Korean Job Discussion Forums

[everything-is-everything]

I was thinking about this scenario the other day and it resulted in more questions than answers.

- Would the Japanese immediately respond?

- Would the Americans respond?

- What about the South Koreans?

I mean considering the sour relations between the Japanese and South Koreans I don't really see the South supporting a retaliation nor would their government allow the Americans to retaliate from South Korean territory.

In fact, I believe many in South Korea would, at least not publicly, applaud the action against Japan.

Furthermore, how would the Japanese respond? They've essentially been neutered since their defeat in WW2. I'm also not sure what kind of response they can muster up.


Basically, if North Korea really wanted to start some s$it this would be an interesting move. Primarily because the response wouldn't be so clear cut and would create divisiveness among the South Koreans, Japanese and Americans.


So what do you posters here think would happen is the North Koreans sent a missile into a Japanese city?

[fermentation]

You are greatly underestimating Japanese military capabilities. The japanese have a much more advanced air force and navy than South Korea. They are more than capable of retaliating. Despite however Koreans think about the japanese, they are technically our allies. Conservatives in particular are more willing to be military partners with them. Regardless I'm sure the Japanese would respond with or without ROK and American support.

That being said, it all depends what an "attack" here means. A long range missile? A single airstrike? An all out invasion?

[12ax7]

North Korea not completely closing Kaesong (and taking nearly a month to actually try to give the impression that they will) is meant to be understood as a sign that they don't want to pick a fight with South Korea.

So, stop worrying.

Oh, and don't freak out if they conduct a missile test in the middle of next week.

[Swampfox10mm]

My Korean coworkers told me they are more scared of Japan than North Korea. Odd, eh?

If NK hit Japan, it would likely cause a push for more armed forces in Japan, which would unnerve basically everyone.... especially China.

[Swampfox10mm]

I will add that many now expect North Korea to shoot another rocker over Japan and toward the USA. In fact, the Obama admin. yesterday laid the groundwork of expectation for that, hoping everyone is calm when it happens.

[12ax7]

[young_clinton]

Lots of luck to North Korea if they ever do. The Japanese can be just like the North Koreans in viciousness, only they're not little midgets from years and years of starving and can actually produce weapons, even atomic weapons that are useful and use them.

Japan could be a potential threat to South Korea if another war breaks out, because of all the years of animosity that South Korea will not let go of.

[everything-is-everything]

[everything-is-everything]

[mithridates]

[ricochet]

Jeju-do has more to worry about than Japan.

[fermentation]

The japanese are certainly more than capable of retaliating, and have plans to do so should they be attacked. The Japanese haven't done any significant militarily since WWII, but they still have a much more advanced airforce and navy than North and South Korea.

I think if the North actually attacks Japan, or any other country, international support would not be on their side.

[silkhighway]

On these hypotheticals, what if N. Korea attacked attacked an American ship in a manner similar to the Cheonan incident? How would America respond? Could N. Korea carry out the attack in such a way that divides South Koreans and Americans and even going a step further, enables the radical left wing in South Korea to help defend N. Korea if it escalated to a full-out war scenario? In other words, creating a true civil war on the peninsula?

Mr. Kim, if you are following Dave's ESL, please don't get any ideas.

[everything-is-everything]

[FMPJ]

http://www.yhchang.com/OPERATION_NUKOREA.html

(enable sound)