|
Korean Job Discussion Forums "The Internet's Meeting Place for ESL/EFL Teachers from Around the World!"
|
View previous topic :: View next topic |
Author |
Message |
poeticjustice
Joined: 28 Feb 2009
|
Posted: Sun Jul 19, 2009 12:23 pm Post subject: Where do we fall in the school heirarchy? |
|
|
I was just wondering this. I'm on my second year in my public High School. In my first year few years in Korea, my age kept me from feeling like part of the group simply because I have always been about 5-10 years younger from the mean age of the average teacher at my school.
These days, though, we seem to be getting a lot of new teachers who start off at an age similar to my age now (23/24/25 Western age).
The other day one of my co-teachers innocently mentionned something which was okay for me to do that was not okay for "normal teachers" to do. I always knew I wasn't a "normal teacher", but I also sort of wondered where I was in the big scheme of things.
Since Korea is a country full of hierarchies, where would NETs fall in the public schools?
Considering we are not teachers, we are "native speakers" (완아민) and rarely am I referred to as "teacher" by the students and faculty, does that mean I am considered to be lower in the hierarchy than all the other teachers? Or are we on the same page as the new teachers who just started out (below homeroom teachers)?
If you spend ten years in Korea and build up a wealth of experience (that shows), are you still considered as being at the bottom of the hierarchy if you teach in a PS?
("Native Speaker" is nothing to write home about... It's the same as labelling someone as "he was born and has the ability to communicate"). |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
Demophobe

Joined: 17 May 2004
|
Posted: Sun Jul 19, 2009 2:33 pm Post subject: |
|
|
You typically fall between the cracks. Part of the lowerarchy.
Seriously, there are too many variables in the equation. The principal, staff and you; these can make you a respected part of the team, a marginalized nobody or somewhere in between.
Native speaker means you have a first language and speak it. Save perhaps feral children, everyone is a native speaker.
Last edited by Demophobe on Sun Jul 19, 2009 2:36 pm; edited 1 time in total |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
andrewchon

Joined: 16 Nov 2008 Location: Back in Oz. Living in ISIS Aust.
|
Posted: Sun Jul 19, 2009 2:34 pm Post subject: pecking order |
|
|
Here are plus/minuses for your pecking order
Your Age: Koreans will respect older person +
Years spent at school: if you personally know students due years spent at school, if you know brothers and sisters, even better ++
Do parents know you? inside the school?+ and outside the school. ++
Paper work: NETs don't do much paper work for ministry --
Are you like a son/daughter to Principal/VP? +
Speak Korean? +
Friends with supporting staff? (cleaners/lunch room staff/admin staff/ bus driver/part time teachers) ++
Know Korean history/current events +
Have a Korean spouse? Does the spouse do any volunteer work at school? ++
Do the students like you? +
Do you old-boy network with powerful people? +++
Personal experience: One day 4th year teacher-wannabes came for practicum. After we were introduced, they were scolded for not getting up to bow to me. You can make what ever conclusions from that. I'd say my in-school respect is up but outside I am not. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
Demophobe

Joined: 17 May 2004
|
Posted: Sun Jul 19, 2009 2:40 pm Post subject: Re: pecking order |
|
|
andrewchon wrote: |
Here are plus/minuses for your pecking order
Your Age: Koreans will respect older person +
Years spent at school: if you personally know students due years spent at school, if you know brothers and sisters, even better ++
Do parents know you? inside the school?+ and outside the school. ++
Paper work: NETs don't do much paper work for ministry --
Are you like a son/daughter to Principal/VP? +
Speak Korean? +
Friends with supporting staff? (cleaners/lunch room staff/admin staff/ bus driver/part time teachers) ++
Know Korean history/current events +
Have a Korean spouse? Does the spouse do any volunteer work at school? ++
Do the students like you? +
Do you old-boy network with powerful people? +++
Personal experience: One day 4th year teacher-wannabes came for practicum. After we were introduced, they were scolded for not getting up to bow to me. You can make what ever conclusions from that. I'd say my in-school respect is up but outside I am not. |
Good post.
I agree wholeheartedly with your list; these things are all a critical part of one fitting in and as you say, being respected. Sure. some of it is BS-y, but what job doesn't have some political/social angle to it? |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
poeticjustice
Joined: 28 Feb 2009
|
Posted: Sun Jul 19, 2009 3:28 pm Post subject: Re: pecking order |
|
|
andrewchon wrote: |
Personal experience: One day 4th year teacher-wannabes came for practicum. After we were introduced, they were scolded for not getting up to bow to me. You can make what ever conclusions from that. I'd say my in-school respect is up but outside I am not. |
You know, I think something similar happened to me. Can't be sure though.
We had this little 22-ish year old teacher come to my school for practicum. She filled in for my co-teacher for one class as part of it. She was under the assumption that she would be teaching at my school very soon, I believe as soon as September came around.
Her English was perfect as she had spent some time Stateside, so I figured we'd get on pretty well. I'm a pretty gentle, unassuming guy who tends (tries) to get along with pretty much everyone lest the rub me the wrong way.
We had a good five minute conversation during class while the kids were doing worksheets. I did get the distinct impression that she was looking down on me, because we were talking about foreigners in the public schools and she never referred to the foreigners as teachers when we talked. She either said Native Speaker or foreign teaching assistant, which I thought was a bit presumptuous considering she referred to herself as a teacher. I let it slide though.
Then I saw her in the cafeteria sitting by herself. Our class ended at a weird time so the place was practically empty. No one from my office had their lunch break at that time on that day, so I thought it'd be best to go sit with her. Ten minutes later her cohorts showed up and I thought nothing of it.
I had a pretty pleasant conversation with her but I did keep it professional (she was cute but turned a bit cold when her friends came so I was finding an excuse to leave). Anyway, I think the most personal question I asked was "what do you do for fun?" or "what do you do on evenings and weekends?"
That got me in a world of trouble. Next thing you know my whitey wrangler is telling me that she is spreading rumours around the entire school that I asked her on a date and that I was being really creepy, etc. I was really hurt by this as I've never been accused of either of these things before and it's really not in my personality to come on as pushy (I'm not pushy enough, really). That and, I showed no real interest in her aside from being polite, making conversation and hopefully starting a professional relationship.
My whitey wrangler said that he didn't buy it either and that he was pretty pissed off about her trying to start shit about me on her first day of practicum. I blew her off for the next week. She called my office desk asking me if I wanted to go to lunch outside of school but I feigned being busy and didn't acknowledge her in the cafeteria (why would I want to do that?) I guess the gossip mill turned around on her because on her first day she was extremely confident (audibly) in getting a position at my school then by the end of the week, when she stopped by my office to give me a gift (?!) she seemed really discontent and said I would in fact not be seeing her in September.
I guess that means I'm at least above the trainees, hah!
(I think this had to do more with the fact that she was being incredibly immature than the fact that it related to me. Still though, it means they know me, know what I'm like and respect that). |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
lifeinkorea
Joined: 24 Jan 2009 Location: somewhere in China
|
Posted: Sun Jul 19, 2009 4:02 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Quote: |
she seemed really discontent and said I would in fact not be seeing her in September |
I think that had more to do with age. There are many young Korean teachers who are more qualified and have had the experience abroad, but the older teachers who have been in the school system longer get first pick.
Was she replaced with an older teacher? |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
Mr. Pink

Joined: 21 Oct 2003 Location: China
|
Posted: Sun Jul 19, 2009 5:55 pm Post subject: |
|
|
To poeticjustice:
Your official title is assistant teacher. I know, I know, you and others might teach the whole class. I think there is something in the law, that only Korea certified teachers can have the title "teacher".
Once that girl is done her practicum, she will get certified, and she will be above you in status. As a 4th year student though, she shouldn't have been so cocky. That surprised me quite a bit. When I dealt with student teachers at my old school they were always very respectful and never insulting to the foreign staff. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
poeticjustice
Joined: 28 Feb 2009
|
Posted: Sun Jul 19, 2009 7:54 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Mr. Pink wrote: |
Your official title is assistant teacher. I know, I know, you and others might teach the whole class. I think there is something in the law, that only Korea certified teachers can have the title "teacher". |
I've never felt comfortable with how the title "teacher" must always unequivocally equal "one whom posesses a bachelor's degree and X teaching degree." I think you're either a teacher or your not, but not in the really vague sense of the word (not saying that everyone's mother is a "teacher"), but I think if your job is to bestow knowledge in a certain fashion then you are a "teacher." I know plenty of "teachers" but not very many teachers.
On an unrelated note, how much more difficult is their jobs than ours?
When I tell my co-workers that I teach 17 repeat classes a week + 4 teacher's classes they're always very jealous. I'm of the opinion that it is a lot harder for us to teach then it is for them because of the cultural/language barrier, with the added stress of there being a lot more pressure on us to perform.
When my co-workers say my job is easy I usually retort that I have to perform in the classroom, constantly, for my classes to work. I feel like I can either "win" or "lose" the class, and I can never give assignments that last the entire class like they are required to. There is meant to be zero babysitting or busy-work giving when I teach (though some foreign teachers might try and get away with that, and we're all guilty of showing videos to shut the kids up when they're being ridiculous).
I think their job is harder in the sense that they have to spend so much more time at school. Most of my co-workers work 12-14 hour days while I rarely work more than 8. Not to mention, I don't have to grade tests or check homework.
Win / lose I guess. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
Rex Jacobs
Joined: 17 Jul 2009
|
Posted: Sun Jul 19, 2009 8:56 pm Post subject: |
|
|
You're on par with the cleaning ajumma or cafeteria ajumma in terms of respectability. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
Koveras
Joined: 09 Oct 2008
|
Posted: Sun Jul 19, 2009 9:01 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Rex Jacobs wrote: |
You're on par with the cleaning ajumma or cafeteria ajumma in terms of respectability. |
I'm low, but I'm not that low. At the assemblies I take my bow to the parents, along with the other teachers, and get a hearty round of applause. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
Rex Jacobs
Joined: 17 Jul 2009
|
Posted: Sun Jul 19, 2009 9:02 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Koveras wrote: |
Rex Jacobs wrote: |
You're on par with the cleaning ajumma or cafeteria ajumma in terms of respectability. |
I'm low, but I'm not that low. At the assemblies I take my bow to the parents, along with the other teachers, and get a hearty round of applause. |
You're better than me. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
Elvis Gratton
Joined: 12 Jul 2009
|
Posted: Sun Jul 19, 2009 9:33 pm Post subject: Re: pecking order |
|
|
poeticjustice wrote: |
andrewchon wrote: |
Personal experience: One day 4th year teacher-wannabes came for practicum. After we were introduced, they were scolded for not getting up to bow to me. You can make what ever conclusions from that. I'd say my in-school respect is up but outside I am not. |
You know, I think something similar happened to me. Can't be sure though.
We had this little 22-ish year old teacher come to my school for practicum. She filled in for my co-teacher for one class as part of it. She was under the assumption that she would be teaching at my school very soon, I believe as soon as September came around.
Her English was perfect as she had spent some time Stateside, so I figured we'd get on pretty well. I'm a pretty gentle, unassuming guy who tends (tries) to get along with pretty much everyone lest the rub me the wrong way.
We had a good five minute conversation during class while the kids were doing worksheets. I did get the distinct impression that she was looking down on me, because we were talking about foreigners in the public schools and she never referred to the foreigners as teachers when we talked. She either said Native Speaker or foreign teaching assistant, which I thought was a bit presumptuous considering she referred to herself as a teacher. I let it slide though.
Then I saw her in the cafeteria sitting by herself. Our class ended at a weird time so the place was practically empty. No one from my office had their lunch break at that time on that day, so I thought it'd be best to go sit with her. Ten minutes later her cohorts showed up and I thought nothing of it.
I had a pretty pleasant conversation with her but I did keep it professional (she was cute but turned a bit cold when her friends came so I was finding an excuse to leave). Anyway, I think the most personal question I asked was "what do you do for fun?" or "what do you do on evenings and weekends?"
That got me in a world of trouble. Next thing you know my whitey wrangler is telling me that she is spreading rumours around the entire school that I asked her on a date and that I was being really creepy, etc. I was really hurt by this as I've never been accused of either of these things before and it's really not in my personality to come on as pushy (I'm not pushy enough, really). That and, I showed no real interest in her aside from being polite, making conversation and hopefully starting a professional relationship.
My whitey wrangler said that he didn't buy it either and that he was pretty pissed off about her trying to start shit about me on her first day of practicum. I blew her off for the next week. She called my office desk asking me if I wanted to go to lunch outside of school but I feigned being busy and didn't acknowledge her in the cafeteria (why would I want to do that?) I guess the gossip mill turned around on her because on her first day she was extremely confident (audibly) in getting a position at my school then by the end of the week, when she stopped by my office to give me a gift (?!) she seemed really discontent and said I would in fact not be seeing her in September.
I guess that means I'm at least above the trainees, hah!
(I think this had to do more with the fact that she was being incredibly immature than the fact that it related to me. Still though, it means they know me, know what I'm like and respect that). |
Make a point of calling her Student-teacher Kim in front of the students. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
Mr. Pink

Joined: 21 Oct 2003 Location: China
|
Posted: Sun Jul 19, 2009 10:12 pm Post subject: |
|
|
poeticjustice wrote: |
Mr. Pink wrote: |
Your official title is assistant teacher. I know, I know, you and others might teach the whole class. I think there is something in the law, that only Korea certified teachers can have the title "teacher". |
I've never felt comfortable with how the title "teacher" must always unequivocally equal "one whom posesses a bachelor's degree and X teaching degree." I think you're either a teacher or your not, but not in the really vague sense of the word (not saying that everyone's mother is a "teacher"), but I think if your job is to bestow knowledge in a certain fashion then you are a "teacher." I know plenty of "teachers" but not very many teachers.
On an unrelated note, how much more difficult is their jobs than ours?
When I tell my co-workers that I teach 17 repeat classes a week + 4 teacher's classes they're always very jealous. I'm of the opinion that it is a lot harder for us to teach then it is for them because of the cultural/language barrier, with the added stress of there being a lot more pressure on us to perform.
When my co-workers say my job is easy I usually retort that I have to perform in the classroom, constantly, for my classes to work. I feel like I can either "win" or "lose" the class, and I can never give assignments that last the entire class like they are required to. There is meant to be zero babysitting or busy-work giving when I teach (though some foreign teachers might try and get away with that, and we're all guilty of showing videos to shut the kids up when they're being ridiculous).
I think their job is harder in the sense that they have to spend so much more time at school. Most of my co-workers work 12-14 hour days while I rarely work more than 8. Not to mention, I don't have to grade tests or check homework.
Win / lose I guess. |
This is Korea. They are all about titles. Our titles are "assistant teacher". I know what you're saying and I agree. I taught for 6 years in my own class. There was NEVER any Korean teacher attached to my class. When I asked for that certificate of employment Korea has, it had "assistant teacher" as my job title. Nevertheless, I was pretty insulted at that, but what could I do? As I said, I believe that the full title of "teacher" is reserved in Korea for those who are certified or registered with the government.
Also remember, in Korea they don't do the 5th year like we do in the west for teaching degrees. They start out in 1st year knowing they will go into education. Sort of like in the US how they do their B.Ed as a 4 year degree.
I never had students treat me like I wasn't a teacher, so I guess in terms of your original question, it is all in what type of support you get from the admin, how much they like you, and how that is shown to the students. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
poeticjustice
Joined: 28 Feb 2009
|
Posted: Sun Jul 19, 2009 10:52 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Mr. Pink wrote: |
Also remember, in Korea they don't do the 5th year like we do in the west for teaching degrees. They start out in 1st year knowing they will go into education. Sort of like in the US how they do their B.Ed as a 4 year degree. |
That's odd... I thought they all had more than four years of education. That would mean there isn't much that separates us from them other than experience.
Wouldn't they need to take on a different degree for their major? |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
Hyeon Een

Joined: 24 Jun 2005
|
Posted: Mon Jul 20, 2009 1:22 am Post subject: |
|
|
poeticjustice wrote: |
Mr. Pink wrote: |
Also remember, in Korea they don't do the 5th year like we do in the west for teaching degrees. They start out in 1st year knowing they will go into education. Sort of like in the US how they do their B.Ed as a 4 year degree. |
That's odd... I thought they all had more than four years of education. That would mean there isn't much that separates us from them other than experience.
Wouldn't they need to take on a different degree for their major? |
They have also passed the Korean teacher's exam which is incredibly competitive. In terms of English teachers about 1/10 who take the exam pass it each year. Actually it's not a pass/fail exam, but rather there are x number of openings and the top x applicants get hired. I know lots of students who would make excellent teachers who've failed this exam unfortunately.
There are also temporary teachers who are on usually 1 year contracts who haven't yet passed the teachers exam. These teachers teach the same as their fulltime counterparts but have no job security, lower pay and few of the benefits of a tenured teacher.
In private schools the teachers can be hired as full time teachers without passing the teachers exam, however this is very hard to do. You either need excellent contacts, or 'buy' the position for in the region of W20,000,000+ through a bribe.
I think the older teachers a lot of you guys work with were hired years ago when it was a much less competitive job. Young teachers these days have worked exceptionally hard to get their position. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
|
|