|
Korean Job Discussion Forums "The Internet's Meeting Place for ESL/EFL Teachers from Around the World!"
|
View previous topic :: View next topic |
Author |
Message |
Mosley
Joined: 15 Jan 2003
|
Posted: Tue Jan 19, 2010 1:18 pm Post subject: JET Programme still shows how it's done.... |
|
|
Long-timers here might remember me as an unabashed booster and proud alumnus of Japan's superb JET Programme, which has been going strong for over 20 yrs. now. It's amazing that in Korea, public school contracts and the bizarre immigration hassles have been regressing, not progressing. In short, there's even more dissatisfaction w/public school jobs in Korea than there was just a few short yrs. ago. And for good reason. Look what a new JET ALT, by contrast, gets:
-first visa is free of charge
-you don't pay for a flight and fight for reimbursement later. You're just given a (first class!) ticket.
-21 days vacation PLUS Japanese holidays PLUS any freebies your base school decides to give you.
-An orientation at a five star hotel.
-rate of savings comparable to that of PS teachers in Korea.
-a professional support network that is there to serve YOU.
-yes, you must supply a CRC but no horsehockey about apostilles, etc.
-if a successful applicant, you must submit to a medical but guess what? It's done in your hometown by your family doctor!
I could go on & on but I think you get the idea. At this point, there is always some joker(insert huffy-puffy, hissy-fit voice of a rejected JET applicant who's likely teaching in Korea or at a non-JET job in Japan) who comes up w/this gem: "Well! JET is set up to make the foreign teacher happy! It's done on purpose!! They want the barbarian to spread the word on how great Japan is!"
I won't go into the psychology of the person who would actually offer this as a criticism. It should actually be held up as THE model. Look at Korea: more and more PS NTs are getting POed as never before and the irony is that it's in a culture that's obsessed about foreigners saying how great Korea is!! And yet, right across that little pond, there's the model of how to please the barbarian.... |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
Sadebugo1
Joined: 11 May 2003
|
Posted: Tue Jan 19, 2010 2:47 pm Post subject: Re: JET Programme still shows how it's done.... |
|
|
Mosley wrote: |
Long-timers here might remember me as an unabashed booster and proud alumnus of Japan's superb JET Programme, which has been going strong for over 20 yrs. now. It's amazing that in Korea, public school contracts and the bizarre immigration hassles have been regressing, not progressing. In short, there's even more dissatisfaction w/public school jobs in Korea than there was just a few short yrs. ago. And for good reason. Look what a new JET ALT, by contrast, gets:
-first visa is free of charge
-you don't pay for a flight and fight for reimbursement later. You're just given a (first class!) ticket.
-21 days vacation PLUS Japanese holidays PLUS any freebies your base school decides to give you.
-An orientation at a five star hotel.
-rate of savings comparable to that of PS teachers in Korea.
-a professional support network that is there to serve YOU.
-yes, you must supply a CRC but no horsehockey about apostilles, etc.
-if a successful applicant, you must submit to a medical but guess what? It's done in your hometown by your family doctor!
I could go on & on but I think you get the idea. At this point, there is always some joker(insert huffy-puffy, hissy-fit voice of a rejected JET applicant who's likely teaching in Korea or at a non-JET job in Japan) who comes up w/this gem: "Well! JET is set up to make the foreign teacher happy! It's done on purpose!! They want the barbarian to spread the word on how great Japan is!"
I won't go into the psychology of the person who would actually offer this as a criticism. It should actually be held up as THE model. Look at Korea: more and more PS NTs are getting POed as never before and the irony is that it's in a culture that's obsessed about foreigners saying how great Korea is!! And yet, right across that little pond, there's the model of how to please the barbarian.... |
I don't think anyone expected EPIK to match JET's proficiency in the beginning, but my goodness, they've now had 15 years to get it right! From some of the things I've read on this board, it seems to be getting even worse than when I was in the program in '96-'98. Yes, it's an old story that they want to be the hub of Asia in everything but won't take the steps to make it a reality.
Sadebugo
http://travldawrld.blogspot.com/ |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
ippy
Joined: 25 Aug 2009
|
Posted: Tue Jan 19, 2010 4:17 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Also JET alumni. Also teaching PS in korea, so lets edit one or two things:
1. No first class ticket. That was done away with years and years ago.
2. My medical cost over a 100 quid since you have to have an x-ray. It wasnt cheap.
3. Subsidised accomodation is pretty much luck of the draw. I was paying 12,000 yen a month, my best mate (also a jet in the city next to mine), was paying 60,000. I know because he wouldnt stfu about how he couldnt save money.
4. JET is for the most part the stuff of human tape recording. I was unlucky, i landed a proper placement where i had to do my own plans and lead my own classes, but how i longed for the human tape recorder. In korea it seems to be the other way around.
5. The pay is WAY better on JET. And yet im saving just as good here (without trying). Guess it balances out then.
6. I get 34 days holidays here, plus national holidays. Musnt grumble. Also if im sick im literally ordered to use sick leave and not my paid leave.
I love JET. If JET let me back on (and had a placement in hokkaido), id be there in a heartbeat, but well, even with the recent attacks on our pay and conditions, korea is still pretty much comparable. Plus i like the students here waaaaaaay better. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
reactionary
Joined: 22 Oct 2006 Location: korreia
|
Posted: Tue Jan 19, 2010 4:19 pm Post subject: |
|
|
I'd heard rumors that the JET programs were being scaled back and there were relying more on the "ALT Dispatchers." Conditions for those gigs are horrendous...something like 200,000 yen a month without housing (perhaps even less, 190,000?), working multiple schools, being forced to "rent" a car to commute to said schools, etc.
You can't really deny that the JET program is a bit of a PR tactic if the alternative (read: future) system manages to be worse than EPIK/SMOE. I really think you have to include those dispatchers when comparing the two countries' public school systems.
And yes, I didn't make the cut for JET when I applied my senior year. I'm not gonna hate on it though, I would've loved that job if I could've gotten some of the sweet placements I know some people got (met a guy who was the JET in my Kyoto/Osaka suburb, another one in downtown Kobe - yeesh).
Hell, I even got rejected by AEON after 2 years experience in Korea. I guess Koreans like hiring me more than the Japanese do. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
ippy
Joined: 25 Aug 2009
|
Posted: Tue Jan 19, 2010 4:25 pm Post subject: |
|
|
reactionary wrote: |
I'd heard rumors that the JET programs were being scaled back and there were relying more on the "ALT Dispatchers." Conditions for those gigs are horrendous...something like 200,000 yen a month without housing (perhaps even less, 190,000?), working multiple schools, being forced to "rent" a car to commute to said schools, etc.
You can't really deny that the JET program is a bit of a PR tactic if the alternative (read: future) system manages to be worse than EPIK/SMOE. I really think you have to include those dispatchers when comparing the two countries' public school systems.
And yes, I didn't make the cut for JET when I applied my senior year. I'm not gonna hate on it though, I would've loved that job if I could've gotten some of the sweet placements I know some people got (met a guy who was the JET in my Kyoto/Osaka suburb, another one in downtown Kobe - yeesh).
Hell, I even got rejected by AEON after 2 years experience in Korea. I guess Koreans like hiring me more than the Japanese do. |
Dispatch wages are still around 250,000. Its only shyster companies who are trying to get a foothold in the interac/jet monopoly. Theres some serious competitive bidding going on right now at BOEs and alas its the poor ALT thats getting shat on in the process. I mean, i was getting something like 240,000 (with 2man rent) after JET for a job that had more classes, was longer hours, and had more pressures to be the perfect ALT. They were also claiming i was working under 30 hours i think it was so they didnt have to cover pension or health insurance. Oh and out of a promised 30 odd days holiday, it turns out i rolled away with 3 days :/
Dispatches are awesome! |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
ippy
Joined: 25 Aug 2009
|
Posted: Tue Jan 19, 2010 4:28 pm Post subject: |
|
|
PS.
Kyushoku. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
reactionary
Joined: 22 Oct 2006 Location: korreia
|
Posted: Tue Jan 19, 2010 4:29 pm Post subject: |
|
|
ippy wrote: |
Dispatch wages are still around 250,000. Its only shyster companies who are trying to get a foothold in the interac/jet monopoly. Theres some serious competitive bidding going on right now at BOEs and alas its the poor ALT thats getting shat on in the process. I mean, i was getting something like 240,000 (with 2man rent) after JET for a job that had more classes, was longer hours, and had more pressures to be the perfect ALT. They were also claiming i was working under 30 hours i think it was so they didnt have to cover pension or health insurance. Oh and out of a promised 30 odd days holiday, it turns out i rolled away with 3 days :/
Dispatches are awesome! |
That's pretty cheap rent, but I *know* I've seen some dispatch companies offering less than 240,000 - they still have a laundry list of demands before they will hire you (YOU MUST BE IN THE COUNTRY! YOU MUST HAVE A PROPER VISA! YOU MUST HAVE AN INTERNATIONAL DRIVER'S LICENSE).
All in all, though, you illustrate my point. EPIK/SMOE are surely never going to be JET, but we can at least hope they won't become like the dispatchers (although the after school job positions seem to work in a similar fashion - you work for the recruiter and not the school BS). |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
dirving
Joined: 19 Nov 2009 Location: South Korea
|
Posted: Tue Jan 19, 2010 4:31 pm Post subject: Re: JET Programme still shows how it's done.... |
|
|
Mosley wrote: |
Long-timers here might remember me as an unabashed booster and proud alumnus of Japan's superb JET Programme, which has been going strong for over 20 yrs. now. It's amazing that in Korea, public school contracts and the bizarre immigration hassles have been regressing, not progressing. In short, there's even more dissatisfaction w/public school jobs in Korea than there was just a few short yrs. ago. And for good reason. Look what a new JET ALT, by contrast, gets:
-first visa is free of charge
-you don't pay for a flight and fight for reimbursement later. You're just given a (first class!) ticket.
-21 days vacation PLUS Japanese holidays PLUS any freebies your base school decides to give you.
-An orientation at a five star hotel.
-rate of savings comparable to that of PS teachers in Korea.
-a professional support network that is there to serve YOU.
-yes, you must supply a CRC but no horsehockey about apostilles, etc.
-if a successful applicant, you must submit to a medical but guess what? It's done in your hometown by your family doctor!
I could go on & on but I think you get the idea. At this point, there is always some joker(insert huffy-puffy, hissy-fit voice of a rejected JET applicant who's likely teaching in Korea or at a non-JET job in Japan) who comes up w/this gem: "Well! JET is set up to make the foreign teacher happy! It's done on purpose!! They want the barbarian to spread the word on how great Japan is!"
I won't go into the psychology of the person who would actually offer this as a criticism. It should actually be held up as THE model. Look at Korea: more and more PS NTs are getting POed as never before and the irony is that it's in a culture that's obsessed about foreigners saying how great Korea is!! And yet, right across that little pond, there's the model of how to please the barbarian.... |
A guy from Charlottetown used to have beers with me at uni. He went to Tokyo and did the J.E.T. thing. He used to go on and on to the gang back in Ch'Town about what a great deal it was for the foreign instructor in Tokyo. Come to think of it, I know of three others from P.E.I. who were in the J.E.T. Programme. All loved it.
My co-teachers were caught by the county's co-ordinator "misleading" me about the start and end dates of my Winter Vacaton. Both of them have been wicked cold towards me from the first minute they layed their evil eyes upon me. Hell, both schools do not even provide a lunch for me even though I'm bloody well charged for the crap!
Criminal crap or what? This is a government programme for Christ's sake. Oh well, working for E.P.I.K. beats flippin' burgers at an angry gyopo's favourite burger joint, eh.  |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
ippy
Joined: 25 Aug 2009
|
Posted: Tue Jan 19, 2010 4:37 pm Post subject: |
|
|
reactionary wrote: |
ippy wrote: |
Dispatch wages are still around 250,000. Its only shyster companies who are trying to get a foothold in the interac/jet monopoly. Theres some serious competitive bidding going on right now at BOEs and alas its the poor ALT thats getting shat on in the process. I mean, i was getting something like 240,000 (with 2man rent) after JET for a job that had more classes, was longer hours, and had more pressures to be the perfect ALT. They were also claiming i was working under 30 hours i think it was so they didnt have to cover pension or health insurance. Oh and out of a promised 30 odd days holiday, it turns out i rolled away with 3 days :/
Dispatches are awesome! |
That's pretty cheap rent, but I *know* I've seen some dispatch companies offering less than 240,000 - they still have a laundry list of demands before they will hire you (YOU MUST BE IN THE COUNTRY! YOU MUST HAVE A PROPER VISA! YOU MUST HAVE AN INTERNATIONAL DRIVER'S LICENSE).
All in all, though, you illustrate my point. EPIK/SMOE are surely never going to be JET, but we can at least hope they won't become like the dispatchers (although the after school job positions seem to work in a similar fashion - you work for the recruiter and not the school BS). |
ah no, mine was fine. You could live on it and save a wee bit. It was about 205,000 take home after taxes and rent. Perfectly sustainable. After i left though, teh same job (i admit though the hours were cut from 8.30-5, to 8.30-4.30) was being offered on gaijinpot for 210,000 per month. That pretty much showed whats going on right now. Even underbidding by ten or 15k isnt enough, so theres some radical competition right now for contracts. Its not going to be the end of the story i promise you. This is pretty much the start of it all. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
Easter Clark

Joined: 18 Nov 2007 Location: Hiding from Yie Eun-woong
|
Posted: Tue Jan 19, 2010 4:56 pm Post subject: |
|
|
JET's hiring standards are set quite a bit higher than EPIK or GEPIK, right? |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
reactionary
Joined: 22 Oct 2006 Location: korreia
|
Posted: Tue Jan 19, 2010 5:00 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Easter Clark wrote: |
JET's hiring standards are set quite a bit higher than EPIK or GEPIK, right? |
The application form is a lot longer and the interviewing process is more involved. I wouldn't really say you have to have gone to a better university or have a higher GPA/more valid experience/etc. One hiring season per year as opposed to two and the process starts a good 7-8 months before the contract date.
As ippy said, most positions turn you into a human tape recorder. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
ippy
Joined: 25 Aug 2009
|
Posted: Tue Jan 19, 2010 5:05 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Easter Clark wrote: |
JET's hiring standards are set quite a bit higher than EPIK or GEPIK, right? |
It might be, but thats pretty much arguable. Its the exact same group of people being interviewed for gigs at the end of the day.
I think the difference is the perception. YOu can land a job here in a public school literally within a week if you go through a recruiter (i appreciate there are also official application processes, but i got my job in october outside the normal hiring period).
On JET its a massively long and tedious process. Applications are available around september, deadline for written app is sometime in november, then in january and february they do interviews, and then sometime around april you find out if you got in. Then in june i think it is, you find your placement, and finally in july/august they turf you out to japan. Its a year long application pretty much, so it seems more picky.
From the figures London was throwing out, it was something like 1500 applications, 1000 interviews and 500 placements. When you then factor in the 200 or so people that turn down the job because theyve changed their mind or have other committments (group c), then you have almost a 1/2 chance from the off to get the job (and that 1 in 2 chance includes idiots who are binned because they couldnt fill out the form properly or just have atrocious statements of purpose). Thats pretty good odds for a decently paid trip around the world. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
Mosley
Joined: 15 Jan 2003
|
Posted: Wed Jan 20, 2010 11:02 am Post subject: |
|
|
Good comments from all.
I didn't know the business class ticket had been scrapped, but what the hey....
As for the medical, I don't remember it costing me anything(coming as I do from the land of socialized medicine). In any event, a lot better to have it done at home with no threat of putting your keester on the next flight out if some Korean doctor doesn't like you!
As some have pointed out: make no mistake-applying for JET is a long, tedious and drawn-out process. It's kinda like a test to see if you really want the gig. If you make it...it's worth it.
I got accepted on Apr. 1 for the July 21 Tokyo Orientation of that year. Everything was professional & extremely well organized.
The good news about teaching EFL in Japan is that JET is still going strong. The bad news is that the vast majority of non-JET jobs, over the past dozen years, have gone to rat s---. Yes, even EPIK is better! Dispatch cos. have been the most disturbing trend. A recent ad was recruiting for ALTs(and you won't be living the easygoing life of a JET ALT, believe you me) with a TOP rate of 240,000! And you pay your own airfare over. And you're advised to bring over 3K for "start up costs"! But as long as Japanese employers can find Westerners willing to sign up for that kind of abuse, contract conditions will remain as they are.... |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
sarbonn

Joined: 14 Oct 2008 Location: Michigan
|
Posted: Wed Jan 20, 2010 12:43 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Isn't there also an age limitation with the Jet program? Could have sworn I remember reading that (which is why, I believe, I didn't pursue it back then...think that was the reason). |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
Mosley
Joined: 15 Jan 2003
|
Posted: Wed Jan 20, 2010 1:03 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Yes. If you're 40 or over at time of application, you're 99.9 % sure of being rejected.
It's a policy of JET I disagree with. Hell, I wish they had a MINIMUM age (say, 26) to help keep out spoiled brats w/a sense of entitlement(yes, JET gets them). |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
|
|