Dave's ESL Cafe's Student Discussion Forums

[jasonlulu_2000]

I am going to London. Do you have anything ______?
A. to buy b. to be bought

Could any native tell me which one is more appropriate from the grammatical perspective?

There is a similar question:
I am going to London. Do you have anything _______?
A. to take b. to be taken
The answer given is B.

I think the same rule goes for both the questions. Am I right? Or is there any difference between them?


Many thanks for consideration.

Jason

[eddfx]

You have to love test questions.

These sentence structures are not used by native speakers when we speak. It is obvious these test questions are made by a non-native speaker and used to test you on tenses.

The answer I give is for you to answer your test questions correctly so you can pass your test, but they are not correct in spoken English for they sound clunky and "non-native" to me.

I am going to London. Do you have anything to buy?

This is a strange sentence because the speaker was originally talking about himself going to London then they switch topics without a smooth transition.

These are just sample sentances and only used for examples on how I would personally say them.

I am going to London. Is there anything you want me to buy (for you)?
I am going to London. Is there anything you want bought?

I am going to London. Do you have anything to take?

Again this is a strange sentence because the speaker was originally talking about themselves going to London then they switch topics without a smooth transition.

It sounds better to me to say:

We are leaving for London; do you have anything to take?

These are just my examples. I am really interested in hearing other native English speakers answers as well.

[CP]

I agree with eddfx: These are unnatural constructions made up for test purposes only.

I am going to London. Do you have anything ______?
A. to buy b. to be bought
--A native speaker would say: I am going to London. Do you need anything from there? / Would you like me to get you anything?

I am going to London. Do you have anything _______?
A. to take b. to be taken
--A native speaker would say: I am going to London. Do you have anything to take there / to send there / for me to take there for you?
_________________
You live a new life for every new language you speak. -Czech proverb