|
Korean Job Discussion Forums "The Internet's Meeting Place for ESL/EFL Teachers from Around the World!"
|
| View previous topic :: View next topic |
| Author |
Message |
ReeNah
Joined: 26 Oct 2010
|
Posted: Tue Nov 16, 2010 6:57 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Also I would like to add something else that I've been thinking about.
There are lots of native teachers who are having trouble and at the moment there is really not much they can do yes? I mean there like 25,000+ teachers but when something goes down and they get ripped off there is noone for them to turn to, well apart from this forum.
Is there no union or something like that? I am quite a dreamer and I think maybe one day we (native teachers) could form an organised union and you know work towards a more secure working environment for native speakers.
I know its just a fancy idea at the moment but I don't see why it can't happen in the near future. Just thought I'd throw it in there. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
grnmle
Joined: 13 Sep 2007
|
Posted: Tue Nov 16, 2010 7:06 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Look bud: So far you haven't said anything that every other recruiter out there offers aside from being responsible for paying for teachers. So basically you are a dispatch company.
The reputation of these companies in Japan is well documented. The service they provide makes it easier for companies to find teachers. It's just that it then becomes a race to the bottom. The people that lose out are teachers. It's their pay that gets cut.
And what service have you really provided?
At least you are trying to be the best!
The reason I haven't used a recruiter is that the majority seem like snakes. So far it would seem you fit right in. The first sign is that you are thinking of revolutionizing recruiting. Really?
I've always been able to find work without one and, for the most part I've done quite well that way. As I said, those that have used one have generally felt they got the short end.
Using a recruiter is like going to a prostitute without wrapping. At first it might feel good but you will worry for months and months that something is wrong. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
ReeNah
Joined: 26 Oct 2010
|
Posted: Tue Nov 16, 2010 7:23 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Well our basic wage structure is like this:
Monthly Wage: 2 Million Korean Won
Tax: 3.3%
Pension Contribution: 4.5% of wage (we pay additional 4.5%)
Medical Insurance: 2.835% or wage (we pay additional 2.385%)
We provide housing. Apartments (between 25 and 30 'pyung'). Three bedroom; for three people, same gender. Fridge, Washing Machine, Beds, Wadrobe, TV, AirCon, Boiler Heating. Just your normal apartment. We think its better for people to live together, less lonely etc.
We also plan to have monthly bonuses. Employee of the month, small monetary rewards or coupons to various things.
Also we will hold monthly 'hweshik', like dinners for employees. Where we get-together for dinner and some light drinks (all paid for by us) where we can relax and enjoy a good time. Maybe in the long run we'll hold big Christmas Parties and hold other events such as an Athletics Day etc. Who has been exercising regularly since they got to Korea? I mean everything is home delieverd even at 3am so it's hard not to gain weight I found! We are just starting so most of these are just ideas and concepts we are trying to implement.
Thoughts? |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Summer Wine
Joined: 20 Mar 2005 Location: Next to a River
|
Posted: Tue Nov 16, 2010 7:42 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Quote: |
Monthly Wage: 2 Million Korean Won
|
This might be your first problem. I was getting this in 2001.
With an inflation rate of 4% this year alone in food and other items, plus the changes in exchange rates.
2.0 million doesn't cut it. A minimum should be 2.5 million and even that doesn't really cover costs.
Teaching is no longer a money winner in Korea, but offering 2.0 means that you will just get the dregs of the barrel.
Just my 10 won. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
ReeNah
Joined: 26 Oct 2010
|
Posted: Tue Nov 16, 2010 7:51 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Summer Wine wrote: |
| Quote: |
Monthly Wage: 2 Million Korean Won
|
This might be your first problem. I was getting this in 2001.
With an inflation rate of 4% this year alone in food and other items, plus the changes in exchange rates.
2.0 million doesn't cut it. A minimum should be 2.5 million and even that doesn't really cover costs.
Teaching is no longer a money winner in Korea, but offering 2.0 means that you will just get the dregs of the barrel.
Just my 10 won. |
Is 2 Million not enough? From the research we did I found that 2 Million was average? 2.5 Million is pushing it I found and most places won't hire a experienced teacher for that much.
I am not arguing but I am putting forward my view. If its obvoiusly going to be a problem then we can restructure. Also it's Busan (and the surrounding cities) where the living stardards are relatively cheaper than Seoul.
I've also have friends teaching here and they think 2 million is fine considering housing and everything is paid for.
I have a feeling other places pay you a little higher but do dodgy things like not pay taxes or don't contribute to your pension etc. That's just my understanding though.
So is 2million not enough? |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
grnmle
Joined: 13 Sep 2007
|
Posted: Tue Nov 16, 2010 7:51 pm Post subject: |
|
|
2milKRW Where do I sign up? I take everything I said back. I've been looking all over for an honest recruiter with revolutionary ideas that will take me on for the right price.
Better yet pay me in bananas. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
earthquakez
Joined: 10 Nov 2010
|
Posted: Tue Nov 16, 2010 8:06 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Ree Nah, I think it's good you're on talking about this because it gives us a chance to give recruiters a reality check. Not saying this disrespectfully to you, just noting that recruiters need to hear our opinions.
2 points -
1) Shared housing - A big no no for experienced teachers such as myself.
I wouldn't even want it if I was fresh out of university and the kind of teacher that Korean recuiters and employers seem to want. That is, no real experience of teaching anybody English and little full time employment experience. It's just so uni student - shared digs, no privacy,can't choose who you live with so it could be a disaster in waiting.
I've never shared housing with anybody in my Asian jobs or Korean jobs. Never want to. I've lived quite happily in 3 different Asian countries (including Korea) because I could go home and unwind. Didn't have to worry about drunken housemates, drug taking housemates, housemates who hate the country and their jobs bitching endlessly.
2) The idea that 2 million is great for all English teachers. You've got off on the wrong foot already. You indicate you want experienced teachers so you know what? You're going to have to pay for them.
Most genuinely experienced teachers have a couple of degrees, employment history in their home country, English language related job experience, some have taught in other countries, not just Korea. Even with housing thrown in, no teacher like this should be accepting anything lower than 2.3 million per month.
Especially as most housing provided for foreign teachers is terrible. One room with your neighbours living so close that you hear everything they do all night, all morning. No real ventilation apart from a window. Unsanitary bathrooms with no windows and a toilet in the same small place. Very unhygienic especially with shit particles floating out of the toilet. Mould.
I think you mean by 'experienced teachers', those who have taught in Korea for about 2 years. Don't confuse that with what I referred to as experienced. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
ttompatz

Joined: 05 Sep 2005 Location: Kwangju, South Korea
|
Posted: Tue Nov 16, 2010 8:14 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| ReeNah wrote: |
Also I would like to add something else that I've been thinking about.
There are lots of native teachers who are having trouble and at the moment there is really not much they can do yes? I mean there like 25,000+ teachers but when something goes down and they get ripped off there is noone for them to turn to, well apart from this forum.
Is there no union or something like that? I am quite a dreamer and I think maybe one day we (native teachers) could form an organised union and you know work towards a more secure working environment for native speakers.
I know its just a fancy idea at the moment but I don't see why it can't happen in the near future. Just thought I'd throw it in there. |
This is even funnier than your business idea.
Guess you haven't had that much experience in the Korean ESL industry after all.
If you tried it (organize a union for foreign teachers) you would be about number eleventy-seven on the list (ATEK being the most recent) to attempt and fail miserably.
I think you should have a really close look at the constraints that foreign workers really are under in terms of what they can and cannot legally do under their specific status of sojourn.
In terms of your business model you had better take a MUCH closer look at both immigration and the Offices' of Education (city, provincial and national) rules for hiring of foreign teachers (outside the public school system - who does have different rules as a government body).
Your ignorance of the system you intend to work under is blissful but if you actually attempt it as planned you will crash and burn like Pan-Am 103.
Start at the Seoul help center and work your way out from there or join the ranks of the other "middle-men" who lose their shirts and shorts and usually take down a handful of foreigners (stranding them 10,000 miles from home) in the process.
| ReeNah wrote: |
Well our basic wage structure is like this:
Monthly Wage: 2 Million Korean Won
Tax: 3.3%
Pension Contribution: 4.5% of wage (we pay additional 4.5%)
Medical Insurance: 2.835% or wage (we pay additional 2.385%)
We provide housing. Apartments (between 25 and 30 'pyung'). Three bedroom; for three people, same gender. Fridge, Washing Machine, Beds, Wadrobe, TV, AirCon, Boiler Heating. Just your normal apartment. We think its better for people to live together, less lonely etc.
We also plan to have monthly bonuses. Employee of the month, small monetary rewards or coupons to various things.
Also we will hold monthly 'hweshik', like dinners for employees. Where we get-together for dinner and some light drinks (all paid for by us) where we can relax and enjoy a good time. Maybe in the long run we'll hold big Christmas Parties and hold other events such as an Athletics Day etc. Who has been exercising regularly since they got to Korea? I mean everything is home delieverd even at 3am so it's hard not to gain weight I found! We are just starting so most of these are just ideas and concepts we are trying to implement.
Thoughts? |
Oh, and wages of 2 million and shared housing went out with the toilet water back in about 2001.
Every hakwan (and public school) I have ever worked at provided "staff dinners" where we all went out and got fat eating Galbi and then headed out to the noraebang after.
Oh, and your tax rate is that of a "contractor" and NOT that of an "employee".
You are so far off the mark it really does hurt.
Time to actually go to the NPS, NHIC and NTS sites and get some accurate, up-to-date information then add relevant information from immigration and the POEs. Make a stop at the GU office and see what you need to deal with in terms of your business registration (so YOU can actually hire a foreigner) then immigration again to see if you can actually sponsor an E2 (or does the hakwon provide that and you are even more of a blood sucker).
.
.
Last edited by ttompatz on Tue Nov 16, 2010 8:26 pm; edited 2 times in total |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
ReeNah
Joined: 26 Oct 2010
|
Posted: Tue Nov 16, 2010 8:23 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| grnmle wrote: |
2milKRW Where do I sign up? I take everything I said back. I've been looking all over for an honest recruiter with revolutionary ideas that will take me on for the right price.
Better yet pay me in bananas. |
Once again you decide to be a jerk. You could have easily just be civilised about it and said that 2million is no where near enough, or something along those lines.
Okay so 2 million is not enough? We chose a ball park figure that seemed to be the standard around the area. What seems like a more reasonable figure to you grnmle?
To EQ:
Thank you once again for a great post.
Okay shared housing. We are not only recruiting expereinced teachers but also new teachers. We thought our stance on the housing was good. I understand people have different tasted and we have discussed 'rental assistance' instead of providing housing.
Okay wages for an experienced teacher, 2.3mil is okay then? What about a teacher with no teaching experience? Is 2 million not enough?
Now I know we should change our wage structure abit. So different sections for teachers with experience and teachers without. So for example:
No Experience is what I've got above.
Experienced:
Monthly Wage: 2.3~2.5million KRW (depending on experience)
Tax: 3.3%
Pension Contribution: 4.5% of wage (we pay additional 4.5%)
Medical Insurance: 2.835% or wage (we pay additional 2.385%)
Housing: Flexible. Provided in Apartment 3 bedroom option or form of monthly rental assistance? (Maybe 150,000 to 200,000krw) plus we'll help you find a place?
Sounds reasonable? However it's not for me to decide, I'll need to discuss it with work collaegues but I think it's a very valid point.
For a newbie wouldn't our services be very useful? We help you adapt to the new country. If problems arise or if you have any questions we are here to help etc. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
TheUrbanMyth
Joined: 28 Jan 2003 Location: Retired
|
Posted: Tue Nov 16, 2010 8:29 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| ReeNah wrote: |
Well our basic wage structure is like this:
Monthly Wage: 2 Million Korean Won
Tax: 3.3%
Pension Contribution: 4.5% of wage (we pay additional 4.5%)
Medical Insurance: 2.835% or wage (we pay additional 2.385%)
We provide housing. Apartments (between 25 and 30 'pyung'). Three bedroom; for three people, same gender. Fridge, Washing Machine, Beds, Wadrobe, TV, AirCon, Boiler Heating. Just your normal apartment. We think its better for people to live together, less lonely etc.
We also plan to have monthly bonuses. Employee of the month, small monetary rewards or coupons to various things.
Also we will hold monthly 'hweshik', like dinners for employees. Where we get-together for dinner and some light drinks (all paid for by us) where we can relax and enjoy a good time. Maybe in the long run we'll hold big Christmas Parties and hold other events such as an Athletics Day etc. Who has been exercising regularly since they got to Korea? I mean everything is home delieverd even at 3am so it's hard not to gain weight I found! We are just starting so most of these are just ideas and concepts we are trying to implement.
Thoughts? |
While this wage may be alright for a newbie, I would never accept it. I was working for that back in my second year (9 years ago).
Tax is too high. And that is NOT the tax for an employee, that is the tax for an independent contractor which an E-2 visa holder can (generally) not be. The problem with this is that an independent contractor is (legally) responsible for paying ALL his own pension and medical insurance. So I think you can understand why some people are jumping to conclusions that this may be a scam. (Personally I'm withholding judgment for now...but it's not looking good so far. Just a friendly heads-up.)
As for housing for three people think again. On the contracts sticky thread I always advise people to find single housing only. There are several reasons for this. (A) You see your co-workers all day at work...you may not want to see them on your off-time as well. (b) There are many horror stories (or were in the past) of teachers living with a smoker, or kleptomaniac, or just a flat out psychotic freak. (c) Sometimes you just want your own space. (d) If the teacher is married or has a S.O they probably want their privacy.
Monthly bonuses (for Employee of the Month) sound like a good thing in theory but in practice I can see it leading to backstabbing and petty jealousy among teachers both foreign and Korean. I've met so many of both "teachers" here who would sell their own grandmother down the river for an extra 20 won. Not to mention the flip side which is if these gifts are too small some people won't even bother putting in the extra effort.
Dinners are a mixed bag for expats here I've found. Some hate them, some tolerate them and some like them. I'd suggest making them optional and once in a while going to a restaurant that ISN'T Korean.
Last edited by TheUrbanMyth on Tue Nov 16, 2010 8:37 pm; edited 1 time in total |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
shifty
Joined: 21 Jun 2004
|
Posted: Tue Nov 16, 2010 8:34 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| ReeNah wrote: |
1. Tax: 3.3%
2. We think its better for people to live together, less lonely etc.
3. Employee of the month.
4. Also we will hold monthly dinners. Athletics Day etc. |
1. The tax rate suggests that the pension and med will never see the light of day.
2. Koreans like to mill around one another and have narrow personal radius. Waygukins DON"T!!
3. Koreans are singularly unable to judge this.
4. Please, please desist. The horror. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
ReeNah
Joined: 26 Oct 2010
|
Posted: Tue Nov 16, 2010 8:36 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| TheUrbanMyth wrote: |
| ReeNah wrote: |
Well our basic wage structure is like this:
Monthly Wage: 2 Million Korean Won
Tax: 3.3%
Pension Contribution: 4.5% of wage (we pay additional 4.5%)
Medical Insurance: 2.835% or wage (we pay additional 2.385%)
We provide housing. Apartments (between 25 and 30 'pyung'). Three bedroom; for three people, same gender. Fridge, Washing Machine, Beds, Wadrobe, TV, AirCon, Boiler Heating. Just your normal apartment. We think its better for people to live together, less lonely etc.
We also plan to have monthly bonuses. Employee of the month, small monetary rewards or coupons to various things.
Also we will hold monthly 'hweshik', like dinners for employees. Where we get-together for dinner and some light drinks (all paid for by us) where we can relax and enjoy a good time. Maybe in the long run we'll hold big Christmas Parties and hold other events such as an Athletics Day etc. Who has been exercising regularly since they got to Korea? I mean everything is home delieverd even at 3am so it's hard not to gain weight I found! We are just starting so most of these are just ideas and concepts we are trying to implement.
Thoughts? |
While this wage may be alright for a newbie, I would never accept it. I was working for that back in my first year (10 years ago).
Tax is too high. And that is NOT the tax for an employee, that is the tax for an independent contractor which an E-2 visa holder can (generally) not be.
As for housing for three people think again. On the contracts sticky thread I always advise people to find single housing only. There are several reasons for this. (A) You see your co-workers all day at work...you may not want to see them on your off-time as well. (b) There are many horror stories (or were in the past) of teachers living with a smoker, or kleptomaniac, or just a flat out psychotic . (c) Sometimes you just want your own space. (d) If the teacher is married or has a S.O they probably want their privacy.
Monthly bonuses (for Employee of the Month) sound like a good thing in theory but in practice I can see it leading to backstabbing and petty jealousy among teachers both foreign and Korean. I've met so many of both "teachers" here who would sell their own grandmother down the river for an extra 20 won. Not to mention the flip side which is if these gifts are too small some people won't even bother putting in the extra effort.
Dinners are a mixed bag for expats here I've found. Some hate them, some tolerate them and some like them. I'd suggest making them optional and once in a while going to a restaurant that ISN'T Korean. |
Thanks for your input.
I see the troubles that arise from shared housing. Well we'll all see each other often but since people will be working in different institutions they won't see each other at work, unless the place hiring is large and wants more than one of our recruits.
I guess from an organistational view point, its much easier for us to take care of people/recruits if they are in a house together. We can easily organise smokers only houses etc I guess. I wouldn't want to put people who are incompaitble together. We are only starting so that might not be possible at the start, but once we have 10+ I am sure we can work something workable out. Nothing is impossible.
The dinner thing is definately optional. I was hoping it was a positive thing, for people to get-together enjoy a night out with peers.
Why do you think people hate dinners? It'll be made up of the native teachers and around 4 or 5 other employees from our company including myself. We can have it a restuarant, then maybe a bar the month after. Its an idea we are trying to impelement so any ideas or suggestions are most welcome! |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
harshlands101
Joined: 19 Oct 2010
|
Posted: Tue Nov 16, 2010 8:38 pm Post subject: |
|
|
I might of missed this, but seeing as you are employing the hagwons and then paying the teachers directly, and assuming that one of your 'reputable' hagwons goes down the pan, hates a teacher etc etc, do you have enough funds to pay the teacher/s that you placed at that school and will you ensure that the teacher/s do not loose their accomodation and find them a new job.
Will you also be the go-between for the labour board when the hagwon tries the usual sacking at 11 months to avoid paying the flights and severance bonus? Whilst also financially supporting the teacher/s who are having these problems?
To be honest there is no 'revolution' in your idea whatsoever. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
TheUrbanMyth
Joined: 28 Jan 2003 Location: Retired
|
Posted: Tue Nov 16, 2010 8:45 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| ReeNah wrote: |
[
Why do you think people hate dinners? |
Judging what people have said on these very boards a good many do. See the problem is that many people are the sole foreigner at their workplace. So when they go out for dinner all the Korean workers are chattering away in Korean to each other...while the FT likely not understanding a word, (especially if she or he is a newbie) sits by himself in a corner feeling sorry for himself and wishing this dinner would end soon so he can get back to his house.
For me personally it's not that much of an ordeal...I just dislike sitting on the floor as no matter what posture I adopt my legs eventually go to sleep.
But if as you said there would be several foreigners there then yes people might be more inclined to accept the idea. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
shifty
Joined: 21 Jun 2004
|
Posted: Tue Nov 16, 2010 8:49 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| earthquakez wrote: |
The last time I heard "most delightful" from any native speaker of English was an old relative who tends to speak as if the last few decades haven't taken place. |
Haha!! I love this line, can just imagine it. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
|
|