Dave's ESL Cafe's Student Discussion Forums

ltp-008 · Joined: 09 Apr 2006 Posts: 258

What are dictators afraid of ?

China is No.one nation in the world which has brought up countless dictators, according to some Chinese historians there were about 560 emperors throughout 4,000 years' Chinese history.

What are the dictators afraid of ? Maybe this is a funny question, as a dictator or an emperor in China they had limitless power over their people, they owned the nation, and they could kill their people at will and they regarded their people as rubbish and slaves. They could have hundreds and even thousands of wives companied with thousands of eunuches castrated.Their ministers had kowtowed to these emperors when they met these Chinese dictators.

There once was a king in ancient Rome who admired Chinese emperors and he wanted to order his ministers to kowtow to him when they met him, the result was that he was assassinated soon after.Westerners has the tradition of equality and freedom, they think that you could lead us but you couldn't insult us.

Now you may know the reason why China is No.one nation which has fostered countless dictators, the reality is that not only did China bring up dictators but also extol dictators, even these dictators were invaders and conquers of China, and even they killed countless Chinese. The main reason why the Chinese extol these dictators is that these dictators became the Chinese emperors and also made their offsprings succeed to emperors . Isn't it funny?

There was an emperor called Zhudi in Ming dynasty four hundreds years ago , after he killed ten of thousands of people and ousted his nephew- then an emperor in China and became a new Chinese emperor, he began to fake Chinese history, in the historical textbook in Ming dynasty there was one emperor unwritten who was ousted by Zhudi. What was he afraid of ? The fact was that he was afraid of truth, he was afraid of the people who knew that he ousted his nephew, he wanted to make Chinese consider him as a legitimated emperor. Just like the story of the " New Costume of Emperor", you can't see the costume however you have to cheer with other people together and say that this un-existed costume is so beautiful, this is a lasting Chinese tradition in which Chinese dictators have forced Chinese to form for very long. China doesn't have prosperous and harmonious society but the dictators or the rulers of China say that China has, then the ordinary Chinese people have to follow the dictators to say the " New costume of Emperor", if not then these dictators will accuse these people of not being patriotism.

Back three hundreds years ago Chinese emperors in Qing dynasty finally found effective ways to fake history, they found literary Inquisition or " Imprisonment due to Writings " which made any writtings that were not favorable to Chinese emperors disappear and put these writers in prisons. This Literary Inquisition had made Chinese say " New costume of emperor" for two hundreds years. How happy the Chinese were?!

However at the same time when China was in Literary Inquisition, in 1789 French gave birth to the " Declaration of Human Rights" which claimed that every human being was created equally , since then China began to drop behind the Western.

In modern China from the time of the ruling of Nationalist party in mainland China before 1949 to the time of ruling of communist party after 1949 the Literary Inquisition or "Imprisonment due to Writtings" has become more and more practical and brutal , millions of Chinese people were put into prisons due to their writtings or speeches, many of them even were killed respectively by the Chinese Nationalsit government and communist government.

However on September of 2006 Taiwan of south China happened a significant historical event which was that millions of Taiwanese led by Shimingde had peacefully protested against Taiwanese president Chensuibian for more than one month around president palace.This event surprised the world and shocked the whole China. Shimingde and Chensuibian both were put into prisons for Literary Inquisition before Taiwan became democracy, after 20 years they became opponents , however they both share the common values which are that people have the rights to oppose against their governments and people have the rights to freely express their own views . These common values shared by them were the lessons which they learned throughout their lives in prisons, this is a great treasure for all Chinese.

Now perhaps you knew what the dictators are afraid of , they are afraid of equality, freedom and democracy. In order to maintain their dictatorship ruling these dictators and totalitarian regimes in the world will try their best to supress their people, limit and block the free flow of information, they clearly knew that if they are not doing so they will lose their powers immediately. However people love equality, freedom and democracy in nature, no matter how these dictators and totalitarian regimes exhaust any means to supress their people, freedom and democracy will prevail in these dictatorship countries in the near future, the evolution of civilization in the world can't be stopped by these dictators.

asterix · Joined: 26 Jan 2003 Posts: 1654

I found this an interesting piece.
I agree with you that all dictators are afraid of truth.
Unfortunately, all governments, even democratic ones, are guilty of manipulating the truth.
The difference is that dictatorships will kill you for telling the truth about them, whereas the democratic governments will deny it until they are blue in the face.
It's all very much like George Orwell's classic 1984, in fact.

beancurdturtle · Posted: Mon Apr 16, 2007 1:14 pm Post subject:

I think your conclusion is interesting and quite correct.

And asterix has valid comments as well.

When there is a lack of parity and denial of rights and truth, eventually there is some kind of revolution. This happens both under dictatorships and democracies.

One major difference is that in totalitarian regimes the human cost of revolution is typically much higher than in democracies.

I think reform is best accomplished (least human cost) at a moderate pace. So I hope market and society reforms continue, and everyone will eventually benefit from the increased prosperity in China.
_________________
Daniel

�Be who you are and say what you feel because those who mind don't matter and those who matter don't mind.�
--Dr. Seuss

ltp-008 · Joined: 09 Apr 2006 Posts: 258

ltp-008 · Joined: 09 Apr 2006 Posts: 258

beancurdturtle · Posted: Mon Apr 16, 2007 7:50 pm Post subject:

misuvija · Joined: 07 Feb 2007 Posts: 27

Hi, for thousand years in China the governments were a dynasty. They represent the Chinese culture and Chinese history. This situation is similar in others countries around the world. You talk concerning the dictators afraid about equality, freedom and democracy. I do not believe that, I�m totally disagree with that ideas, I believe the totalitarian regimes are sustain in the fear of the people, unyielding rules and very powerfully army. What do you think about my position?

ltp-008 · Joined: 09 Apr 2006 Posts: 258

ltp-008 · Joined: 09 Apr 2006 Posts: 258