|
Korean Job Discussion Forums "The Internet's Meeting Place for ESL/EFL Teachers from Around the World!"
|
| View previous topic :: View next topic |
| Author |
Message |
fermentation
Joined: 22 Jun 2009
|
Posted: Mon Jul 25, 2011 12:21 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| samd wrote: |
| Do you get to feast on copious amounts of bbqed meat daily, or is the food garbage? |
The food is okay. It isn't as bad as you'd expect. We get meat, although it isn't plentiful. What is plentiful is kimchi and bean sprouts. The worst thing about the food is that I get tired of eating the same thing every day. A lot of guys rather go to the PX and buy microwavable dinners and dumplings. I also never eat korean food when out on leave. I don't think I'll be eating kimchi in a long time after my discharge either. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
fermentation
Joined: 22 Jun 2009
|
Posted: Mon Jul 25, 2011 4:20 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| fezmond wrote: |
what do you do all day? play cards, train, sleep?
i honestly have no idea |
The typical day for us starts at 0600(0630 in winter) with morning roll call, then a 2-3km run, breakfast, and time to shower/rest before work starts at 0830. what kind of work we do depends on the unit and MOS of each individual. My unit supports our division's HQ and staff so it's more varied than your typical infantry unit. There are guys who work in an office with staff officers, guys who stand guard all day in front of the base entrance, guys who fix broken pipes and electrical wiring in the HQ buildling, and guys who cook. Im in charge of human resources in the barracks so I sit front of a computer all day and do paper work. Most people think I have it easy but I'd rather be out jumping out of a helicopter. Work ends at 1700 but our general really stresses the importance of PT so at 1630 we have 4-6km run.
After work and on the weekends we have free time to study, read, watch tv, sleep, work out, etc. Of course "free time" isnt really freetime here. We always have to expect to be interrupted for some cleaning/sweeping/shoveling detail that always seem to pop up. Some high ranking officer decides that there are too many flower petals on the road or there's too much snow or something. BTW, snow is the ROK conscript's worst enemy. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
jvalmer

Joined: 06 Jun 2003
|
Posted: Mon Jul 25, 2011 5:33 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| With all that running I bet you get into shape pretty fast... |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
fermentation
Joined: 22 Jun 2009
|
Posted: Mon Jul 25, 2011 9:43 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| DIsbell wrote: |
Did you ever experience/witness any bullying or sexual abuse?
|
Yes. I think there are three types of abuse here. Guys getting chewed out for doing something wrong, guys getting harsher treatment than warranted, and guys who get treated like crap just because they can. Most of the abuse is the second one but there is plenty the latter. Of course I'm speaking of my own experiences but you have to know that every unit has it's own sort of culture and tradition. Even in my own barracks, a platoon or room might have different rules to one right next to it, although they're in the same building and unit. Different branches are also different. The general consensus is that the Air Force is the most lenient, and the Marine Corp the most strict (lots of bullying). The Army and Navy are somewhere in the middle.
The platoon I'm in has more upperclass, educated guys so it wasn't as bad as some others. I have seen in other units guys getting punched/kicked "playfully" for no other reason than just because. I have seen in a church of all places a corporal sucking and biting the ears of two privates in front of him. Some guys like to sleep holding eachother as well. Its still not as bad as I expected going in.
| Quote: |
| You hinted that you've come to a conclusion about the Army and the society supportive of it, so I'm also curious as to what your thoughts are. |
I didn't really come to a conclusion. I just have thoughts and opinions. I entered thinking the Army will be absolute hell and that I will never befriend a Korean. It sucks yes, but it still not as bad as I thought (I expected regular beatings and expected at least one guy to try to sexually harass me) and Koreans being people, not everybody was a douche. There are a lot of douches but most of them aren't really bad guys, they're just put through the system like everybody else. Without any real training or education or option offered, you can't always blame guys for thinking verbally abusing subordinates is the only way to get them in line. The few true leaders who emerge are rare gems. They exist, albiet scarce. I did make "friends" with Koreans and most of them turned out to be other dudes who have lived in English speaking countries.
I hated Korean society for still supporting such a terrible system. I don't hate it now, but I think the general mindset people have of the military needs to change. I think its sad how people just sort of give into the "system." I can't let myself off the hook either. One thing that bothers me is that most older men I meet and the guys who are going through service now don't think of doing away this system so their sons can live freer lives. Rather, Korean guys have this mentality that since they had to do it, everybody else should. I'm not sure Korea is willing to pay the money to support an all-volunteer force and all the talk of "real men do it" is just a way to justify conscription. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
cisco kid

Joined: 13 Nov 2003 Location: Outlaws had us pinned down at the fort
|
Posted: Tue Jul 26, 2011 12:04 am Post subject: |
|
|
Hey fermy, I remember when you got drafted, seems like it was longer than two years ago. And then I remember you checked in w/us about a year or so ago maybe? In any case, I knew about the 'hazing' mentality from people close to me that had been in, but no one was able to articulate it as well as you (of course).
Having been through hazing of many sorts (military and civilian), I can say it really does suck, and perpetuates itself. Anyway, you'll be out soon - what are your plans? Good luck man, have some fun in your new freedom.  |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
shifty
Joined: 21 Jun 2004
|
Posted: Tue Jul 26, 2011 1:09 am Post subject: |
|
|
South Africans in the days of apartheid also endured conscription.
I recognize the life immediately from the OP; very similar, if not identical.
A lot of guys got quite nervous just before intake, and asked questions to see if they would cope. The answer was 'Think of your worst nightmare and then triple that'. This appeared a tease, but in fact quite true. It was far worse than any possible anticipation.
The training is to toughen you mentally and that's why it's so hard.
Some guys really weren't cut out for it and there were some suicides. Usually the suicides would coincide with first few visits to the shooting range and an unspent round withheld.
In the first few weeks many AWOLS as well. These often missed crucial segments of their training and never quite recovered, ongoing misery.
A lot depends on what unit you're in. In my time the admin and technical people would just have an arduous basics and then freewheeling. Air force and navy also was a cruise. Sounds like the OP is admin with a bit of wake up run here and there.
But the majority; the armor, infantry, engineers, artillery, signals etc have it uniformly tough.
What I liked about the army was that we were treated like men, that is, it wasn't like school where corporal punshment was allowed on a pettifogging basis. It was hard, but in a manly way, leaders not worth their salt quickly found out.
All the conscripts that I knew were ultimately glad that they had to go. It makes a man of you. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
fermentation
Joined: 22 Jun 2009
|
Posted: Wed Jul 27, 2011 1:44 am Post subject: |
|
|
| jvalmer wrote: |
I think the experience depends what you get drafted into and your personality. I've met people that just delivered mail for 2 years, or drive some truck around, or watched for fires in the forest, and other who had to be on the DMZ. Some absolutely hated it, some liked it and most just felt neutral about it (something they just have to do).
My guess is it all comes down to personality on how those 2 years go for your average Korean male. |
Yes your experience will depend a lot on where you're places and what MOS you have. I'm lucky to have been placed unit close to Seoul (it takes me 20mins to get home) while others guys take hours to get home when on leave. My girlfriend and parents can visit me every month while some dudes have never been visited by family because they're so far away. While I didn't want it, most people envy my desk-jockey position and some even suspect that my father (former LTC in the Air Force) used his connections in the military to get me a comfy position. I actually changed my MOS and platoon. I was in my unit's Security Platoon where we did more "soldierly" work (standing guard, packing sandbags, setting up camouflage netting etc) and I enjoyed it more even though it was harder on my body. But our CO was in need of a guy who can do admin work so I was chosen.
Some MOS are even better. Personal drivers for generals are allowed to carry cellphones and sleep/work in their repsective commander's house. But such comfy jobs also come with more psychological stress since you have to deal with high ranking officers everyday. Imagine what the worrying these guys do when driving around the two-star general. I'd rather be digging trenches than deal with and officer. Whatever position you have, you'll still have to deal with the "system": the multiple layers of bureaucracy, politics and gossip, the favoritism and arse-kissing, last minute changes and out-of-touch decisions from the top. No matter what MOS, how long you've been in, the Army is a suffocating place. It's a place void of all reason and logic. You think Korean civilians lack logic? Try dealing with Korean soldiers.
Conscripts who enjoy military life are extremely rare. Even NCOs and officers who enjoy it are not that common. They do it because its a secure living.
| andrewchon wrote: |
| How often the newbies cry? |
I've only seen only a couple guys tear up. One PVT (20 year old with very little social experience) after getting torn up by a senior, and another after I praised him for his hard work.
| marsavalanche wrote: |
| you got any advice for the ladies brah? |
Advice for women who are thinking of joining the service? I advise against it. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
fermentation
Joined: 22 Jun 2009
|
Posted: Wed Jul 27, 2011 2:03 am Post subject: |
|
|
| jvalmer wrote: |
| With all that running I bet you get into shape pretty fast... |
Not really. You get used to running but that's it. Some guys use the army to put in work and get fit, but a lot of guys get fatter here. I think its because eating is one of the few ways conscripts can quell their frustrations here. I'm not just talking about admin guys either, a good plenty of infantry battalions are full of plump targets for the NK.
| cisco kid wrote: |
Hey fermy, I remember when you got drafted, seems like it was longer than two years ago. And then I remember you checked in w/us about a year or so ago maybe? In any case, I knew about the 'hazing' mentality from people close to me that had been in, but no one was able to articulate it as well as you (of course).
Having been through hazing of many sorts (military and civilian), I can say it really does suck, and perpetuates itself. Anyway, you'll be out soon - what are your plans? Good luck man, have some fun in your new freedom.  |
It hasn't been two years yet although it felt like two decades. I've said before I can't hate guys for being products of their environment but still, a part of me would be tempted to sock some of the seniors or officers if I saw them on the street. Some were just absolute douches. A few were very poor excuses for human beings.
| shifty wrote: |
| leaders not worth their salt quickly found out. |
If true, the South African military is in a better state than ours.
| Quote: |
| All the conscripts that I knew were ultimately glad that they had to go. It makes a man of you. |
Can't speak for you, but I hear this so much from Koreans and it really is a bunch of bollocks. Its only a way to justify to yourself what you went through. Because that's easier than going against the rest of society and criticizing something everybody else seems to accept. I've met guys saying "it made them a man" and that they learned valuable lessons. I'm sorry, you're not a man if the only you way you can learn to be one is by being coerced and threatened. I've always thought "men" do what they believe in by their own accord. [/quote] |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
shifty
Joined: 21 Jun 2004
|
Posted: Wed Jul 27, 2011 4:10 am Post subject: |
|
|
[quote="fermentation"]
| shifty wrote: |
| leaders not worth their salt quickly found out. |
| Quote: |
| If true, the South African military is in a better state than ours. |
I'm probably thinking a different context to you. I'm on about junior leaders such as lower level NCO's and 2nd lieutenants. They have to establish their authority over bodies of men who are quick to sense and exploit any lack of confidence. It takes some doing for an slightly-built NCO to assert himself over all shapes and sizes.
I remember in particular, in my troop we had a giant provincial boxing champion. The NCO stood 2 cm away from him peering into his eyes and asked, "Do you want to hit me?" There was a long silence as the boxer stood full length and tried to intimidate with a half-smile on his face. Finally, he muttered "No, corporal." And the day was won for the corp., his authority forever vested over that brute.
The leader has to have a genuine confidence since any diffidence will end in his humiliation.
| Quote: |
| All the conscripts that I knew were ultimately glad that they had to go. It makes a man of you. |
| Quote: |
| I'm sorry, you're not a man if the only you way you can learn to be one is by being coerced and threatened. I've always thought "men" do what they believe in by their own accord. |
I think this quoted bit is simplistic. How people are welded from nothing into a trained force is complicated and one complexity is that those individuals have a growth spurt. I was meaning that you discover your limits, limits far greater than suspected beforehand. So I think that could be classified as learning valuable lessons.
In our first days, getting issued with kit and innoculations, we got a few speeches from some middle ranking officers. The one said, "You come here as boys, but you will leave as men". In retrospect I think he was right.
On another note, one time, there was a surplus of sausage that had to be dispensed with and we were ordered to eat it all. One wag piped up, "In the army, even the good times are bad".
A play on the song title, 'Even the bad times are good'. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
shifty
Joined: 21 Jun 2004
|
Posted: Wed Jul 27, 2011 11:14 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| fermentation wrote: |
| I have seen in other units guys getting punched/kicked "playfully" for no other reason than just because. |
I knew a lieutenant who was demoted to 2nd lieutenant for excessive striking of the troops. But otherwise, while commonplace, it is lowkey stuff. Eg, say marching drill where in the army, excellence is required. The NCO comes behind a squaddie who's a bit 'off', whispers some choice words in his ear and ends with a rabbit punch or bangs his fists together.
Most often the entire squad is punished for one individual's failings. If the instructor really wants something done about an inept soldier, he keeps punishing all for that one's sins.
At any rate, quite early on we used to get lectures and parameters of physical abuse spelled out to us, that 'undue provocation' can cause the instructor to be in the right. Turned out to be 100% of the time.
I agreed with it all, since the instructors had a big job. Eg, where a troopie is looking at his superior with hatred in his eyes; would cause the instructor to justifiably pile into the errant. A dirty rifle barrel would find the rifle butt in the owner's stomach or foot.
But really this wasn't ever an overall concern, recruits had much bigger fish to fry.
| Quote: |
| I'm not sure Korea is willing to pay the money to support an all-volunteer force |
Would an all-volunteer force be necessarily more expensive?
I think Rhodesia (now Zimbabwe) should have gone this route. A dedicated small force is very efficient. For example, in South Africa's border war, the commanders had to keep reckoning manpower with the fact that that conscript intake was close to discharge date, causing some upheaval. The replacement intake had to be made familiar with the particular circumstances causing some loss in efficiency. Special operations could have to be delayed on this account.
In Rhodesia typically, when a one-man-show businessman was called up for an extended stint, his business would often collapse.
I don't really know about Korea in this regard, but I suspect they'd be better off with a dedicated force. Such is the speed of battle nowadays, it would take forever to get mobilisation effective in any event. By the time a Korean is finished with his call-up, and then university, he's getting near his thirties before even looking like becoming productive. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
shifty
Joined: 21 Jun 2004
|
Posted: Thu Jul 28, 2011 7:30 am Post subject: |
|
|
I hope I'm not boring you guys with all my reminiscences. If I am, please read no further.
| fezmond wrote: |
what do you do all day? play cards, train, sleep?
i honestly have no idea |
It depends on the unit. If you're Admin or Technical Services you do about 8 weeks basics and then posted as a clerk or mechanic somewhere. Quite nice, but it has its own frustrations as presented by the OP.
If you're in a frontline fighting battalion, the basics merge into ongoing hard training. I was in for a year, and times I felt really down after a bad day. If the call-up had been 2 years my nose would have been more out of joint, as counting the days is an obsession in the army, worse than EFL in Korea..
I think 2 years would have been intolerable.
During basics there is full-kit inspection every morning weekdays at 6.30. I used to get up with some others at 4am, b/c making the bed in the prescribed manner takes long. All that you possess must be on the bed and in the steel closet. On the bed, the rifle, with working mechanism in spread arrangement. All spare socks must look 'puffed up' so you need to find some cardboard to achieve this. A full set of razor, soap, toothbrush, toothpaste that you use only for inspection. So the toothpaste has no dimples in it and the toothbrush bristles remain firm and there's no gunk in the razor..
On the closet, spare boots must gleam, with soles polished as well. Your great coat has to be trussed up in prescribed manner and on the bed; I never got that right.
The floor of the bungalow has to be polished. In the final moments before inspection we'd slide about on bits of cloth so that our boots didn't leave telltale signs. The handles on the windows had to be brassoed and the sand in the fire buckets outside smoothed and the gravel outside the bungalow brushed. So we had to work together.
Breakfast at 5.45am. It is a punishable offence to not breakfast since you are state property. Before breakfast, a shower and a shave. You can understand why I got up at 4.
Inspection itself was always a nerve-wracking affair with all manner of unbelievable shouting, swearing and insults.
After inspection, Battle PT for 1 and a half hours. This is much harder than mere running, although running is a sizeable element. One form of Battle PT is pole PT where 2 guys carry the pole with one hanging in the middle. Not fun.
Back to the barracks for a 10 minute break to change from overalls into regular combat fatigues. The rest of the morning is taken by drilling, frequented by sessions of collective punishment. The punishment is typically running up and down an embankment.
Finally lunch. The food the finest you could ever have, like a banquet. Dessert each day and all manner of premium jams for bread.
In the afternoon, we'd have to stand in a battalion while they bullied us about, finding fault with all ad hoc things. Once an NCO claimed that he'd overheard one of us talking smack about them in the showers and this accounted for his rightous wrath. Until 4 pm when the second bout of battle PT would take place, although the accent here was more on running. Dinner at 5.45 and sporadic evening inspections.
Sometimes the inspections could start at 7pm and go right through on the hour until one am after they had continually trashed the bungalow. Bits of your rifle inner mechanism strewn across the floor and they had ordered the use of fire buckets to throw water across the floor. We had to work quick to restore in the balance of the hour for the next one.
Wed afternoon we had to choose a sport. We just went through the motions b/c we were exhausted.
We did full-kit route marches quite often, but they were tame affairs in comparison with the Battle PT. Guess what, at the end of the march, when you had reached your destination, the Battle PT would start.
We also spent about 2 weeks in tents in the bush learning camouflage and a variety of lore. They really put us through it there and we were often at the end of our tether.
After basics it was more or less the same, but fewer inspections. We had to learn codes, radio and map reading. For map reading they'd take us after dark by truck into the grounds designated military use.
I remember the first one, my own map reading was definitely shaky so I just waited for our group to come up with something. There was a dirty great mountain next to us and the guys who seemed to have a clue worked out that we had to go over the mountain. Doing that in the inky black was a real ball of fun.
I won't go into the rest of it, but in brief it was about .30 and .5 Browning machine guns. Getting a licence for a 3 tonner truck and then a licence for a Panhard armored car and how to work their main armament. Once I drove one over a hill. It had 8 gears and I used the lowest to climb the hill at 2 k/h. Coming down the other side, one had to tack, else it would fall end over end.
Well, you asked!! Can you imagine how my family stays clear of me when the subject of army gets raised? |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
shifty
Joined: 21 Jun 2004
|
Posted: Mon Aug 01, 2011 12:48 am Post subject: |
|
|
Another in what is becoming a series of posts from me on the topic. As I have said, noone is obliged to read, purely voluntary.
Following on my last post, I could have mentioned that it is difficult to change tack driving an armored car down a hill, since sometimes a boulder gets jammed into one of the front wheels and the steering feels locked.
When I jumped out at the bottom my whole body was trembling and my legs felt like rotten bananas.
The instructors we had were Permanent Force or career soldiers, called as a whole, PF's. They mostly had rank of corporal, which in the South African army had a lot of clout, perhaps b/c of a flatter hierarchy than other armies. These instructors were highly motivated and incorruptible, such was the nationalist leaning in the country, as well as looming emergency vis a vis our politics.
I would expect there are some parallels with South Korean forces.
Our 2nd lieutenants were mostly conscripts. They had been told to listen and learn from the PF NCO's and tacitly told to keep a wide berth from any friction. For their part, the PF corporals held them in calculated disdain. They had of course to salute them, but pulled all sorts of ploys to make their lack of respect palpable.
Otherwise these PF NCO's had a brotherhood with the PF officers and were supported by them. Our conscript officers mainly just kept a watching brief.
Incidentally, there was a time that certified teachers were axiomatically held as officer material, but that was quietly downscaled and seen in a more common sense light.
At the shooting range the firing contingent had their counterparts in the target pit. The target could be pulleyed up and down from the pit into the air. The guys manning the pit had long 15 foot rods with a metal pointer at the tip. One side was red which would denote bullseye. The opposite side black was to show in the circle outside the bullseye ring. If the pointer was swung black from side to side, it meant complete miss and outside anything that counted.
If it was your turn to shoot, you could scan from left to right and check where the instuctors were. Usually they'd be busy with individuals constantly shooting miss and had a boot in the small of their backs to encourage focus.
At this moment of no supervision you took a shot, then waited for the pointer. As the pointer showed, shoot immediately and hit the pointer. The bullet hitting the metal pointer would cause the guy in the pit to get a nice fright with the sudden unpleasant vibration going through the rod.
There'd be a long no show, with him unsure if you had simply made an error or had done it on purpose. Then finally, up it would come again and you'd give it the treatment. Then there'd be a long pissed off no show.
Once I had my own mate in the pit. So he gives me full score like 40 out of 40 for each distance. When the marks came over the radio, all heads turned to me as if to assess if I really looked an eagle eye sniper. I could feel myself blush. If he could have just used his brains and given me a 36 or 37. Still good for a sharp shooter badge and allay interest in sending me to sniper school. Very embarrassing!!
We also fired Uzi sub machine guns. They were from Israel (SA and them were buddies in crime at the stage). The magazine held 30 rounds and if you didn't run up to the target and follow the dust path you could fire all 30 rounds miss. In other words you had to sacrifice some to get some.
At long range with rifles, sometimes the guy next to you would misalign and put all his shots through your target causing a nice fat score. Although a radio message from the pit would alert the instructors and the miscreant would feel a boot in his back .
We had also to do live firing in the bush. You'd run with the instructor directly behind you and you'd have to double tap the targets that had been secreted behind the bushes, causing you to gyrate as you belatedly spotted them. I remember how nervous the instructors were b/c they imagined that someone would take revenge on them and swing right around and shoot them in a deniable accident.
In the eighties the USSR had its back to the wall as America achieved ascendancy. The Russians needed a big fillip and was after Africa, using its surrogates the Cubans. If they had succeeded in taking Africa with all its minerals plus the prestige of having a whole continent gone communist the wall would only have fallen in much later years.
So the West has quite a debt to the South African Defence Force and all its doings. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Paddycakes
Joined: 05 May 2003 Location: Seoul
|
Posted: Mon Aug 01, 2011 1:39 am Post subject: |
|
|
Question for the OP:
What do they do with the guys who are just totally and absolutely unable to hack even basic training?
Maybe I'm thinking of westerners, but there are a lot of guys out there who could not hack 8 weeks of what you just described... they just couldn't do it... their personalities are so non-average or mainstream conventional that they'd never fit in the system no matter how hard you tried.
What happens to these guys? Do they just skip basic and do something else? |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
nukeday
Joined: 13 May 2010
|
Posted: Mon Aug 01, 2011 1:42 am Post subject: |
|
|
damn, shifty. thread hijack!
I'd be what Paddycakes described, unable to adjust to anal retentive routines. Plus I'd probably collapse and die during PT.
I'm not obese, either. Just amazingly nonathletic. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
shifty
Joined: 21 Jun 2004
|
Posted: Mon Aug 01, 2011 2:19 am Post subject: |
|
|
Yeah, sorry bout the hijack.
Well, the powers that be weren't entirely merciless. Sometimes a guy would just disappear. He wasn't rollcalled anymore, so not AWOL. I think they'd quietly dispatched him to somewhere as a clerk.
However, they'd be quite judicious about that, else it would be catchy.
For example, during Battle PT, if a guy had an ankle sprain or similar, he would be forced to carry on, regardless. If he were allowed to fall out, it's just amazing how many others would get opportunistic.
If the instructors were unsure in a given situation, they'd insist that the soldier sick report, to cover their backs.
We knew, however, to not do any bogus sick reporting. On the return from the hospital the news would come through and the fraud's life would be worth tuppence. But even if you'd had incurred something genuine, you'd be a marked man on your return.
Another safeguard was the rigorous medical done on the first one or two days. One would see a little group outside the main gate awaiting transport, going home. Lucky sods!
One schoolfriend of mine wasn't even initially called up, owing to curvature of the spine. I couldn't see anything wrong with him, ridiculous. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
|
|