|
Korean Job Discussion Forums "The Internet's Meeting Place for ESL/EFL Teachers from Around the World!"
|
| View previous topic :: View next topic |
| Author |
Message |
Dodge7
Joined: 21 Oct 2011
|
Posted: Sun Jul 08, 2012 4:39 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| LuckyNomad wrote: |
My first son is just two years old now. He has been in a preschool for a little less than a year. I don't think the kids his age are old enough to quite get that he is different. Though they are often surprised when I pick him up at the bus stop so it must click in their heads.
To elementary school kids my sons are 외국인 babies. And then I have to explain to them that their mother is Korean. To which the question is always, "Koreans can marry foreigners? What?!" Yes! Go ask your parents about it and I'm sure they'll be happy to explain the facts of life to you.
To teenagers they are 혼혈. Teenage girls will say, "I envy them. They don't have to get plastic surgery." Uhh, yeah..
To adults they are either labeled as cute or simply exotic looking and everyone has to point out that they look like their father and that is the reason they are cute(wife hates hearing this every time she steps out of the house) . To nobody in this country are they Korean. Apparently you have to win a gold medal or become a famous celebrity to gain that status. That's when the country will claim you as their own.
As far as languages goes, from the time he started talking until a couple of months ago, my first son's dominant language was Korean. I've always read to him in english and we both use Korean and english with him but his mother used to use more Korean with him than she does now.
Now that he can use sentences we both put a lot of effort into using mostly english in the house. We also have him watch all his favorite shows in english using BTV. These days his english is at least equal to his Korean. |
Underlined: LOL
Bolded: So all you did was converse mostly in English, as did you wife, and put on English videos and cartoon programs and his ENglish is par with his Korean?
I really want to do what Steelrails said and go home when my daughter begins talking, but my wife is so opposed living in America right now, mostly because of money and being away from her mother. I hope to just take my daughter with me and the two of us can just go live with my grandmother for a few months each year. <----anyone try the live in your home country for a few months each year thing, and how was it?
It both really makes my sad and angry that my child will be the black sheep in this country. It really makes me want to go on a soapbox in the middle of town and berate them, when will these kinds of things stop? It must start in the home, but parents themselves are the same way, unfortunately, most times. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
LuckyNomad
Joined: 28 May 2007
|
Posted: Sun Jul 08, 2012 8:09 pm Post subject: |
|
|
I'll try my best to describe his situation and you can take from it what you will.
My first son is now 26 months old.
He lives with Me, his mother and his aunt.
The aunt usually uses Korean but sometimes uses her substandard english.
His mother used to use mostly Korean with him but now she uses more of a balance. I almost always use English with him. Just about everyone else he comes into contact with uses Korean.
Now. I don't think he learned much english naturally at first. I made an effort and still make an effort to teach him all the time. When we go outside I point to everything and tell him what it is and what color it is, etc.
"That's a blue truck."
That's a green car."
"It's a purple flower."
"That's a tree."
"What's that?"
If he points at a bus and says, "It's blue car." I correct him and tell him "It's a blue bus." Now instead of calling everything a car, he uses truck, bus, and car. Sometimes he still uses "Car," as a universal term for vehicles but when he does I correct him and he repeats it correctly.
He can say, "Yellow bus coming." "Blue car going."
He knows most basic body parts in both languages and sometimes when he forgets the english word he will say it in Korean.
He began really learning numbers on the elevator. We always read the numbers as the elevator went up or down and now he reads them himself. Also I made cards with colors, numbers, and animals on them and played, "bring me the blue card, bring me the 3, bring me the lion." He really likes those kinds of games.
He greets everyone with hello and says goodbye with, Good bye even to Koreans.
He knows the alphabet and can spell using it but doesn't know anything about hangeul.
He only counts using english. He doesn't seem to know how to count in Korean.
He knows all the basic colors in english. He also knows some of them in Korean. He used to almost always say them in Korean but now he almost always says them in english.
He always calls me 아파. And almost never uses Daddy. Though he knows the word.
He and his brother often wake up early in the morning at which time me and my wife are like zombies. So we turn on the TV and let him watch shows in english while we lay on the living room floor half asleep. He watches TV after school too. I don't feel bad about all that TV watching because he learns from it and often repeats what they say on TV.
So I think the most important thing to do is talk to your kid, a lot. More than you would to a normal person. Narrate every little thing you and everyone else does when you're doing it so she/he gets words, words, and words. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Lolimahro
Joined: 19 May 2009
|
Posted: Sun Jul 08, 2012 10:22 pm Post subject: |
|
|
My son is not mixed-race but I hope no one minds if I chime in for a second about what we've been doing for his language ability.
My son has been attending Korean daycare since he was 14 months old (before he even said his first word) and has been attending Korean Kindergarten since March 2012. He will be 4 in September.
As I work 9 hours a day and my husband is a full-time student, my son has been attending child care and kindergarten 5 days a week, between 8 and 10 hours a day. Thus, most of his daily interactions with both adults and other children happen in Korean. As a result, I've been concerned about his English language development as well as his Korean (actually his Korean worries me more because neither his father nor I speak Korean very well). However, he appears to have acquired both pretty proficiently.
Some of the things we do in our house (though I can't guarantee which, if any, produced the best results in his language development):
1. We speak to him in English all the time. While at meal times, giving him a bath, on the bus, etc. There's not a quiet moment in our house. It sounds annoying but he loves the attention and I've come to accept that constant chatter is a reality of life with a 3-year-old. *^^* We never punish our child for talking to much, or encourage him to be quiet (except at bedtime, and maybe dinner if he's not eating at all). I understand that in mixed-heritage households there will be language(s) that will be used in addition to English, but if the English speaker uses English most of the time, or sets aside constructive time every day to engage a child in the language, then I think that's an important part of encouraging a child's language development.
2. We read books to him in English every day. At first I wanted to read to him in Korean but I don't want him to pick up my bad pronunciation, so we just quit that and read books in English. I'm not suggesting others, especially with native speakers of Korean in the family, stop reading books in Korean - alternatively, reading at least one story book in English every day, and talking about it (critical thinking and comprehension - who are the characters? what are they doing? why did they do that? what happened? what will happen next? What do you think? How would that make you feel? etc...) is beneficial. Sometimes we just look at photo albums and talk about them. We try to answer every question he asks, no matter how silly or mundane.
We have books about trucks, tools, pirates, bugs, babies, etc. Every time there's a new life event (going to a new school, moving to a new home, new baby to be born) we go to What the Book and get a Berenstain Bears (or whatever) book about it. Sometimes I even read kids' novels to him (one chapter a night) and he falls asleep that way. Reading to children helps promote literacy skills in any language, especially when accompanied by discussion of the stories.
3. We watch TV programs in English only. This wasn't intentional - it was how he ended up liking it. We have found that TV programs that feature characters who are both children and adults really have developed our son's vocabulary (he was talking about hayrides the other day, something we certainly have never discussed living in Korea). Caillou, Little Einsteins, The Backyardigans and Max & Ruby are favorites in our house. TV programs with repetitive themes (Thomas the Train, etc.) provide a more limited amount of vocabulary (generally speaking) so it's good to be aware of that.
4. We call Grandma and Grandpa in the U.S. every once in awhile and they chat together over the TV. It's good for them to see him and also he has to speak English to his grandparents and other extended family members in the U.S.! Increasing the amount of situations in which a child has to use the target language will encourage them to use that language more, I think.
5. For the last few months, we have been working through a book of ABCs, numbers, etc. for pre-schoolers that we bought at Costco. Sometimes my mom sends coloring activity books from the U.S. for learning shapes, rhyming, comparing, and other cognitive/critical thinking skills for pre-kindergarten. Since it's a one-on-one activity that's focused solely on him, he loves doing it and he really is proud of himself. (Really, though, any one-on-one time you spend with your kid engaging them in English - and not in front of the TV - will help produce more language skills; play-dough, coloring, reading, activity books, playing with stickers, board games, etc. are all activities that can spur a lot of conversation).
6. We make him ask for things in complete sentences. This is actually part of his manners training. I got tired of hearing things like "I want milk!" and "Give me milk!" He has to say "May I have some milk please?" or he doesn't get anything. Sometimes we have to feed him the right phrase but with enough practice he gets it down. I wish I could teach my son Korean manners but all I know is how to use manners in English, so I do the best I can, I guess.
I'm sure there's more things we could be doing. I think just a little bit of one-on-one time with the kids every day is so important; I wish I could spend more!
As for how he's getting along at school, it seems to be mostly positive. He doesn't share any particularly negative experiences with us, but his teacher did say the kids cheer and clap when he arrives at school (this was back in April). I don't know, I think he just wants to be treated like a regular kid, even though he looks different than others and can speak English. He's very resistant to talking to strangers and won't speak English on the playground. I have always been concerned that kids will just be his friend so they can learn English (pressure from moms), but it seems he has some genuine friends that he's been in the same class with for the last 2 years (spanning both daycare and kindergarten). Hopefully it lasts through kindergarten and he has good relationships in elementary school, too. I'm really happy to hear that other expats' children have had positive experiences in elementary school. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
v88
Joined: 28 Feb 2010 Location: here
|
Posted: Sun Jul 08, 2012 10:47 pm Post subject: |
|
|
My boy will be 2 in a month. He speaks both Korean and English, but gets Korean most of the time so he prefers it. My wife and I talk to him in both languages and translate most things that we say so that he gets all the basics in two languages. He watches both Korean and English shows. We aren't too worried as we plan to leave in the near future. We're actually more worried about his Korean ability and will need to put some work into that when we move.
He has been going to daycare for about a year, mostly on a part time basis, but full time recently so mom can work. I love daycare, it has really improved his speaking. I love the fact that he has all these kids to talk to and interact with and the teachers to teach him things that perhaps my wife and I would not. No complaints yet about him being a halfie. The kids all notice he's different, but they don't really clue into the reality of what it might mean to be a foreigner in Korea. They do touch him endlessly and it was a little rough when all the older girls wouldn't leave him alone. They just had to touch his blond hair.
The playgrund is more annoying for me and it can be a bit annoying for my wife too. Even shopping the endless "Look a foreign baby!" gets annoying. Even when my wife is with him without me. Blows my mind. With some people there is just no such thing as a middle ground, or the possibility that anyone with less than 100% Korean genes can be Korean. Bloody Korean purity nonsense pisses me off. At the play ground kids activily argue about his race and continually comment on it. No one can just play with him because he's a cute kid, it's always because he's a cute foreign kid, a novelty. I sometimes like to ask kids if they are Chinese, at which point most kids just get angry. Works sometimes on older kids. I really hate it when parents just stand and giggle as their kid points and yammers about the foreign kid with the strange hair. People endlessly take pictures of him in public too. Most of it isn't bad, Koreans really just think he's cute. There is a lot of curiosity about mixed kids these days, but I wish they understood that he is not just a novelty. He is my little boy and he'll grow up to be a normal person who actually likes Kimchi, cheeseburgers and christ knows what else. I really wish Koreans wouldn't be so hung up on their Koreaness and how strange it is that others might also like it. It's not like I go to Burger King and stand slack jawed at all the Koreans eating burgers.
I'd like to film a parody of how I feel I get treated sometimes. Perhaps I'd film my self or a friend walking around saying Anyong to everyone. Perhaps interview people and ask if they like burgers and cheese, if they can handle greasy food, and if they like America. Perhaps tell people about the the important sovereign lands of America stolen by the vile Canadians. Remind people of the things that Japanese did to Americans in WWII and ask people to demand that Japan say sorry for bombing Pearl Harbor... |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Who's Your Daddy?
Joined: 30 May 2010 Location: Victoria, Canada.
|
Posted: Sun Jul 08, 2012 11:34 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| v88 wrote: |
| At the play ground kids activily argue about his race and continually comment on it. No one can just play with him because he's a cute kid, it's always because he's a cute foreign kid, a novelty. I sometimes like to ask kids if they are Chinese, at which point most kids just get angry. Works sometimes on older kids. I really hate it when parents just stand and giggle as their kid points and yammers about the foreign kid with the strange hair. People endlessly take pictures of him in public too. Most of it isn't bad, Koreans really just think he's cute. There is a lot of curiosity about mixed kids these days, but I wish they understood that he is not just a novelty. He is my little boy and he'll grow up to be a normal person ... |
To be honest this thread is depressing me, and making me think I have to move my family home. Do you really think your boy will grow up to be normal? This sounds terrible. My son is only 8 months and he's treated this way.
Secondly, I guess, my takeaway from above is it's like fighting the tide here in getting him to properly speak English. I want to actually have in depth conversations with my son later, not ESL-level conversations. And to have your child and mother talking in Korean while you sit there? WTF kind of life is that. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Steelrails

Joined: 12 Mar 2009 Location: Earth, Solar System
|
Posted: Sun Jul 08, 2012 11:42 pm Post subject: |
|
|
As someone who has grown up being different and being in a multi-cultural family and has dozens of friends who grew up with culture gaps between their family, it isn't easy, but it isn't that hard. Kids are strong and life goes on.
Immigrants the world over have done it before for the last 200 years. If they can do it, we can too.
That being said, as a parent, I will want to give my kid the best opportunity in a global economy, and clearly proficiency in English is a must for that. I wouldn't worry too much about the cultural and racist aspects and being an outsider. Trust me, its not that bad. I would seriously worry about lacking development in English.
Get them to Grandma! |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Dodge7
Joined: 21 Oct 2011
|
Posted: Mon Jul 09, 2012 2:35 am Post subject: |
|
|
| Who's Your Daddy? wrote: |
| v88 wrote: |
| At the play ground kids activily argue about his race and continually comment on it. No one can just play with him because he's a cute kid, it's always because he's a cute foreign kid, a novelty. I sometimes like to ask kids if they are Chinese, at which point most kids just get angry. Works sometimes on older kids. I really hate it when parents just stand and giggle as their kid points and yammers about the foreign kid with the strange hair. People endlessly take pictures of him in public too. Most of it isn't bad, Koreans really just think he's cute. There is a lot of curiosity about mixed kids these days, but I wish they understood that he is not just a novelty. He is my little boy and he'll grow up to be a normal person ... |
To be honest this thread is depressing me, and making me think I have to move my family home. Do you really think your boy will grow up to be normal? This sounds terrible. My son is only 8 months and he's treated this way.
Secondly, I guess, my takeaway from above is it's like fighting the tide here in getting him to properly speak English. I want to actually have in depth conversations with my son later, not ESL-level conversations. And to have your child and mother talking in Korean while you sit there? WTF kind of life is that. |
That's what I'm talking about.. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
T-J

Joined: 10 Oct 2008 Location: Seoul EunpyungGu Yeonsinnae
|
Posted: Mon Jul 09, 2012 2:56 am Post subject: |
|
|
| LuckyNomad wrote: |
He always calls me 아파. And almost never uses Daddy. Though he knows the word.
|
He actually calls you 아빠. And I'm not picking on you, but I do want to make a point.
If I didn't speak, read, and write Korean I would not chose to live here long term. I don't mean at a level to survive, order a pizza, or whatever. I mean enough to interact with his friends, his friends parents, and his teachers. Enough to help him with his homework. Enough to be a part of his life outside of our home.
If I couldn't do at least those things I would not chose to live here regardless of how good his English was.
I think those things also make a difference in how he is seen as well. His friends come over to our house, or we take one of his friends out to see a movie and his dad is seen as interacting in the manner and language they expect. It breaks down barriers.
Anyway, interesting thread. Some very good points made.
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Dazed and Confused
Joined: 10 Jan 2003
|
Posted: Mon Jul 09, 2012 6:21 am Post subject: |
|
|
My son is only 10 months old and attending daycare. Since he is adopted he's 100% Korean and it confuses the crap out of Koreans. If we are outside with or without my Korean husband they always point out that he "isn't American looking". To which I reply "NOOOO! REALLY?!" Even his pediatrician made a comment about how he didn't resemble me or his dad.
My son has an English first name, Korean middle name, and of course a Korean surname. The kids at daycare can see me on the monitor when I come to pick him up and I always hear them yell "(Son's name) your mom is here!!!". I find it kind of funny. And, I'm sure they do this to all the other kids when their mom's come.
However, I did get irritated one day. At the daycare there are also a Korean-white mixed race child and a Korean-Chinese mix child. One of the mothers saw me one day and made some snarky comment about this daycare being where all the foreigners come. I was half attempted to tell her to go find another daycare if she didn't like her kid associating with all those foreigners. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Dodge7
Joined: 21 Oct 2011
|
Posted: Mon Jul 09, 2012 9:08 am Post subject: |
|
|
| Dazed and Confused wrote: |
My son is only 10 months old and attending daycare. Since he is adopted he's 100% Korean and it confuses the crap out of Koreans. If we are outside with or without my Korean husband they always point out that he "isn't American looking". To which I reply "NOOOO! REALLY?!" Even his pediatrician made a comment about how he didn't resemble me or his dad.
My son has an English first name, Korean middle name, and of course a Korean surname. The kids at daycare can see me on the monitor when I come to pick him up and I always hear them yell "(Son's name) your mom is here!!!". I find it kind of funny. And, I'm sure they do this to all the other kids when their mom's come.
However, I did get irritated one day. At the daycare there are also a Korean-white mixed race child and a Korean-Chinese mix child. One of the mothers saw me one day and made some snarky comment about this daycare being where all the foreigners come. I was half attempted to tell her to go find another daycare if she didn't like her kid associating with all those foreigners. |
How well can you speak Korean? Maybe you misunderstood her. If you did understand her and she indeed say it in a malicious tone you should have said something. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
LuckyNomad
Joined: 28 May 2007
|
Posted: Mon Jul 09, 2012 3:40 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Dodge7 wrote: |
| Dazed and Confused wrote: |
My son is only 10 months old and attending daycare. Since he is adopted he's 100% Korean and it confuses the crap out of Koreans. If we are outside with or without my Korean husband they always point out that he "isn't American looking". To which I reply "NOOOO! REALLY?!" Even his pediatrician made a comment about how he didn't resemble me or his dad.
My son has an English first name, Korean middle name, and of course a Korean surname. The kids at daycare can see me on the monitor when I come to pick him up and I always hear them yell "(Son's name) your mom is here!!!". I find it kind of funny. And, I'm sure they do this to all the other kids when their mom's come.
However, I did get irritated one day. At the daycare there are also a Korean-white mixed race child and a Korean-Chinese mix child. One of the mothers saw me one day and made some snarky comment about this daycare being where all the foreigners come. I was half attempted to tell her to go find another daycare if she didn't like her kid associating with all those foreigners. |
How well can you speak Korean? Maybe you misunderstood her. If you did understand her and she indeed say it in a malicious tone you should have said something. |
Maybe you misunderstood her because I would think that 99%, no, 100% of Korean mothers would want to send their kids to a school where there are english speaking kids to interact with her kid. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
LuckyNomad
Joined: 28 May 2007
|
Posted: Mon Jul 09, 2012 3:59 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Who's Your Daddy? wrote: |
| v88 wrote: |
| At the play ground kids activily argue about his race and continually comment on it. No one can just play with him because he's a cute kid, it's always because he's a cute foreign kid, a novelty. I sometimes like to ask kids if they are Chinese, at which point most kids just get angry. Works sometimes on older kids. I really hate it when parents just stand and giggle as their kid points and yammers about the foreign kid with the strange hair. People endlessly take pictures of him in public too. Most of it isn't bad, Koreans really just think he's cute. There is a lot of curiosity about mixed kids these days, but I wish they understood that he is not just a novelty. He is my little boy and he'll grow up to be a normal person ... |
To be honest this thread is depressing me, and making me think I have to move my family home. Do you really think your boy will grow up to be normal? This sounds terrible. My son is only 8 months and he's treated this way.
Secondly, I guess, my takeaway from above is it's like fighting the tide here in getting him to properly speak English. I want to actually have in depth conversations with my son later, not ESL-level conversations. And to have your child and mother talking in Korean while you sit there? WTF kind of life is that. |
Don't be depressed. Actually I like bringing my sons out in public. They get a lot of attention, especially from girls. And let me tell you, my first boy loves attention from girls already. So I can imagine if we actually decided to stick around here for his whole life. Afterall, the attention isn't negative. People call him a 외국인, but the only problem that I have with the word is that it is way too broad a category. It includes 7 billion people. I would prefer the term 미국인 as it doesn't actually imply a race. But I think Canadians have lobbied for 외국인 as a more politically correct term for western people in Korea.
My kids have double eyelids, big eyes, high noses, v-line chins, speak english, and have American citizenship. That is exactly what just about every young Korean on this peninsula wants. Right? The difference is that they already have it rather than their mothers having to fly to Saipan to give birth and then going through millions of won worth of english lessons followed by millions more in plastic surgery. Anyhoo, as soon as we move away from here they'll drop back down to being totally unnoticed by anyone, just like me.  |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Who's Your Daddy?
Joined: 30 May 2010 Location: Victoria, Canada.
|
Posted: Mon Jul 09, 2012 4:08 pm Post subject: |
|
|
I've been thinking about it, and I think my family is still better here in Korea. We save so much money here. I will send him to English kindergarten, and if he needs maybe like Grade 4 at a private school or something, or spend one semester in Canada.
I think we'd live okay in Canada, but when it came to retirement, we'd been in poverty basically, and I'd probably be working to 65. The cost of living is so high there, you can't save enough, and you need so much to retire. Here I could possibly retire at 55.
Here we can move to the country and have a pretty nice house. But there we'd have a pretty crap house.
I feel more secure financially in Korea. We'll have to spend money on private education for my son at certain points for him to have good English.
I think I may have to study Korean again, although I'm bored with it and not sure I will. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
sojusucks

Joined: 31 May 2008
|
Posted: Mon Jul 09, 2012 5:25 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| fosterman wrote: |
the kids are now at that age where teasing, and belittling each other is becoming the norm in the classroom,
...
now I am not saying Korean schools are bad, not at all, we had a very positive time here, never any racism or anything like that |
In a previous post, one parent noted that their kindergartener was called foreigner and American. Are you sure that the belittling does not include a little racism, i.e. being called a foreigner as a putdown or American for being bad at math? |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Dazed and Confused
Joined: 10 Jan 2003
|
Posted: Mon Jul 09, 2012 7:01 pm Post subject: |
|
|
[quote="LuckyNomad"][quote="Dodge7"][quote="Dazed and Confused"]My son is only 10 months old and attending daycare. Since he is adopted he's 100% Korean and it confuses the crap out of Koreans. If we are outside with or without my Korean husband they always point out that he "isn't American looking". To which I reply "NOOOO! REALLY?!" Even his pediatrician made a comment about how he didn't resemble me or his dad.
My son has an English first name, Korean middle name, and of course a Korean surname. The kids at daycare can see me on the monitor when I come to pick him up and I always hear them yell "(Son's name) your mom is here!!!". I find it kind of funny. And, I'm sure they do this to all the other kids when their mom's come.
However, I did get irritated one day. At the daycare there are also a Korean-white mixed race child and a Korean-Chinese mix child. [b]One of the mothers saw me one day and made some snarky comment about this daycare being where all the foreigners come. [/b]I was half attempted to tell her to go find another daycare if she didn't like her kid associating with all those foreigners.[/quote]
How well can you speak Korean? Maybe you misunderstood her. If you did understand her and she indeed say it in a malicious tone you should have said something.[/quote]
Maybe you misunderstood her because I would think that 99%, no, 100% of Korean mothers would want to send their kids to a school where there are english speaking kids to interact with her kid.[/quote]
I understand and speak Korean well enough that I understood her perfectly and her tone was quite snarky. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
|
|