|
Korean Job Discussion Forums "The Internet's Meeting Place for ESL/EFL Teachers from Around the World!"
|
| View previous topic :: View next topic |
| Author |
Message |
JeJuJitsu

Joined: 11 Sep 2005 Location: McDonald's
|
Posted: Sun Feb 26, 2006 10:32 am Post subject: |
|
|
Smoked a spliff with Perry in Budapest many years ago...ah, the days...
anyway, even though he makes like 5 albums a year, my essential Lee Perry to a newbie would be something like:
Time Boom - De Devil Dead (w/ Dub Syndicate)
SuperApe (w/ The Upsetters & Greatest album cover of all time)
From The Secret Laboratory (lotsa old schoolers don't like this one, but i think it's mostly brilliant)
Kung Fu Meets The Dragon
Roast Fish Collie Weed & Corn Bread
Black Ark in Dub
I prefer the heavy dub though, so I could listen to the bass lines and Perry screeetching all day...whereas lots of his 80's stuff is rather normal (for scratch) raggae fare... |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
RACETRAITOR
Joined: 24 Oct 2005 Location: Seoul, South Korea
|
Posted: Sun Feb 26, 2006 5:35 pm Post subject: |
|
|
No, actually Korea is pretty far behind. Generally reggae and ska are connected with the growth of punk music, but in Korea it's been largely ignored. I think if you're just talking about stoner dub reggae, it's a bit rarer.
Japan - Yeah, obviously. They have everything there.
China - There are just more people in touch with reggae and ska there. The two main skinhead bands in Beijing are both very traditionally influenced. I'd say they're not very far ahead of us, but Beijing's underground scene is the fastest growing on the continent. They've had two ska bands, both of them filled with foreigners.
Malaysia - They have a huge skinhead/ska/rocksteady/reggae scene. The best recommendation is Gerhana Ska Cinta. Indonesia and Singapore are pretty similar too.
The Philippines - I don't know anything about it there either but every Filipino person I talk to generally knows more than just the basics of reggae.
Whatever they have for reggae and ska in Thailand, Hong Kong, Taiwan, Nepal, or Vietnam, I don't really know.
My personal taste is the older stuff, skinhead reggae done by the likes of Derrick Morgan and Clancy Eccles and so on. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Satori

Joined: 09 Dec 2005 Location: Above it all
|
Posted: Sun Feb 26, 2006 9:50 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| RACETRAITOR wrote: |
| Generally reggae and ska are connected with the growth of punk music |
Rubbish. The so called "reggae" you`re talking about is rough, stiff, and tragically white, and has no business even appropriating the term reggae. Reggae means roots reggae, Jamaican style. Proper reggae can and does flourish in places where there is no punk scene at all. Pull another one out your fundamental canal... |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
RACETRAITOR
Joined: 24 Oct 2005 Location: Seoul, South Korea
|
Posted: Sun Feb 26, 2006 10:49 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Satori wrote: |
Rubbish. The so called "reggae" you`re talking about is rough, stiff, and tragically white, and has no business even appropriating the term reggae. Reggae means roots reggae, Jamaican style. Proper reggae can and does flourish in places where there is no punk scene at all. Pull another one out your fundamental canal... |
Roots reggae is an odd name, considering it was not the first stage of reggae. It was a mid-'70s phase that was influenced by Rastafarianism and more concerned with Jamaican identity than earlier reggae and ska. To be honest, I think most modern reggae going back to the '80s doesn't have any right appropriating the term "reggae." It's simply grown into something else.
Reggae has gone through a lot of various phases. What you refer to as dub reggae was made popular in the mid-to-late '70s in England by the punk movement there. When I talk about punky reggae, I mean the likes of Mikey Dread and Big Youth. They were not rough or stiff or tragically white.
The most traditional Jamaican sound is bluebeat ska, which is what Kingston Rudy Ska mimics. Reggae has changed a lot, and if you have a question about the genre's history, you're as well off asking a skinhead as you are an average Jamaican. The best music may come from Jamaicans, but it was championed by people in other countries. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Satori

Joined: 09 Dec 2005 Location: Above it all
|
Posted: Mon Feb 27, 2006 5:02 am Post subject: |
|
|
| RACETRAITOR wrote: |
Roots reggae is an odd name, considering it was not the first stage of reggae. It was a mid-'70s phase that was influenced by Rastafarianism and more concerned with Jamaican identity than earlier reggae and ska. |
Incorrect. The term roots reggae was not used until reggae began to modernise and move away from the traditional sound, that is when roots reggae was coined to distinguish between traditional reggae ( the seventies sound ) and Dub and electronic based reggae.
| Quote: |
To be honest, I think most modern reggae going back to the '80s doesn't have any right appropriating the term "reggae." It's simply grown into something else. |
Agreed. Ska is ska, its not reggae. And most white people who play ska should simply not bother in my opinion. Madness and the Specials are the only worthy groups. Punky ska and the whole Sublime school is one of the musical aberations of the earth.
| Quote: |
Reggae has gone through a lot of various phases. What you refer to as dub reggae was made popular in the mid-to-late '70s in England by the punk movement there. |
I think you`re confused. Dub is the atmospheric reggae offshoot characterised by big delays and lots of effects being applied live. Big players being Scratch Perry, King Tubby, Mad Professor. Dub was not made popular by punks.
| Quote: |
When I talk about punky reggae, I mean the likes of Mikey Dread and Big Youth. They were not rough or stiff or tragically white. |
I dont call that reggae at all.
| Quote: |
The most traditional Jamaican sound is bluebeat ska, which is what Kingston Rudy Ska mimics. |
So call it ska, dont call it reggae
| Quote: |
Reggae has changed a lot, and if you have a question about the genre's history, you're as well off asking a skinhead as you are an average Jamaican. |
Twaddle. Tell that to the fans of Steven Marleys new albumn that is blowing up big time in Jamaica now. Tell that to fans of burning Spear. How do YOU know how much Jamaicans know about reggae history?
You don`t seem to know your terms so well, and seem a bit confused on parts of the history. If I were you Id try to get my facts a bit more straight before coming off as Mr Reggae... |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
RACETRAITOR
Joined: 24 Oct 2005 Location: Seoul, South Korea
|
Posted: Mon Feb 27, 2006 5:50 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Reggae is a big thing with a large catalogue. I like older reggae and you like newer reggae. There is a strong connection between ska and reggae because ska is the roots of reggae.
Ska-punk is neither ska nor punk. Bands like Goldfinger and No Doubt and Sublime and Reel Big Fish were a serious aberration; on that we agree. Madness and the Specials were two-tone, not ska-punk. What I'm talking about is music like the Slackers, Hepcat, and the Aggrolites. They play music that respects the roots of ska and reggae.
Roots reggae was the era after skinhead reggae. If you look at all the old skinhead reggae bands, a lot of them grew their hair out into dreadlocks in the early '70s and started getting into Rastafarianism and playing roots. One of my favourites is Junior Byles, who sang in the Versatiles in the late '60s and then later Rasta-ised. Skinhead reggae is definitely less Jamaica-focused than roots reggae. But it did come first, roughly between 1967 and 1971. And for the most part it was the same group of singers, just most of them matured a bit for roots reggae. Both terms were applied after the fact.
| Quote: |
| Quote: |
When I talk about punky reggae, I mean the likes of Mikey Dread and Big Youth. They were not rough or stiff or tragically white. |
I dont call that reggae at all.
|
You don't know who Mikey Dread and Big Youth are? You're seriously missing out. How about I-Roy, Dennis Alcapone, U-Roy, or Scotty?
I'll leave you with a picture of an early ska band, the Wailing Rudeboys, featuring Peter MackinTOSH, Robert Marley, and Neville Livingstone.
Just because I'm a nice guy, here's some reggae you can download:
- Dub
Big Youth + Augustus Pablo + Crystalites - Silhouettes Version
http://www.canadianskins.com/mp3//Big%20Youth%20Augustus%20Pablo%20Crystalites%20-%20Bass%20and%20Drum%20Version.wma
- Skinhead reggae
Laurel Aitken - Skinhead
http://www.canadianskins.com/mp3//laurel%20aitken%20&%20hor%2007%20-%20skinhead.mp3
Derrick Morgan - The Conqueror
http://www.canadianskins.com/mp3//Derrick%20Morgan%20-%20Conquering%20Ruler.mp3
EK Bunch - Banana
http://www.canadianskins.com/mp3//EK%20Bunch%20-%20Banana.mp3
Rudy Mills - John Jones
http://www.canadianskins.com/mp3//Rudy%20Mills%20-%20John%20Jones.mp3
Judge Dread + Dr Ring Ding - Big 7
http://www.canadianskins.com/mp3//Judge%20Dread%20and%20Dr%20Ring%20Ding%20-%20Big%20Seven.wma
Desmond Reily
http://www.canadianskins.com/mp3//desmond%20reily%20-%20tear%20them.mp3
Hot Rod All-Stars - Ten Commandments from the Devil
http://www.canadianskins.com/mp3//Hot%20Rod%20All-Stars%20-%20Ten%20commandments%20from%20the%20Devil.mp3
Seven Letters
http://www.canadianskins.com/mp3//seven%20letters%20-%20bam%20bam%20baji.mp3
Dandy Livingstone
http://www.canadianskins.com/mp3//dandy%20livingstone%20-%20REGGAE%20IN%20YOUR%20JEGGAE.mp3
Ethiopians - Engine 54
http://www.canadianskins.com/mp3//ethiopians%20-%20Engine54.mp3
- Punky reggae
Mikey Dread - Barber Saloon
http://www.canadianskins.com/mp3//Mikey%20Dread%20-%20Barber%20Saloon.mp3
You can't tell me that's not reggae.
- Bluebeat ska
Bob Marley and the Wailers - Hooligans
http://www.canadianskins.com/mp3//Wailers%20-%20Hooligan.mp3
- Modern traditional ska (not ska-punk)
Chris Murray - Janie Jones
http://www.canadianskins.com/mp3//Chris%20Murray%20-%20JANIE%20Jones.mp3
Operators - One Day
http://www.canadianskins.com/mp3//Operators%20-%201%20Day.wma
Slackers - Rude & Reckless
http://www.canadianskins.com/mp3//Slackers%20-%20Rude%20And%20Reckless.mp3
Radiation Kings - Murder
http://www.canadianskins.com/mp3//radiation%20kings%20-%20Murder.mp3
- Two tone
Bad Manners - Big Five
http://www.canadianskins.com/mp3//Bad%20Manners%20-%20big%20five.mp3
- German Dancehall
Dr Ring Ding - Rukumbine Mark II
http://www.canadianskins.com/mp3//Dr%20Ring%20Ding%20-%20Ruckumbine%20Mk%20II.wma |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Satori

Joined: 09 Dec 2005 Location: Above it all
|
Posted: Mon Feb 27, 2006 9:18 pm Post subject: |
|
|
I`ll try some of those links, but not all of them thanks. And I`m well aware that the core wailers were first playing ska and blue beat.
Of course ska came before reggae, it is the roots. But don`t call ska reggae. A major major shift happened in the music, and they are quite distinct forms. Reggae slowed down, got the distinctive "one drop" kick drum pattern, and the expanded basslines with lots of pauses. It is this "space" in the music of reggae that makes it so much more sophisticated and rhythmically complex for me. Reggae got soul. Reggae has the "skank" that I need. Ska to me sounds musically teenaged, hyper, and unsohpisticated. And I don`t like the culture surrounding it either. Reggae has a much more complex rhythmic interplay between the drums, bass, and guitar. It`s more europhic, conscious, and pot oriented. UK ska is more associated with whizz, alcohol, and has undertones of violence, and low culture. Roots reggae is conscious political "uplift" music, and is just more musically absorbing to me.
My pick for you, though I can`t link an mp3, is a New Zealand group called "Fat Freddies Drop" whose albumn "Based on a true story" is a vibrant blend of roots reggae, soul, jazz, funk, and RnB, both modern and trad at the same time. Very very classy and understated. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
RACETRAITOR
Joined: 24 Oct 2005 Location: Seoul, South Korea
|
Posted: Mon Feb 27, 2006 9:49 pm Post subject: |
|
|
I'll give a look for that band, thanks.
What I like in early reggae and ska is that hooligan aspect, the drinking and singing along with your friends atmosphere. More important is a stable dance beat. You can't dance to Augustus Pablo. Also, lyrics about going back to Africa and King Selassie don't really do it for me as much as "The Ten Commandments from the Devil." I also don't like a lot of bluebeat because it is unsophisticated and sounds more like early R&B.
It annoys me when people say that there is no link between ska and reggae. I think the name of ska was smeared too much by ska-punk. Too many people just assume reggae is black and ska is white. Race is important only in roots reggae. You said it: the only difference between ska and reggae is that little bit of the rhythm. I have to agree with you that the music is less mature--definitely--but I like that about it.
I also enjoy the really complex stuff like that Mikey Dread song I threw up there; don't skip that one. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
|
|