|
Korean Job Discussion Forums "The Internet's Meeting Place for ESL/EFL Teachers from Around the World!"
|
View previous topic :: View next topic |
Author |
Message |
phill458
Joined: 08 May 2009 Location: Sang Ju
|
Posted: Thu Nov 04, 2010 1:14 am Post subject: Law School Personal Essay Critique |
|
|
Heavily revised, still needs major work, please let me know where and hold nothing back!!!!
Failing English, Moving to Korea and Other Things You�re Not Supposed to Do
In life there are many things we are told that we are not supposed to do. For most people things such as lie, cheat, and steal come to mind. As well, most people are told that they needed to do things such as excel in school, attend a good university, and work in a professional field. I was told different. I was not supposed to graduate from high school, definitely not college. I was not supposed to travel abroad, and aspirations of becoming a lawyer were dreams that, if spoken aloud, would have made me the laughing stock of the community. I was told to put my head down, to work in the family construction business, and to be thankful for what I had. As you can tell, I wasn�t a very good listener! I had a drive, an ambition for something more. I believed in my core that my life has a greater purpose, and I viewed the law as the medium with which to help me accomplish this. As my life will testify, given my experiences and hard work, if given the chance, I will accomplish my goal.
You�re not supposed to go to college. I was not even supposed to graduate from high school. Raised on food stamps by a single mother, I wasn�t exactly given every chance to excel. However, I knew a better life existed for me than what my family had planned; earning honest money performing back breaking labor on construction sites. If I was to make it out of my supposed lot in life, it could only be through hard work and with a steely determination. Through it all, the multiple divorces, the domestic abuse at the hands of my step-father, even the paralysis when I suffered 4 broken vertebrae in an accident; I never lost sight of my goal. I graduated high school by way night school. At University I went on to graduate top of my class, during which time I also won an intramural soccer championship. At every juncture and with every purported disadvantage throughout my life I have succeeded. But the greatest testament to my will and determination, I can walk.
You�re not supposed to move to Korea. I was instead supposed to accept one of the lucrative job offers I received upon graduating. I didn�t. I had a compelling notion that demanded I see this globalized world everyone talked about and where I would one day have to work. I chose a sojourn to Korea, where many years before my grandfather had spent his youth fighting. In my two years of teaching English in a small rural village, there were many daunting tasks I was faced with. Out of everything I endured and had to overcome, from learning the language, enduring the racism while winning over my fianc�s parents, to accepting to live the Confucian way of life, all of those things paled in comparison to the labor dispute my lawyer and I recently argued and won. The dispute arose after my employer at a private academy I worked at canceled my contract and visa prematurely in order to save a few thousand dollars on severance fees and airfare. His rationale was that since I was as a foreigner, I would have no avenues of recourse and would just accept his decision, as is the norm in Korea. Threatened with deportation and with my back to the wall, I proceeded to craft the initial complaint, located an attorney to help file charges with the Seoul Labor Office and participated in marathon negotiation sessions until we finally settled the for 90% of our initial claim of damages. No matter how great the obstacle might be, I have proven that I�m more than up to the task, and will not quit until it is overcome.
You�re not supposed to go to a good law school. With my LSAT score of 153 I�m not supposed to apply to a good law school. I will. I have the confidence coupled with the humility to know that if I put in the hard work that will be required, to truly devote myself to my studies; I will rise to the top. With my record of diverse experiences, and wit my record of accomplishments, I feel I would make a positive contribution to any class. However, at a good law school where my peers would undoubtedly possess fantastic qualities as well I could really shine.
In the end did what I wasn�t supposed to and didn�t do what I was. I opted instead to live my life. I chose not to succumb to the barriers and restrictions placed upon my life. I attribute this behavior for allowing me to surpass every expectation others have placed on my life. Through my experiences I have grown more into the person that I envisioned, a person who, when they get knocked down, get up again. A person with the unflinching will to succeed. A person ready to learn the law. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
Ruthdes

Joined: 16 Oct 2008 Location: Seoul
|
Posted: Thu Nov 04, 2010 5:35 am Post subject: Re: Law School Personal Essay Critique |
|
|
phill458 wrote: |
Heavily revised, still needs major work, please let me know where and hold nothing back!!!!
Failing English, Moving to Korea and Other Things You�re Not Supposed to Do
In life there are many things we are told that we are not supposed to do. For most people things such as lie, cheat, and steal come to mind. As well, most people are told that they needed to do things such as excel in school, attend a good university, and work in a professional field. I was told different. I was not supposed to graduate from high school, definitely not college. I was not supposed to travel abroad, and aspirations of becoming a lawyer were dreams that, if spoken aloud, would have made me the laughing stock of the community. I was told to put my head down, to work in the family construction business, and to be thankful for what I had. As you can tell, I wasn�t a very good listener! I had a drive, an ambition for something more. I believed in my core that my life has a greater purpose, and I viewed the law as the medium with which to help me accomplish this. As my life will testify, given my experiences and hard work, if given the chance, I will accomplish my goal. (1)
(2) You�re not supposed to go to college. I was not even supposed to graduate from high school. Raised on food stamps by a single mother, I wasn�t exactly given every chance to excel. However, I knew a better life existed for me than what my family had planned: (3) earning honest money performing back breaking labor on construction sites. If I was to make it out of my supposed lot in life, it could only be through hard work and with a steely determination. Through it all, the multiple divorces, the domestic abuse at the hands of my step-father, even the paralysis when I suffered 4 broken vertebrae in an accident; I never lost sight of my goal. I graduated high school by way night school. At University I went on to graduate top of my class, during which time I also won an intramural soccer championship. At every juncture and with every purported disadvantage throughout my life I have succeeded. But the greatest testament to my will and determination: (4) I can walk.
(5) You�re not supposed to move to Korea. I was instead supposed to accept one of the lucrative job offers I received upon graduating. I didn�t. I had a compelling notion that demanded I see this globalized world everyone talked about and where I would one day have to work. I chose a sojourn to Korea, where many years before my grandfather had spent his youth fighting. In my two years of teaching English in a small rural village, there were many daunting tasks I was faced with. (6) Out of everything I endured and had to overcome, from learning the language, enduring the racism while winning over my fianc�s parents, to accepting to live the Confucian way of life, all of those things paled in comparison to the labor dispute my lawyer and I recently argued and won. The dispute arose after my employer at a private academy I worked (7) at canceled my contract and visa prematurely in order to save a few thousand dollars on severance fees and airfare. His rationale was that since I was as a foreigner, I would have no avenues of recourse and would just accept his decision, as is the norm in Korea. Threatened with deportation and with my back to the wall, I proceeded to craft the initial complaint, located an attorney to help file charges with the Seoul Labor Office and participated in marathon negotiation sessions until we finally settled the for 90% of our initial claim of damages. ( No matter how great the obstacle might be, I have proven that I�m more than up to the task, and will not quit until it is overcome.
(9) You�re not supposed to go to a good law school. With my LSAT score of 153 I�m not supposed to apply to a good law school. I will. I have the confidence coupled with the humility to know that if I put in the hard work that will be required, to truly devote myself to my studies; I will rise to the top. With my record of diverse experiences, and wit(10) my record of accomplishments, I feel I would make a positive contribution to any class. (11)However, at a good law school where my peers would undoubtedly possess fantastic qualities as well I could really shine.
(12) In the end (13) did what I wasn�t supposed to and didn�t do what I was. I opted instead to live my life. I chose not to succumb to the barriers and restrictions placed upon my life. (14) I attribute this behavior for allowing me to surpass every expectation others have placed on my life. Through my experiences I have grown more into the person that I envisioned, a person who, when they get knocked down, get(15) up again. A person with the unflinching will to succeed. A person ready to learn the law. |
1) Change the last sentence of the first paragraph. Maybe make it two or make it less wordy.
2) You change your pronoun. Maybe "I was not supposed to go to university" makes more sense, seeing you use "I" in the second sentence. If there was a reason for you doing this, I don't understand it. *edit* Now I've read the rest, I get it. Refer to 9) for further comment, and ignore point 5) (I can't be bothered changing all the formatting I did!)
3) I'm pretty sure you want a colon here, rather than a semi-colon. I will defer to more accomplished grammarians if anyone disagrees with me though.
4) Another colon I think.
5) Pronoun again.
6) The next sentence is too long. Rewrite.
7) I would use "for" instead of "at". The double use of at sounds repetitive. Just caught another typo in the next sentence: "since I was as a foreigner".
I think I would say "No matter how great any given obstacle in my life has seemed, I have proven that I am up to the task of dealing with it and succeeding."
9) Pronoun- though now having read the whole piece, I get what you're doing. Maybe make it more obvious by putting these "You're" sentences in italics.
10) typo: wit - with.
11) I don't get this next sentence. How will you shine when everyone's good? I think you need to elaborate on this point.
12) Is this a new paragraph? Put in a space.
13) Typo: you need an "I"
14) Incorrect use of "attribute". You should reword to start of saying something like "I attribute my success to...." or " I acknowledge that it was this attitude that led me to..." I like attitude better than behavior.
15) Typo. Should be "gets" Actually, I'd reword this whole paragraph to something like this:
"Through my experiences I have grown closer to the person that I always envisioned: a person who, when they get knocked down, gets up again; a person with the unflinching will to succeed; a person ready to learn the law."
Another suggestion. Maybe break your Korea paragraph into two. Have the first one with positive things, and the negative/challenge stuff in the second. As one paragraph it's a little long, i feel.
I actually quite like this essay now. Your first draft was a mess, your second cliched. This is neither a mess, nor too cliched. Good luck with your application!
*P.S. I kept the in on purpose!
*P.P.S. I don't know anything about what law schools are looking for in an essay, so I'm judging/correcting this purely from a clear writing and level of interest point of view. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
phill458
Joined: 08 May 2009 Location: Sang Ju
|
Posted: Thu Nov 04, 2010 5:38 am Post subject: |
|
|
Awesome critique, thank you!!! |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
cert43
Joined: 17 Jun 2010
|
Posted: Sat Nov 06, 2010 7:05 am Post subject: |
|
|
1.You need to use more logic-based critique as you sound WAY too self-critical ( to the point of poor little me). By this point, no one really cares what happened in your childhood, it's all about what your going to bring now. Sure, talking about food stamps is ok if it's realted to something in law ( such as economic advocacy), but NOT the way your using it.
Most people on the admissions' commitee have been to law school, passed thier bars,praticed law, served on some kind of judicary board, etc..so using utter and simplitisic law terms ( think dispute), WILL NOT help your case.In fact, think major major insult to the third degree.
2. Don't worry so much about your content. Yes, it is important,but not the most ;as they will assume that you already know how to write a college-level essay.
3. Don't use the Korean experience as your whole disputation for getting into law school, unless you've learned some substantial skill ( foreign langage fluency, treaty , negioation, etc). There also might be a Korean on the admissions' commitee,so think about how that can really work against you.
4. Law Schools' look for well-rounded, diverse applicant pools'. If you have ANY-THING that will stand out ( URM, a family name, etc), USE IT. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
schlotzy
Joined: 10 Mar 2010 Location: South Korea
|
Posted: Sun Nov 07, 2010 10:33 pm Post subject: |
|
|
I don't have a lot of time to write so I'll just add a couple of things.
1. In a formal essay, I would never use contractions or casual language.
2. The first sentence of each of your paragraphs seems like a topic sentence, which is great! It really helps the reader to follow your organizational layout and plan. However, they're all kind of quote sounding without the actual quotes and don't seem like complete sentences. If I were you, I'd say something more along the lines of-- People telling me I'm not supposed to go to college was one of the more difficult obstacles I've overcome in my life.
3. Be careful with punctuation. I'd say your semi-colon is incorrectly used. The second phrase is dependant and cannot stand alone on its own. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
schlotzy
Joined: 10 Mar 2010 Location: South Korea
|
Posted: Sun Nov 07, 2010 10:35 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Also, not sure if you should be including your kinda average LSAT score (no offence..it's not easy directly in the body of your essay. It almost draws more attention to it. I've heard a lot of places will just throw out applicants instantly who don't meet the minimum score requirement. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
cert43
Joined: 17 Jun 2010
|
Posted: Mon Nov 08, 2010 4:15 am Post subject: |
|
|
You shouldn't be including your score, period ( even if it is perfect).
They can view that for themselves. |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
offtheoche
Joined: 21 Mar 2007
|
Posted: Mon Nov 08, 2010 7:27 am Post subject: |
|
|
I recommend you make one change,.....delete the entire thing.
As one poster pointed out, if you don't even know that contractions should not be used in academic writing, then I suggest you move onwards and sideways from teaching ESL to flipping burgers.
Please write back with your personal essay for KFC, and we'll take another look.  |
|
Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
|
|