|
Korean Job Discussion Forums "The Internet's Meeting Place for ESL/EFL Teachers from Around the World!"
|
| View previous topic :: View next topic |
| Author |
Message |
jaderedux

Joined: 10 Jan 2003 Location: Lurking outside Seoul
|
Posted: Wed Nov 23, 2005 3:02 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| joe_doufu wrote: |
| I try to treat my students like adults. Like customers. It's not my job to mold their behavior, it's my job to deliver English lessons. That's why I don't like to "punish"... who am I to say that their behavior (=being Korean) is right or wrong? I eject them from the classroom if they are preventing me from teaching, not to change their behavior, just to enable myself to teach the cooperative students. |
I can understand that and respect your opinion but I don't agree with that concept. They are not adults. Some students are young adults at the third year level. Some are just babies out of elementary school. They are not ADULTS BY ANY STRETCH and need some nuturing and kindness.
Expectations are outlined at the beginning of the year. You don't sleep, You don't talk when I talk, and if you vandalize my classroom you don't get to have English Class there. It is likened to my home. So respect it as such. In 4 years I have had to ban 1 class from my classroom.
I guess I don't feel like they are my customers...they are my students...and somedays my teacher! I invest emotionally in them and thankfully they do also sometimes. English has become an adventure and not just a class for alot of these students.
All of this came through hard fought battles with myself, my teaching style, constantly updating and changing the type of teacher I am.
I just can't buy into the part of them being adults or customers. Again I respect the opinion and I am sure it works sometimes. But not for me.
This thread has been interesting to see how we all view teaching. Not making judgements here just fascinating to see the diverse views.
Jade |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Yu_Bum_suk

Joined: 25 Dec 2004
|
Posted: Wed Nov 23, 2005 4:45 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| jaderedux wrote: |
| joe_doufu wrote: |
| I try to treat my students like adults. Like customers. It's not my job to mold their behavior, it's my job to deliver English lessons. That's why I don't like to "punish"... who am I to say that their behavior (=being Korean) is right or wrong? I eject them from the classroom if they are preventing me from teaching, not to change their behavior, just to enable myself to teach the cooperative students. |
I can understand that and respect your opinion but I don't agree with that concept. They are not adults. Some students are young adults at the third year level. Some are just babies out of elementary school. They are not ADULTS BY ANY STRETCH and need some nuturing and kindness.
Expectations are outlined at the beginning of the year. You don't sleep, You don't talk when I talk, and if you vandalize my classroom you don't get to have English Class there. It is likened to my home. So respect it as such. In 4 years I have had to ban 1 class from my classroom.
I guess I don't feel like they are my customers...they are my students...and somedays my teacher! I invest emotionally in them and thankfully they do also sometimes. English has become an adventure and not just a class for alot of these students.
All of this came through hard fought battles with myself, my teaching style, constantly updating and changing the type of teacher I am.
I just can't buy into the part of them being adults or customers. Again I respect the opinion and I am sure it works sometimes. But not for me.
This thread has been interesting to see how we all view teaching. Not making judgements here just fascinating to see the diverse views.
Jade |
I have to agree completely. I take whatever their Koran age is, subtract 5, and treat them accordingly. Hence I view my grade 1 HS students as 12-year-olds, my grade 2s as 13-year-olds, and grade 3s as 14. Nice 12-14-year-olds, mind you, but children all the same. 'Treating them like adults' would be the perfect way to make sure that almost no one did any work. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
joe_doufu

Joined: 09 May 2005 Location: Elsewhere
|
Posted: Wed Nov 23, 2005 6:12 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| I'm in a hagwon, not a public school. The parents have more than once made it clear that they don't want me "molding" their student. If they want the child to grow up evil, the child gets to be evil. But if that child disrupts my class (thus wasting the other mothers' money) out he goes. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
ilovebdt

Joined: 03 Jun 2005 Location: Nr Seoul
|
Posted: Wed Nov 23, 2005 6:23 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Yu_Bum_suk wrote: |
| jaderedux wrote: |
| joe_doufu wrote: |
| I try to treat my students like adults. Like customers. It's not my job to mold their behavior, it's my job to deliver English lessons. That's why I don't like to "punish"... who am I to say that their behavior (=being Korean) is right or wrong? I eject them from the classroom if they are preventing me from teaching, not to change their behavior, just to enable myself to teach the cooperative students. |
I can understand that and respect your opinion but I don't agree with that concept. They are not adults. Some students are young adults at the third year level. Some are just babies out of elementary school. They are not ADULTS BY ANY STRETCH and need some nuturing and kindness.
Expectations are outlined at the beginning of the year. You don't sleep, You don't talk when I talk, and if you vandalize my classroom you don't get to have English Class there. It is likened to my home. So respect it as such. In 4 years I have had to ban 1 class from my classroom.
I guess I don't feel like they are my customers...they are my students...and somedays my teacher! I invest emotionally in them and thankfully they do also sometimes. English has become an adventure and not just a class for alot of these students.
All of this came through hard fought battles with myself, my teaching style, constantly updating and changing the type of teacher I am.
I just can't buy into the part of them being adults or customers. Again I respect the opinion and I am sure it works sometimes. But not for me.
This thread has been interesting to see how we all view teaching. Not making judgements here just fascinating to see the diverse views.
Jade |
I have to agree completely. I take whatever their Koran age is, subtract 5, and treat them accordingly. Hence I view my grade 1 HS students as 12-year-olds, my grade 2s as 13-year-olds, and grade 3s as 14. Nice 12-14-year-olds, mind you, but children all the same. 'Treating them like adults' would be the perfect way to make sure that almost no one did any work. |
Ah, I see where I am going wrong now YBS. I relate to my highschoolers as I would if I was teaching High School at home. I.e as young adults. I will employ your thinking methodology now. Cheers mate. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
n3ptne
Joined: 14 Sep 2005 Location: Poh*A*ng City
|
Posted: Wed Nov 23, 2005 7:52 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Mebbe I'm the only one here who acts/thinks this way....but,
I don't treat my students like students, or customers, I treat them as peers... and often superior ones. What I mean by this is very simple, I'm studying Korean, they're studying English. They speak one better than I, and I speak one better than them, so with all due respect to them and their country, I don't pull the "I'm the teacher" BS that I absolutely hated being around for my entire academic career.
Having said this, my kids treat me well, very well... That shouldn't suggest that the job is problem free, or that I don't occassionally feel like throwing a kid out the window, but such incidents are few and far between.
What I do is typically start off every class by saying whatever it is I'm in the process of learning (in Korean) and let them scream at me for a good ten minutes before trying to take control of the class and explain an English concept. Or tell them what food I recently tried, going to a singing room, whatever.
Insofar as discipline is concerned I have but three tactics: Yelling, Sending into the Hall, and Writing, and I use them sparingly (all except for the yelling, which isn't "yelling" in the sense of chastisement, but rather talking very loudly to get their attention... you cant honestly expect children (ones who don't speak English no less) to focus on you, and not talk while your talking for the duration of an hour, however I do *yell* in rare moments.)
Now.. I start off with the *yelling* when someone is pissing me off, typically a rapid fire English rant that I'm sure they won't understand, followed by a sort of demeaning, and this time slow, reexplanation of the rant, mixed with a few "Do you understand"'s, and "Are you sure"'s. The rant usually consists of telling the person they're this close (hold up your fingers) to being kicked out of my class if you keep pulling that shit (hand gestures are key), and even then, I only do it when the shit they're pulling is of an especially distracting kind that disallows other students to learn... or if its so repetitive I can't stand it. What I really love is how the student I'm going off on... is so shocked by being talked to in English so loud and fast, that he almost never understands the jist of the rant (even the second time around, just sits there staring blank eyed), then one of his friends will talk in Korean and tell him what i'm saying... which usually results in a "AWWWWWWW", makes my heart smile.
Now I often times find that when one such student is misbehaving that he begins feedng off rest of the class, and everyone is suddenly more concerned with focusing on what he is going to do, than on what I'm trying to do... Thats when the writing comes in, before I kick him out, I'll tell him to write the word list of whatever chapter we're in 10 times. While writing he isn't allowed to participate in anything we're doing. If he keeps going, he's gone... if the room keeps going after hes gone, they all write 10 times and I get to read. Extra homework is a good way to temper behavior over a long period of time too.
Last resort? I get the director. She yells so loud and makes so many threats that after she goes the kids don't even like to talk if I ask them a question. But I don't get her unless I *absolutely have to*.
I bring in candy for my kids, play with them constantly, rarely give them homework (or if I do I let them do it in class, another favorite is doing a few things in class and then telling them that their homework for the night is what we just completed). All in all, over the course of two months of consistent behavior on my part, my kids have naturally "molded" their behavior quite nicely. Now I like to think they did this because they wanted to, because I'm there friend... might not be the case, but at the very least they're thinking "OK, we have to be with this white man for an hour, he can either be really nice and way cooler to us than all our other teachers, or we can be dicks and have him get pissed". |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
ddeubel

Joined: 20 Jul 2005
|
Posted: Wed Nov 23, 2005 8:44 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Quote: |
| This thread has been interesting to see how we all view teaching. Not making judgements here just fascinating to see the diverse views. |
SCARY. Very scary...........................
But Jaderedux, I liked your post except for the previous one . Where you state....
| Quote: |
| They are wastoids and like it or not, not every kid is a delicate little blossom waiting for your ray of sunshine to bless them |
Sorry, not the attitude I believe a teacher should have. Maybe a bad day? But I don't think so. But all the other posts about being a mean SOB, carrying a stick, yelling, getting kids to hold chairs over their heads.........this is all about power , a power trip. Why kids grow up to kill others.
n3ptne --- take your egalitarian, I teach peers back to the cultural revolution or north. Do peers "yell" in rapid fire at peers? who are you fooling? Yourself.
I think the proper teaching attitude should be patient humility --- in particular, that we are there for the least. I am most proud after many many years of teaching, most proud of the few kids at the bottom who I made to be good people......curriculum is just a means of achieving that end. Punishment as I've read on here, a means of destroying that....
DD
"When one teaches, two learn." |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Yu_Bum_suk

Joined: 25 Dec 2004
|
Posted: Wed Nov 23, 2005 8:57 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| ddeubel wrote: |
| Quote: |
| This thread has been interesting to see how we all view teaching. Not making judgements here just fascinating to see the diverse views. |
SCARY. Very scary...........................
But Jaderedux, I liked your post except for the previous one . Where you state....
| Quote: |
| They are wastoids and like it or not, not every kid is a delicate little blossom waiting for your ray of sunshine to bless them |
Sorry, not the attitude I believe a teacher should have. Maybe a bad day? But I don't think so. But all the other posts about being a mean SOB, carrying a stick, yelling, getting kids to hold chairs over their heads.........this is all about power , a power trip. Why kids grow up to kill others.
n3ptne --- take your egalitarian, I teach peers back to the cultural revolution or north. Do peers "yell" in rapid fire at peers? who are you fooling? Yourself.
|
When used sparingly, as they seem to be at my school, those methods seem to work pretty well, and I don't see too many of my students turning out as killers.
As for the peer thing - today I told off a student for listening to an MP3 player (it was at the end of the lesson when we were playing a game so maybe she thought it was all right) and she got a bunch of disgusted looks from the rest of the class and the girl behind her smacked her one. Now that's the kind of classroom peer pressure I can live with! Am I their peer? It would never happen, especially when I'm the first foreign teacher most of them have ever had. It's obvious n3ptne isn't either. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
n3ptne
Joined: 14 Sep 2005 Location: Poh*A*ng City
|
Posted: Wed Nov 23, 2005 8:58 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Yes, peers do teach by yelling... thats how the kids teach me... they scream. And I teach by the philosophies of "by any means necessary" and "there is no such thing as a bad kid". I'm going to teach them, and I'm not going to allow one to prevent others from learning. Discipline is a must when in a classroom environment, but I don't consider them "students" in an intellectually inferior fashion.. they're peers, child peers, but this concept is moot. They must be forgiven for most, if not all, of the infractions they commit... because they're kids. Thats what they do, you can't expect them not to be.
I haven't pronounced one a bad apple yet, but am this close to doing so. Now I just kick him out of the class in the first fifteen minutes, and he's no longer an issue. I don't get the director, I don't care if he gets in trouble, stands in the hall, goes home early, just so long as he isn't in the room bothering me. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
|
|