Dave's ESL Cafe's Student Discussion Forums

[jasonlulu_2000]

�Poor but honest.� �The deserving poor.� These words always come to my mind when I think of �the poor.� But I also think of people who, perhaps through alcohol or drugs, have ruined not only their own lives but also the lives of others in order to give way to their own pleasure. Perhaps alcoholism and drug addiction really are �diseases,� as many people say, but my own feeling --- based. Of course, not on any serious study --- is that most alcoholics and drug addicts belong to the �undeserving poor.� And that is largely why I don�t give spare change to beggars.
But surely among the street people there are also some who can rightly be called �deserving.� Deserving what? My spare change? Or simply the government�s assistance? It happens that I have been brought up to believe that it is proper to make contributions to charity ,but if I give some change to a beggar, am I making a contribution to charity and thereby helping someone, or, am I perhaps simply encouraging someone not to get help? Or, maybe even worse, am I supporting a cheat?
If one believes in the value of private charity, one can either give to needy people or to charitable organizations. In giving to a beggar one may indeed be helping a person who badly needs help, but one cannot be certain that one is giving to a needy person. In giving to an organization, on the other hand, one can feel that one�s money is likely to be used wisely. True, facing a beggar one may feel that this particular unfortunate person needs help at this moment --- a cup of coffee or a sandwich --- and the need will not be met unless I put my hand in my pocket right now. But I have come to think that the beggars whom I meet can get along without my spare change, and indeed perhaps they are actually better off for not having money to buy alcohol or drugs.
I know nothing about these beggars, but it�s my impression that they simply prefer begging to working. I am not generalizing about street people. I am talking about the about whom I acturally meet. That�s why I do not give �spare change,� and I don�t think I will in the future.

The above reading comes from a exam in my city. One of the multiple choices comes from the reading, which I was at a loss which to choose.

Which of the following opinions does the author accept?
A. Drug addiction is a disease.
B. Some street people are poor and needy.
C. Most beggars have received enough help.
D. Charitable organizations handle money properly.

In my opinion. both B and D are acceptable. Could any native speaker throw some light upon it after reading the text?

Thanks a million.

Jason

[asterix]

Yes, I agree with you that B. and D. are supported by the text.
In D. it says they handle money properly which is not necessarily the same as wisely but I don't think they are trying to trick you.