Korean Job Discussion Forums

[jtpe]

I'm not sure, but I think this statement is grammatically correct.
"If someone is shy and timid, you can say that THEY are are a mouse."
I would say, "If someone is shy and timid, you can that HE or SHE is a mouse."

Is the 1st one correct?? If so could you explain???

Thanks!!!!!

[Ramen]

[branchsnapper]

Yes, it is correct, in that people speak and write that way all the time. Pedantic grammarians sometimes insist on other constructions, but they are fighting a losing battle on that point.

[jtpe]

ramen: Thanks for pointing that out.

branchsnapper: Thanks for the quick reply!!! Much appreciated.

[jadarite]

I wonder which gender these pedantic grammarians would make the "someone". I use "they" because "someone" could be male or female, you can't tell which gender THEY are.

If we must stick to singular usage, then I would say, "If someone is shy and timid, you can [say] that person is a mouse."

[Tobias]

"He or she" is the correct subject, but I think "they" is becoming more acceptable. Sometimes being correct is annoying.