from an English program and that my Korean level is about intermediate) |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
postfundie

Joined: 28 May 2004
|
Posted: Sat May 26, 2007 6:55 am Post subject: |
|
|
Quote: |
guess you're talking about Goldman Sachs Korea, and in that case, I can believe it. But that's still no reason to get a degree from either Yonsei's GSIS or international MBA schools. I remember the Korean government tried to get the GSIS program off and running by pumping in a million dollars, and it did little to nothing for the program. It seems the int'l schools are trying to woo foreigners by offering partial to full scholarships but I don't expect to see any of them on the top 25 rankings within my lifetime.
|
Dude you got your blinders on big time...Do you have any clue what's going to be happening to the derivatives market here over the next few years...Are you even aware of the Capital Market Consilidation Act??? Do you know anything about Financial Markets...??
And getting a job in Goldman Sachs isn't a reason to get the Masters' degree??? What are you on? I guess working at a Hagwon or doing small Business English classes is the road to everlasting riches. Ok then how about other people who've gotten jobs at JP Morgan, Merrill Lych, and Citigroup...or others who've started working at the World Bank? Oh no must attend Harvard...must attend Harvard...but hey man my Korean language skills got me a job in LA...great that's an exception to the rule...look at your argument..... |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
JZer
Joined: 13 Jan 2005 Location: South Korea
|
Posted: Sat May 26, 2007 11:18 am Post subject: |
|
|
Quote: |
Like I said, an Ivy League education doesn't guarantee anything BUT the talented people do go for the best, and just because a few people who did MBAs that YOU met weren't all that, so you're assuming an U.S. MBA is not all that, either? |
And you are assuming that some talented people do not go to IVy League schools.
Not to mention that the talented people of this world are not doing the things that are being taught in Ivy League schools. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
pavement burns

Joined: 24 Sep 2006 Location: Pocheon, Kyonggido Korea
|
Posted: Sat May 26, 2007 7:16 pm Post subject: To add fuel to the fire...? |
|
|
To add fuel to the fire...?
This is for the guy who thinks you have to get with the "Ivy League" in your twenties or else? Risk and uncertainty which will effect the big pay-off? Do your research and planning and it will not matter where you study but how you plan for and manage risk, uncertainty, change, negotiation, education, and decision-making at any age and any escuela. It is more about what you put in to your education not where that matters to what you get out. Korea has a batch of risks and uncertainties unique to this nation which can and might effect earning potentials in future education-wise or not.
Korean Trends
ECONOMIC TRENDS: A first trend is in employment where service industries are seen to be rising to 76% of workers as of 2010 from a rate of 72.8 % as of 2004 (Lee, Y.H., 2004: 16) with managers, technical staff and professional categories increasing while semi and low skilled labourers percentages are falling. In addition nearly half the working population is employed in irregular or short term positions, be they temporary or daily contracts which continue to grow implicating not only continued educational programs for youth but necessarily increased retraining programs for aging or mature workers. Further globalization is projected to require more workers with, �analytical, communication and collaboration skills� than currently available (Ibid, 2004: 19). Also a polarization of jobs available in the top 30% and bottom 30% pay ranges has seen a continued reduction in middle income positions which may be a future impediment to continued economic growth. Youth unemployment in itself is also seen to be double the average OECD members at 7.9% as of 2004.
A second trend reveals that interest rates and currency exchange rates with the US dollar will continue to be effected by global considerations such as the price of oil which has affected a downturn in industrial output since the end of 2006 decelerating exports due to weak US demands however supporting continued export trade volumes increases with Europe (Chan, 2007). This trend is considered difficult to determine due to persistent variability however Korea�s policy is described as �independent or free floating� with little interventionist practices according to IMF classifications and there appears little evidence to suggest indirect influences (Frankel, 2003; Bubula & Otker-Robe, 2002 in Willet & Kim, 2006: 6 & 7).
DEMOGRAPHIC TRENDS: A first trend is the declining birth rate found to be one of the lowest in the world at an average of 1.1 children per woman as of 2006 according to the Population Reference Bureau (PRB) (The Korea Times, 2006). Local initiatives to increase the rate of births include parental tax breaks, benefits in the area of social insurance and childcare subsidies. However a United Nations Population Division report in 2000 concluded that the only viable solutions included drastically increasing immigration rates beyond past levels with the dire warning that, "projected population decline and population ageing will have profound and far-reaching consequences, forcing governments to reassess many established economic, social and political policies and programmes, including those relating to international migration." (UN Population Division, 2000 in Wickramasekera, 2000:14). The report also definitively states that international migration is the only option which will effectively reduce declines in the short to mid term to maintain minimum support ratios.
A second trend directly linked to the first is a growing proportion of older workers in the nation which reveals that the percentage of elderly in the population was 9.1% in 2005 increasing to 10.9% by 2010 and to 37.3% by 2050 (Gey, 2006). This trend implicates worker retirement ages and it is suggested prior to 2050 the retirement age should be raised to 85 to mitigate increases in life expectancy which suggest that workers within the next two decades will need to work until the age of 75 and increase senior work support programs due to pension and traditional support services collapse (Staines, 2006).
http://crossculturalreviews.blogspot.com/2007_02_01_archive.html |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
Yaya

Joined: 25 Feb 2003 Location: Seoul
|
Posted: Sun May 27, 2007 12:04 am Post subject: |
|
|
postfundie wrote: |
Quote: |
guess you're talking about Goldman Sachs Korea, and in that case, I can believe it. But that's still no reason to get a degree from either Yonsei's GSIS or international MBA schools. I remember the Korean government tried to get the GSIS program off and running by pumping in a million dollars, and it did little to nothing for the program. It seems the int'l schools are trying to woo foreigners by offering partial to full scholarships but I don't expect to see any of them on the top 25 rankings within my lifetime.
|
Dude you got your blinders on big time...Do you have any clue what's going to be happening to the derivatives market here over the next few years...Are you even aware of the Capital Market Consilidation Act??? Do you know anything about Financial Markets...??
And getting a job in Goldman Sachs isn't a reason to get the Masters' degree??? What are you on? I guess working at a Hagwon or doing small Business English classes is the road to everlasting riches. Ok then how about other people who've gotten jobs at JP Morgan, Merrill Lych, and Citigroup...or others who've started working at the World Bank? Oh no must attend Harvard...must attend Harvard...but hey man my Korean language skills got me a job in LA...great that's an exception to the rule...look at your argument..... |
You must be one of the few people who keep championing Korean MBA programs, so if you're so gungho about it, why not go? I'd also say most will agree that a Korean MBA isn't worth it unless it's paid for (and even that is open to question).
And let me be clear about one thing, I'm not saying an Ivy League MBA is the guaranteed ticket and that people who get degrees from other schools are screwed. The question is whether a Korean MBA is worth it, and my take is a resounding NO, that you can get a much better education abroad (albeit at much higher prices).
And I don't teach or run a hakwon, so I have no idea where the hell you got that from, though I do know people who are making great money teaching English. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
|
|